Subway Menu - New Buffalo, MI

Your local New Buffalo Subway® Restaurant, located at 207A N Whittaker St brings new bold flavors along with old favorites to satisfied guests every day. We deliver these mouth-watering flavors with our famous Footlongs, 6” sandwiches, wraps and salads. And we offer a variety of ways to order—quick and easy in the app or online, convenient delivery, come into your neighborhood shop for an in-restaurant meal, or pick up curbside. We’re proud to offer a change from same old fast food with fresh cut veggies and toppings with protein choices, fresh-baked bread and let’s not forget cookies! And we’re happy to help you with any catering needs as well.

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options. Based on 79 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $

Subway 49117

Address:
207A N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117

Phone: (269) 469-5055

Website: https://restaurants.subway.com/united-states/mi/new-buffalo/207a-n-whittaker-st?utm_source=yxt-goog&utm_medium=local&utm_term=acq&utm_content=12466&utm_campaign=evergreen-2020&y_source=1_MTUyOTk0MTUtNzE1LWxvY2F0aW9uLndlYnNpdGU%3D

Drinks
Honest Kids® Super Fruit Punch Grape, strawberry, apple, watermelon juices and other ingredients unite to truly pack a punch. USDA organic certified. Sweetened only with fruit juice. No added sugar. No artificial sweeteners. No high fructose corn syrup. Gluten free. No GMOs.
Dasani® Water As delicious as our sandwiches are, they are even better when paired with the perfect side and drink or even adding a little something extra. With such a variety to choose from, there’s truly something for every taste.
Coca-Cola® Classic Crisp, refreshing, original taste.
1% Low Fat Milk As delicious as our sandwiches are, they are even better when paired with the perfect side and drink or even adding a little something extra. With such a variety to choose from, there’s truly something for every taste.
Sides
LAY’S® Classic It all starts with farm-grown potatoes, cooked and seasoned to perfection. So every LAY’S® potato chip is perfectly crispy and full of fresh potato taste. Happiness in Every Bite.®
DORITOS® Nacho Cheese The iconic bold and intense cheesiness of Doritos® Nacho Cheese Flavored Tortilla Chips. Doritos® flavors ignite adventure and inspire action. Are you ready? If so, crunch on.
White Chip Macadamia Nut Our delectable White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie is anything but cookie cutter. That’s because it has a generous amount of tasty ingredients: white chips, macadamia nuts, vanilla and other natural flavors mixed together to prepare a delightfully ri…
Oatmeal Raisin Our Oatmeal Raisin Cookie is perfectly soft and chewy making it a must have with your order. Rolled oats, molasses, real California Raisins and just the right touch of cinnamon—all mixed and baked for the perfect treat any time of the day, includi…
Baked Lay’s® Original SNACK A LITTLE SMARTER™️ with Baked LAY’S®️ Potato Chips. It’s the LAY’S®️ chip you love, just Baked. Perfectly paired with your favorite Subway sandwich.
SunChips® Harvest Cheddar® The flavor of real cheddar cheese is layered onto a delicious whole grain chip to create this tasty combination.
GoGo SqueeZ® Apple Apple GoGo squeeZ® applesauce pouches are a yummy, nutritious snack made from 100% fruit, no sugar added* and no artificial anything. With a resealable cap, GoGo squeeZ® fruit on the go can be enjoyed wherever life takes you. *Not a Low Calorie Food. C…
Raspberry Cheesecake Hold the silverware, because our Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie is a hands-on experience. Sweet raspberry flavored pieces, white chips and just the right amount of cream cheese are mixed together to bake the perfect cookie. So go ahead, dive right in…
Chocolate Chip One bite of our Chocolate Chip Cookie and you may just find the sudden urge to order 2, 3… maybe 6. It has semi-sweet chocolate chips, vanilla and other natural flavors folded into buttery cookie dough. It’s waiting to be devoured, just don’t say …
Cookies Every meal deserves a dessert, because simply put, they just belong together. So, when you’re ordering your favorite sandwich, just remember that it pairs perfectly with one of our delectable cookies. They’re freshly baked, come in a variety of fl…
Fountain Drinks
Fountain Beverage
Chips
LAY’S® Classic It all starts with farm-grown potatoes, cooked and seasoned to perfection. So every LAY’S® potato chip is perfectly crispy and full of fresh potato taste. Happiness in Every Bite.®
DORITOS® Nacho Cheese The iconic bold and intense cheesiness of Doritos® Nacho Cheese Flavored Tortilla Chips. Doritos® flavors ignite adventure and inspire action. Are you ready? If so, crunch on.
Baked Lay’s® Original SNACK A LITTLE SMARTER™️ with Baked LAY’S®️ Potato Chips. It’s the LAY’S®️ chip you love, just Baked. Perfectly paired with your favorite Subway sandwich.
SunChips® Harvest Cheddar® The flavor of real cheddar cheese is layered onto a delicious whole grain chip to create this tasty combination.
Kids’ Sides
GoGo SqueeZ® Apple Apple GoGo squeeZ® applesauce pouches are a yummy, nutritious snack made from 100% fruit, no sugar added* and no artificial anything. With a resealable cap, GoGo squeeZ® fruit on the go can be enjoyed wherever life takes you. *Not a Low Calorie Food. C…
Wraps
Black Forest Ham The Black Forest Ham wrap is packed with a double portion of ham, lettuce, spinach, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers and red onions. Definitely delish.
Pizza Sub Hot outta the oven, it’s the Pizza Sub wrap. Enjoy spicy pepperoni, piled high and layered with melt-a-licious American cheese and our signature marinara sauce. Topped with green peppers and red onions in a wrap.
