Bringing NY style pizza to Downtown Fargo, ND. This is where we got our start many moons ago as a small pizza joint in the heart of downtown Fargo, North Dakota. When you want pizza, you don’t want second best. Whether you’re a college student attending NDSU, MSUM, or Concordia, looking for a great place for a date night, or just want to treat yourself on a weeknight, you want pizza made from the best ingredients.
We offer in-person dining in a family-friendly atmosphere, pizza delivery, event catering, and large group dining.
New York-style pizza by the slice or pie in a funky space with upcycled furniture & a graffiti wall. Based on 866 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
322 Broadway N, Fargo, ND 58102
Phone: (701) 356-7437
Website:
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Roberto Hendy
Spicy pie is a favorite when I am on town from my home in mesa. Being able to get a couple slices made to order with my specifications and ability to choose the spicy or regular sauce is one of the reasons I choose to visit every time I am in town. The desert bites dipped in creamy white frosting top off a perfect lunch or dinner. Quaint downtown brick and industrial type atmosphere makes for an even better dining experience.
… more
Anagha Dange
Pizza by the slice! Besides the long list of choices, you can create your slices, too!
… more
Shana Durdin
Love being able to order pizza by the slice. We tried several different options and everything was fantastic.
… more
San Allen
The pizza and wings were great this is one of the best spots yet we’ve ate at I definitely recommend this place
… more
Cyndi Schefflin
Hubby and I are on a road trip from Idaho to Minnesota and now back to Idaho. We stopped in Fargo for our first overnight and my darling found this pizza place knowing how much I love a good pizza. Unless you are with a few people or ultra hungry go the slice route. Slice is large and delicious!! Beer or soda with your meal. Great employees, excellent pizza so go and enjoy!!!
… more
Richard Dagostino
Always found it difficult to find good pizza in the Midwest. This was amongst the better in the area. I did have to add black pepper. Although that was easy enough. I left pleased with my purchase. I found the younger staff to be very efficient, knowledgeable and polite. The atmosphere had a nice feel although somewhat of a small place. I’ll be back.
… more
Karli Brekke
Great pizza like always, but wow was it littered with flies and gnats in there. My husband and I couldn’t even sit down for more than a minute without swatting them away. It was pretty frustrating as it didn’t seem like they had a handle on the situation.
… more
Sydni May
Can’t get enough of the PBR pizza! My favorite spot to go for lunch downtown. Huge slices, made fresh, for a great price!
… more
Luke Larson
Pickles, bacon, and ranch? Yup. It was amazing. Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Garlic knots were in point as well.
… more
Ross Peterson
I moved away from Fargo a few years back and I still dream about Spicy Pie. Hot and fresh New York slices with the trifecta of what a good slice should be: generous, flavorful cheese, herby fresh sauce, and crust that cracks when you fold it. It’s a miracle if a pizzeria can do two of those things right, but this spot does it all. I can’t find anything else like this pizza with such unique basics anywhere else, along with those addicting bread bites and piping hot zeppoli. I’ll know Fargo is still doing alright as long as this place stands!
… more
… View more
