Based on 188 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
565 NJ-23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Phone: (973) 616-6624
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jacqueline Cottrell
We hosted a private party for my daughter’s baptism in the large dining room. We had about 50 adults and 10 kids. The room was plenty big, food was outstanding (so many guests commented on it as they hadn’t been there before), and we added the gelato bar/cart which was a hit for adults and kids alike. The owners were very accommodating and made the process easy, yet executed perfectly. I couldn’t recommend it more. We plan to host many future parties there going forward.
… more
Renu Fozdar
We just had a Celebration of Life party at Stefano’s and couldn’t be happier. The set up was perfect and Junior and his team were so accommodating and flexible. The food choices were abundant and they were willing to do any combination we chose. They were also so accommodating for our guests who were vegan, vegetarian or on a gluten free diet. We received so many compliments from our guests on the service, food and atmosphere. I highly recommend Stefano’s if you are looking for a venue for a party!
… more
Cristina Stivala
One of the most memorable and authentic dining experiences my family and I have had a long time. The service was impeccable and each dish was loaded with love and with flavors beyond belief. Don’t hesitate to stay around for dessert because this place does not disappoint!!! Xoxoxo
… more
Lauren Bolnick
The food was delicious. The staff was exceptionally nice and helpful. Our waitress Sue was so patient and answered all our questions. Definitely will be back
… more
Jasmin Ortiz
Hubby and I found our new favorite family owned Italian restaurant! We stopped in really late for a quick bite. Grabbed some slices and a tiramisu cannoli. Seriously, the best pizza we’ve had since moving to town. My husband had the buffalo chicken and I had a meat lovers. They were both absolutely delish!! Had the tiramisu cannoli and it was heaven on earth! They even have homemade gelato. The cherry on top was how nice the staff was. Thank you Stefano’s!!
… more
Gregory Levita
Been coming here for over a decade. This place is a gem. Legit authentic over-the-top presentation Italian fare with service to match. Formal restaurant is intimate with nice decor. BYOB.
… more
Rich Hoffman
Love this place, BYOB,Food is fantastic, had lots of different meals off the menu along with the rest of my family and have never been disappointed, always get one pizza for the table, awesome thin crust and we get treated like family . The best cannoli’s around and we have had a party here that was just great , again love this place.
… more
Giorgi Surabischwili
Im from Philly and this was the best pizza I have had in years, maybe my whole life. Friendly owner’s and staff. Will come here every time im mountain biking at mountain creek!
… more
Linda Cucolo
Food was very overpriced, and we waited about an hour for our food. Everything was pretty slow in general. The mash potatoes tasted like a instant mash potatoes and my grand son said the green beans where the same canned ones they had at his school. I tasted them and they tasted exactly like canned green beans. Had to return my chicken julian because it was extremely dry and tasteless. My husband thought the bronzini was decent and my sons steak was like a sponge. The only decent thing was the rice. Our grand total was $115. Never again. Don’t bother coming hear. (THIS IS A REVIEW ON THE LEFT RESTAURANT NOT THE RIGHT ONE)
… more
Paul Cohen
Great experience with absolutely delicious Italian food. Fantastic atmosphere inside. The wait staff was welcoming and friendly. A huge amount of specials given to us by the waitress. Ordered two fish entrees that were outstanding. The sauces on the food were fantastic. Everything was perfect. The restaurant is BYOB.
… more
… View more