Buffalo Chicken A wrap that’s not afraid to be bold. We start with a Footlong portion of grilled chicken, adding just the right amount of Frank’s RedHot® Buffalo sauce. Then we cut the heat with crisp lettuce, tomatoes and cucumbers, and roll it all up in a wrap….
Meatball Marinara Our Meatball Marinara wrap is a double portion of Italian-style meatballs in irresistible marinara sauce, with Parmesan cheese, in a wrap. Get yourself one.
Oven Roasted Turkey & Ham Take a bite of this wrap filled with a footlong portion of our tender, thin-sliced oven roasted turkey and tasty Black Forest ham. Top it with lettuce, spinach, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers and red onions. It’s simply delicious.
Oven Roasted Turkey Our Oven Roasted Turkey Wrap is a go-to. It’s a footlong portion of our premium, thin-sliced, oven roasted turkey, with fresh veggies like lettuce, tomatoes, spinach, cucumbers, green peppers and red onions, all served up in a wrap.
Tuna Our tasty Tuna Wrap is completely cravable. It has a double serving of 100% wild caught tuna mixed with mayo in a wrap. Then it gets topped with any crunchy veggies you want.
B.L.T Simply delicious! This classic on a wrap, is filled with a double portion of our crispy hickory smoked bacon and finished off with lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and mayo.
Veggie Delite® The Veggie Delite® wrap has a double portion of the fresh veggies you love. All wrapped in a flavorful wrap with lettuce, tomatoes, spinach, green peppers, cucumbers, and red onions. It’s one bold, crunchy flavor combo.
Spicy Italian Feeling spicy? Grab a Spicy Italian wrap. It’s a double portion of spicy pepperoni and Genoa salami. Topped with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers and red onions…it’s a pretty delicious meal.
Cold Cut Combo® Can’t decide what kind of meat you want? Get three at once on a delicious wrap. Stacked with a double portion of turkey-based meats including ham, salami, and bologna. Enjoy it with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, and red onions.
Steak & Cheese Our Steak & Cheese wrap is a double portion of shaved steak, wrapped up with melty American cheese. Get crazy with veggies and sauces to make it what you want.
Italian B.M.T. ® The Italian B.M.T.® tastes great on a wrap. It’s filled with a double portion of Genoa salami, spicy pepperoni, and Black Forest ham topped with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, and red onions. So tasty.
Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki Packed with flavor and texture, the sweet and tangy Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki wrap cannot be kept under wraps. Dig into a classic combination of juicy chicken strips marinated in our Sweet Onion Teriyaki sauce, with lettuce, spinach, tomatoes, …
Cookies
Cookies Every meal deserves a dessert, because simply put, they just belong together. So, when you’re ordering your favorite sandwich, just remember that it pairs perfectly with one of our delectable cookies. They’re freshly baked, come in a variety of fl…
Salads
Italian B.M.T. ® The Italian B.M.T. ® salad is the salad version of our popular sub. Crisp greens topped with Genoa salami, spicy pepperoni, and Black Forest ham. Meaty deliciousness, all in a salad.
B.L.T Savory hickory smoked bacon. Crisp lettuce. Ripe tomatoes. All mixed with Spinach, crunchy cucumbers, sweet green peppers, black olives, and zesty red onions.
Tuna Our Tuna salad is simply delish. 100% wild caught tuna mixed with mayo, riding high on top of a bed of crisp lettuce and veggies. Classic for a reason.
Oven Roasted Turkey & Ham Thin-sliced oven roasted turkey and Black Forest ham with crisp lettuce, tender spinach and many more of your favorite veggies.
Meatball Marinara The Meatball Marinara salad is the ultimate cravings crusher. Hot Italian-style meatballs in marinara sauce and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese, all sitting on top of your favorite greens and veggies. Yes!
Black Forest Ham The Black Forest Ham salad is a flavorful way to enjoy a Subway® favorite. Sliced ham, lettuce, and a pile of your favorite veggies – all tossed with your choice of dressing.
Oven Roasted Turkey The Oven Roasted Turkey Salad is a go-to salad choice. Our premium, thin-sliced oven roasted turkey, tossed together with lettuce, crunchy veggies and whatever dressing does it for you. Simply the best.
Buffalo Chicken Grilled chicken topped with Frank’s RedHot® Buffalo sauce, with lettuce, spinach, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, black olives and red onions. A drizzle of peppercorn ranch dressing cools the spice. Very nice. Frank’s RedHot® is a registered t…
Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki The Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki salad has so much flavor that it may turn into your go-to meal. It starts with crunchy veggies—lettuce, spinach, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, black olives, and red onions followed by our juicy, grilled chick…
Spicy Italian Our Spicy Italian salad is a combo of pepperoni and Genoa salami. Basically, the ideal Italian sub, but transformed into a salad. Genius, right?
Pizza Sub Spicy pepperoni, American cheese and mouthwatering marinara sauce over crisp lettuce, spinach, ripe tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, black olives and red onions.
Steak & Cheese The Steak & Cheese salad starts with crisp greens, but gets to the next level with warm, delicious steak topped with cheese. Dreams do come true.
Veggie Delite® Enjoy the simpler things? The Veggie Delite® salad is simply delish. A pile of your favorite veggies, finished with the dressing of your choice. Crisp. Delicious. All for you.
