Based on 20 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
129 W Main St, New Albany, IN 47150
Phone: (812) 308-3004
Hours
| Sunday | 2–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 5 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 5 PM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Patricia Appleton
I loved everything about this place. The pizza took time, but it was so worth the wait! It was hot, rich, and delicious. We got the 18″ for 4 people and it was way more than enough. The staff was amazing and answered all our questions and were so professional.
… more
Gabrielle Lang
Ordered my pizza and apps for pick up, paid extra for extra sauce on the pizza, xtra sauces on the side. Of the 6 that were ordered, I received 2 of one and none of the other. I set an order time of 6:15 to which I received a “your order is ready” text 15 minutes earlier than my order time. I arrive right on time at the time I expressed, I received the order, I ask, and the sauces are in the order? I received a yes (they were not) The pizza and bread x2 were dryer than the Sahara Desert, no sauce but ya charged for extra on the pizza too. Oh and cold too. Perhaps I’m just not a New York style pizza girl.
… more
Corriann Pollison
First it is important to know that this place is located inside the bar that you see on the corner, so don’t bring your children (not that it’s a bad thing just wanted to warn anyone who was thinking of bringing minors) My husband and I just tried this spinellis for the first time tonight and I will start on a positive note by saying the girls working were amazing, great customer service, super informative, and just overall very nice, we ordered a margherita pizza and pepperoni knots, I was so excited for this pizza but unfortunately we got home and the dough was not cooked, it was raw and chewy which ruined the entire pizza, however the pepperoni knots were pretty good. I would give them a second try if I knew for sure the dough would be cooked on the next trip, when I saw it was raw, when we picked up the slices they just dropped and everything fell off, it was actually cold raw dough.
… more
Jakob Wagner
I love Spinellis in all, but y’all got me messed up with the 21 and over rule. We called 3 times to try a do a curbside order and nobody picked up. Mf just tryna get some pizza 🙁
… more
Tripw
Yeah, this place was terrible service wise . It was loud it was obnoxious when ordering didn’t even offer us a drink just got straight to the point get your order and get out. It’s basically the mentality of this place I can see why it has a 3.7 this place was awful
… more
Kristie Anderson
Was very disappointed! Crust was very undercooked and toppings were minimal. Won’t revisit! You can get a better pizza at Papa John’s.
… more
Patrick Burke
This place has a great vibe and the pizza slices are huge straight out of a brick oven. The best New York style pizza around with live music and a brewery on site.
… more
AJ
Not cool to trash my car with your menu.
… more
Josh Harrison
My first visit to any of the Spinelli’s Pizza locations. Large, floppy foldable slices of delicious pizza. Nice selection of beer on tap, friendly staff and a great atmosphere. Live entertainment in the Enchanted Forest area. Super cute place with assorted board and card games to play. Our group of 8 had a wonderful time.
… more
Nick Ramos
These guys kill it. Came in at 1130 and got me a couple slices of pizza with some beers on tap. Awesome staff, great environment, and most importantly – huge slices of pizza for my midnight munchies!
… more
… View more