Based on 176 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
12 N Main St, Warsaw, NY 14569
Phone: (585) 228-1246
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dave Gardingham
Being from downstate NY, I’m always on the hunt for authentic NY style pizza in the WNY region. Stefano’s came through! Solid crust, super cheesy, and a perfectly tart, subtle sauce.
… more
Matt Smith
Their fried foods are good, fried pickles are hit or miss if you get the coins or the fries, NY style-ish pizza is hit or miss if you actually get a big fluffy crust when you’re craving that NY thin crust pizza. Also as writing this ordered deep dish and pan pizza. They have two separate options for deep dish and pan pizza, so i was kinda afraid being in NYS and ordering a deep dish that this would be the case. Gave them the benefit of the doubt, was hopeful when they said it would be an hour to make, However it was simply a pan pizza. Also Delivery always seems to be an hour and a half even at 2PM on a Tuesday they quoted an hour and a half. 4PM on a Friday, hour and a half. Bottom line, they are reliable for fried foods thats about it.
… more
RJ Nels
What’s up people of Warsaw I go by Rj and I’m new to town. I needed to be lazy today so although everything in this town is walking distance I ordered delivery you would be surprised but there is actually only one place in this town that will deliver you some food believe it or not so naturally I found Stefanos! first thing I noticed is that no one in town seems to enjoy posting pics of there food as I do this made me worried about the quality bit I had no choice o had to take a leap of faith I got a medium chicken finger sub with lettuce tomato onion cheese a AND Blue cheese thank you please , I also tried the fried zucchini which I have unsuccessfully ordered from previous restaurants for about two years now because everybody was always out so that was a very pleasant surprise they were exactly what you want a zucchini fry delicious and as for the chicken finger sub yo listen this bread which I planned on taken a picture of but iv beeen sitting here writing this picking at the bread cause it’s so dang soft an light psshh thank you stefanos I needed to eat somthing fulfilling and I got that and last but of course not least the staff was very friendly and quick
… more
Marsha Bouslimi
This is 2nd time we visited
… more
Kraig Lyons (VinjiOfTheDeep)
Ordered: Large Turkey Club with Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Provalone Cheese, and Blue Cheese
… more
Mircea
Very delicious pizza. One of the best pizza around. Delicious, right size, good food service.
… more
Kyle Jones
Good pizza if the lazy kid working ever has any made to sell. Twice I’ve been in there and he is always sitting down n says either the ovens aren’t warmed up yet or he sold his last slice. This was between the hours of 12:15pm and 1:30pm. I’m done trying. I’ve walked out one other time because I stood by the counter waiting for 10 minutes while he was in the back.
… more
Kara M
Order 10 pc wing typically you expect mixed flats and drums, I like flats save drums for kids/husband, get my wings and EVERY last one of them are drums, call to ask if they were having a shortage and only had drums, they said no, didn’t seem to care my order has this issue, a waste of $20 extremely disappointed.
… more
Alicia Wittenberg
Would give it a zero!!!!! Put on hold but ending up hearing the whole conversation between employees and customers. Had to call back and my order was finally taken after being on hold and having to call back. When I complained I was hung up on, so I canceled my order.
… more
D. Hunt (Guarded Life LLC)
Man, spare of the moment hunger hit me at 9:30 pm. The small Pepperoni pizza and mild wings were delicious. True NY style.
… more
… View more