Cold Cut Combo® The Cold Cut Combo® salad has ham, salami, and bologna (all turkey-based) tossed together with crisp lettuce and your favorite veggies. Mix it up with whatever dressing you love best.
Shareable Desserts
12 Pack Cookie Box 12 cookies. 1 delicious order. That’s what our 12 Cookie Box is all about. Pick your favorite flavor and enjoy a dozen of fresh-baked cookies. That’s a one-way ticket to sweet treats that you can share with friends, family or co-workers. With so m…
Bottled Beverages
1% Low Fat Milk As delicious as our sandwiches are, they are even better when paired with the perfect side and drink or even adding a little something extra. With such a variety to choose from, there’s truly something for every taste.
Honest Kids® Super Fruit Punch Grape, strawberry, apple, watermelon juices and other ingredients unite to truly pack a punch. USDA organic certified. Sweetened only with fruit juice. No added sugar. No artificial sweeteners. No high fructose corn syrup. Gluten free. No GMOs.
Dasani® Water As delicious as our sandwiches are, they are even better when paired with the perfect side and drink or even adding a little something extra. With such a variety to choose from, there’s truly something for every taste.
Coca-Cola® Classic Crisp, refreshing, original taste.
Kids Drinks
Honest Kids® Super Fruit Punch Grape, strawberry, apple, watermelon juices and other ingredients unite to truly pack a punch. USDA organic certified. Sweetened only with fruit juice. No added sugar. No artificial sweeteners. No high fructose corn syrup. Gluten free. No GMOs.
1% Low Fat Milk As delicious as our sandwiches are, they are even better when paired with the perfect side and drink or even adding a little something extra. With such a variety to choose from, there’s truly something for every taste.
Classic Sandwiches
Italian B.M.T.® The Italian B.M.T.® sandwich is filled with Genoa salami, spicy pepperoni, and Black Forest ham. Big. Meaty. Tasty. Get it.
Meatball Marinara The Meatball Marinara sandwich is drenched in irresistible marinara sauce, sprinkled with Parmesan cheese, topped with whatever you want (no judgement) and perfectly toasted just for you.
Oven-Roasted Turkey & Ham Enjoy the flavor of tender, thin-sliced oven-roasted turkey and Black Forest ham with your favorite veggies, from juicy tomatoes to sweet red onions, all served on freshly baked, Hearty Multigrain bread.
Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki The Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki sub is one sah-weeet sub. It starts with Hearty Multigrain bread, add perfectly cooked grilled chicken strips, marinated in our Sweet Onion Teriyaki Sauce, then pile on the crunch with lettuce, spinach, tomatoes, c…
Cold Cut Combo® The Cold Cut Combo® sandwich with ham, salami, and bologna (all turkey based) is a long-time Subway® favorite. Yeah. It’s that good.
Veggie Delite® The Veggie Delite® sandwich is crispy, crunchy, vegetarian perfection. With lettuce, baby spinach, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers and red onions, all on our Hearty Multigrain bread.
Oven-Roasted Turkey If a classic is what you crave, our thin-sliced Oven-Roasted Turkey is the sandwich for you. It’s full of flavor and made to order with your choice of crisp veggies, served on our freshly baked, Hearty Multigrain bread.
B.L.T The sub that proves great things come in threes. In this case, those three things happen to be hickory smoked bacon, lettuce and juicy tomatoes. While there’s no scientific way of proving it, this B.L.T might be the most perfect sub in existence.
Pizza Sub Hot outta the oven, it’s the Pizza Sub. Enjoy spicy pepperoni, piled high and layered with melt-a-licious cheese and our signature marinara sauce. Try it on freshly baked Artisan Italian bread today.
Buffalo Chicken When you’re looking to spice things up, do it with Frank’s RedHot® and buffalo chicken. Our Buffalo Chicken Footlong is made with everyone’s favorite hot sauce – Frank’s RedHot® and topped with peppercorn ranch. Try it with lettuce, tomatoes and c…
Steak & Cheese Our Steak & Cheese sandwich is where warm, delicious steak gets topped with melty cheesiness. Get crazy with veggies and sauces to make it what you want.
Black Forest Ham Our Black Forest Ham sandwich is a true classic. We add lettuce, baby spinach, cucumbers, green peppers and red onions to our delicious, thin-sliced ham and serve it on our Hearty Multigrain bread. Want cheese? Just ask.
Tuna You’ll love every bite of our classic tuna sandwich. 100% wild caught tuna blended with creamy mayo then topped with your choice of crisp, fresh veggies. 100% delicious.
Spicy Italian Our Spicy Italian sandwich is a combo of pepperoni and Genoa salami. Pile on cheese, crunchy veggies, and finish it with your favorite sauce. Or don’t. Your call.
Fresh Fit for Kids®
Black Forest Ham For Kids Our Black Forest Ham for Kids is BIG on flavor. They get delicious slices of ham with their favorite veggies on freshly baked bread, and also enjoy a side of apple sauce and a choice of a bottle of low-fat milk or Honest Kids’® Fruit Punch.
Oven-Roasted Turkey For Kids A turkey sandwich for lunch is a classic for a reason—it’s why kids go crazy for our Oven Roasted Turkey for Kids. The main attraction is tasty oven roasted turkey slices with their favorite veggies piled on, all on freshly baked bread. But they a…
Veggie Delite® For Kids Veggie Delite® for Kids is the easiest and most delicious way to get them to eat their veggies. This meal starts with their favorite veggies piled on freshly baked bread, and continues with a scrumptious side of apple sauce, and finishes with a ch…

