Playful joint offering American grub, including breakfast fare, plus trivia nights & outdoor tables. Based on 398 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
65 Main St, West Sayville, NY 11796
Phone: (631) 218-6500
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–11 PM |
| Thursday | 12–11 PM |
| Friday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 4–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Cristi Aiello
The food and drinks were delicious. Our server was very attentive and fun. It wasn’t a night to check out the backyard seating area. Will definitely be back!!
… more
Virginia Nanni
Met up with a friend for lunch on a Sunday. Was hoping to get the regular menu…we didn’t realize it was brunch. We were not disappointed. We both got Benny’s…her the fried chicken and waffles, me the ham, avocado and tomato. White sangria was spot on as well. Will definitely come back for dinner. Maybe take advantage of the cute patio and atmosphere.
… more
Peter Montalvo
A good spot here for sure! I feel like it’s a sleeper. Not many know yet how good it is.
… more
Kelsey Herrera
South shore dive is one of the only places I come to alone whenever I want to enjoy an evening. Bobby and Jules were amazing and so accommodating it was such a pleasure to hang out with them for awhile. Best drinks and good food, highly recommend stopping by!
… more
Thomas Mcdonald
This place is a hidden gem with great food and an awesome staff, the tacos and lemon pepper wings were excellent. They have brunch on the weekends, which I have not tried yet, bit will. The wife and I will be back.
… more
Russell Rowsell
The food is great. Love the bingo on Wednesday nights. The bartender is incredible he will make you anything you can dream up. I think his name is Joey
… more
John Halter
Decent drinks. Good selection of LI brews. Not the biggest menu but food was delicious. Wings were mediocre- not enough flavor. Pretzel was good. They had weinerschnitzel on special and it was excellent. Tater tots with Chipotle dip is the bomb, and you can get toppings on the tots like pork belly and other good toppings. Burger was great. They add a gratuity for parties of 6 or more. Chill outdoor seating area.
… more
Sarah Johnson
I love this place! I first went when they first opened and the owner was hanging lights in the outdoor area. Pretty nice guy! I’m a vegetarian so I can’t say much for majority of their food, but their Mac and Cheese is pretty bomb. You can also customize it with additional toppings (for an added charge). Their tater tots are interesting, they’re like a cross in between a Knish, Latke and Hashbrown, but I think they’re pretty bomb.
… more
TM cG
Frequent attendee at trivia nights on Tuesday nights. The drinks and food are great. Our one gripe would be the lack of integrity and blatant disregard for cheating amongst the trivia teams. Maybe just remind people not to cheat and monitor a bit more?
… more
Rodino Janowski
Really cool spot. Fun alternative to The Shed for Brunch. Took my my friends and it was a hit. 3 of us had the Churro Waffle w/Chicken with Frose’s with one person going with the Avocado Toast with Cold Brew—- Delicious, all around !!!! – The waffles were a kick in the but with the first bite b/c of the sweetness, but when you combine the spices with the chicken. BOOM! Flavor explosion. Our attendant was great and we already can’t wait to go back and try out the dinner menu. Keep up the fantastic work ladies and gents! Go- Enjoy everyone
… more
… View more