Based on 122 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $
Address:
WILLOW WOOD SHOPPING CENTER, 1161 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Supreya Me
Excellent service by our server Jamie, she was welcoming, friendly and great at her service! Her manager was extremely courteous! Food was excellent as well, they had some special going on and got us a free dessert sundae!!!
… more
R.Alexandria Collins
My hubby placed an order for delivery, since it’s nasty out and cold plus we have a newborn. I was super excited bc they serve funnel cake and I haven’t had one in years!! They have a wide array of food which also excited me bc I had been craving a chicken quesadilla, which was also on menu. The pricing seemed adequate for the food, so I assumed. However upon receiving my food I was NOT IMPRESSED AT ALL! 4 out of the 6 items we ordered either was missing an item or tasted terrible. As u see in the pic my hubby cheese steak on one side barely had meat on it. My quesadilla is missing the salsa and sour cream, as seen in the pic. The funnel cake looks fine but it is HARD AND DRY. Two things things a funnel cake should not be. Oh yeah and my daughter’s fresh fruit salad looks like and tastes like it came out of a can! Being that the bill came to almost fifty dollars, I feel as though the food should have been worth the price!
… more
Gabriella Sobell
Delicious food and amazing Stewart’s floats!! I love their sweet potatoes fries and their creamsicle float was TO DIE FOR!! I am now addicted to orange vanilla sodas.. says someone who isnt a big soda fan to start with!
… more
Thomas Moudatsos
Great Family Restaurant this retro diner ice cream shop is a great find in Wantagh I highly recommend this place . Check it out I’m sure you will become a regular
… more
Susanne Kimball
My husband, 2 daughters (7 &4) and I had a wonderful experience at Stewart’s earlier this evening. Our server, Sal, was totally awesome!!! Absolutely wonderful service!!! All of our meals and desserts were delicious! The kids had a blast with the provided wiki stix and crayons! They loved their ice cream sundaes that came in cool cars that they still enjoyed playing with when we got home!
… more
Karen F
2/11/18 Second time we tried this place. Food is just ok, they forgot the coleslaw and pickle AGAIN, when my husband asked for it, it took forever for waitress to bring it. Then waitress disappears AGAIN. Nobody asked how was your meal? Do you want anything else? It’s pricey for mediocre food and service. The management should train their employees to be more attentive, that would go a long way in improving the experience, of course that wouldn’t improve the food. I’ve had better meals at Wendy’s, at a much better price. .. we won’t be back…
… more
Rebecca Wilensky
When Stuart’s first opened I read reviews about the poor service. I waited for months after months to try the restaurant hoping that all the kinks would be worked out. Well, I was wrong. First of all, when we walked in, they said we had to wait for silverware because it was being cleaned. After a while, we ordered our food. The food came out quick, but one meal was wrong. They brought it in to be fixed, and it came out wrong again. At this point we just asked to not have it. Not to mention our milkshake came out AFTER our food when we clearly said to bring it out as soon as possible. Also, the coleslaw and pickles that came with our meals never arrived. You would think they would want to give you the check quickly, but no! It took forever to get the check. Throughout the whole meal, the waitress kept apologizing, but the manager never came over. Usually we would pay for the food with a credit card, but we used cash to get out of there faster. Overall we would not recommend the restaurant to anyone and we are not returning.
… more
Paul Paretta
Last night I had dinner at Stewart’s with my daughter. We had a great dining experience. The staff was friendly, professional and on top of their game. The food was very good and the menu selection is excellent. You must come down to Stewart’s for a great meal.
… more
Joe Tarry
Service was fine. But I ordered a taco salad and it was dry. No salsa dressing. Just like a regular salad with shredded cheese in a taco bowl. And the server offered me gyro meat on it which I took. It wasn’t like real gyro meat. It was like a grey flat piece of dry cold cut meat. So I will still go to stewarts, but I will stick to what they are good at. Always liked their burgers and chili dogs. That’s what I’ll get next time.
… more
Donna Rivera
My daughter and I took my 4 grandsons to Stewarts Sat Morning, the service was great, food was great, fast, clean, and everyone was so nice, and as we paid our bill and was leaving, the Manger or Owner, not sure offered me to select 4 flavors of their cream sodas to try, We tried them and loved it. I will definitely be going back, and will be recommending the place to my friends and family. Thank you to the staff , for a great experience. <3 <3 Donna Rivera, West Babylon, NY
… more
… View more