… View more

Reviews

Amanda Bronson

The platters are amazing and done picture perfect.. hats off to the manager.

… more

Luisana Pulido

There is a sign stating customers are able to use the restroom yet being customers we were denied the right to use the restroom. We still had to drive an hour and a half to get home. I don’t think any customer should be denies the right to use the restroom. My 4 year old daughter was crying after this because she couldn’t hold it. Too bad I can’t leave 0 stars.

… more

Kristen Pollack

I go to this location all the time. Today my 10 year old daughter and i were yelled at because the woman did not know how to ring up my coupon. She yelled at me like it was my fault that she was new and was never trained corectly. We just left the building and she came outside still yelling at us . Also, she was cleaning out the garbadge cans when we walked in, after a minute or 2 she then walked behind the counter to make our order WITHOUT WASHING HER HANDS. We are not tourists, we live here. I have never been mistreated in public by any employee of any establishment in our town . If anyone is smart, please think twice before eating here.

… more

Autumn Cox

I went in to buy a cookie and a pop and was treated very rudely by the older only lady working because I had asked her to break a 20. She was Thento concerned about my pay whatever she was doing in the back and not about being kind to her customers. I went in later to use the restroom and she was literally leaning over the side of the counter waiting for me to come out of the bathroom to yell at me as I’m walking out the door to use the porta potties outside. I’m in town visiting you Buffalo and now I know that I will no longer be supporting the local Subway here and will go to other places to spend my money. Considering they’re never busy you would think they would treat their customers better.

… more

David Martin

They always have good sandwiches, but they are expensive for the larger sandwiches. Daily specials and coupons help.

… more

Jeff Furtaw

This store is snugly nestled near the New Buffalo marina. A warm November afternoon found us purchasing several sandwiches with very little meat. My cohorts and I threw bits of our lunch to visiting sea gulls since they were barely adequate for human consumption.

… more

Stephanie C

The lady let me share the foot long, but when we tried to split payment, it was attitude. I also didn’t like how she rushed me. First time at that location

… more

Cool

The lady has a lot of attitude towards certain customers and when we tried to pay she told we couldn’t. My sister ended up having to take everything from her wallet to try and pay just because the lady wouldn’t let her pay with what she had.

… more

Craig Johnson

Customer service was outstanding. Love the subway sandwich. Spicy Italian. Very fresh and hot bread. This establish lives up to Subway name.

… more

Jonathon Hartzell

Sandwich was good. Customer service was good. Floors and bathrooms could use a cleaning

… more

… View more

Menu

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Subway Menu – New Buffalo, MI

Menu

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions