Smoke Shack Express at the Mayfair Collection Menu – Wauwatosa, WI

Type : Barbecue restaurant

Location : Wauwatosa, WI

Welcome to Smoke Shack Express! Order at the counter, grab a seat, and enjoy our slow-smoked BBQ. In a rush? Easy. Grab our good eats to-go. Don’t forget dessert!

We’re obsessed with the craft of smoked meat. Our certified humanely-raised meats are dry rubbed, slow smoked, and sauced by you. Our signature Black Angus Beef Brisket is slow smoked for 14 hours to ensure you get the perfect quality barbecue.

American BBQ place dishing slow-smoked, dry-rubbed meats in a weathered-wood shack with a patio. Based on 324 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $$

Smoke Shack Express at the Mayfair Collection 53222

Address:
11340 W Burleigh St, Wauwatosa, WI 53222

Phone: (414) 431-1119

Website: http://www.smoke-shack.com/

Menu

Lunch / Dinner
Texas BBQ Nachos
Tortilla chips piled high with fresh jalapeño, tomato, red onion, black beans, sour cream and white cheddar with your choice of pork or brisket
$12.50
Chicken Wings
Rosemary wet-rubbed Amish chicken wings slow smoked and fried crispy served with celery and housemade blue cheese dressing
$9.50
Rib Tips
A little known BBQ secret served with housemade kettle chips (Rib Tips are in limited supply and may sell out based on demand)
$9.25
Pork Belly Bites
Double smoked, fried crispy and tossed in Kansas City BBQ sauce
$9.75
Burnt Ends
A must-try delicacy served with kettle chips (Burnt Ends are in limited supply and may sell out based on demand)
$13.50
Kansas City Eggrolls
Premium Iowa pulled pork, Monterey jack cheese, cabbage, honey mustard and Kansas City BBQ sauce
$9.75
Fried Green Tomatoes
Chipotle aioli, chopped cilantro and lemon zest
$7.50
Chicken Fried Spare Ribs
Alabama white BBQ sauce
$13.50
Roasted Poblano Corn Chowder $4.00
Housemade Chili
Carefully crafted daily
$4.00
House Salad
Spring mix, red cabbage, radish, cucumber and tomato with balsamic raspberry dressing
$3.75
Wedge Salad
Iceberg lettuce, blue cheese crumbles, tomato, red onion, Nueske’s bacon and cucumber ribbons with housemade blue cheese dressing
$6.75
Smoke Shack Salad
Romaine, Nueske’s bacon, pulled smoked Amish chicken, red cabbage, hard boiled egg, tomato, cucumber and blue cheese crumbles with honey mustard dressing
$13.50
Pulled Amish Chicken $12.25
Pulled Premium Iowa Pork $12.50
Black Angus Beef Brisket $13.75
Andouille Sausage $12.50
BBQ Seitan $9.75
Brisket Sloppy Joe $13.50
Combo Plates
Your choice: 1/3 pound of any meats, side and pickled veggies
$18.50
Baby Back Or Spare Ribs $19.00
1/3 Rack Baby Back Ribs
1/3 Rack Spare Ribs
1/4 Lb Brisket
1/4 Lb Sausage Links
1/4 Lb Pulled Pork & Chicken
Fried Corn
Slaw
Corn Bread
Decadant Mac & 4-Cheese
Sweet Potato Fries
Sweet And Spicy Beans $3.00
Pickled Veggies $2.75
Coleslaw $2.75
Sweet Potato Fries $3.50
Decadent Mac & 4-Cheese $4.50
Roasted Brussels Sprouts $3.25
Cornbread $3.25
Fried Corn On The Cob $2.75
Skin-On Kettle Chips $3.00
Bourbon Praline Cake
Made with Woodford Reserve Bourbon
$7.50
Pecan Pie
Served with a scoop of Purple Door Whisky Ice Cream or vanilla custard
$8.25
Bacon Bourbon Brownies
Made with Woodford Reserve Bourbon, served with a scoop of vanilla custard
$7.75
Purple Door Whiskey Ice Cream
A Smoke Shack exclusive by Purple Door with whiskey and cinnamon
$4.50
Vanilla Custard $3.50
Brunch
The Shack Scratch Cinnamon Roll
Served with vanilla frosting
$6.75
Build Your Own Biscuits And Gravy
Homemade biscuits and Sassy Cow milk gravy served with home fries. Add pulled ham, pulled pork, pulled chicken, andouille sausage or seitan for
$4.00
Burnt Ends Benedict
Poached eggs, Alabama white BBQ sauce, griddled English muffin, served with home fries
$14.50
Pulled Pork Benedict
Fried green tomatoes, poached eggs, Cajun hollandaise, griddled English muffin, served with home fries
$13.75
Sweet Potato Pancakes Two Ways
Sweet (vegetarian): mascarpone whipped cream, toasted pecans and homemade apple syrup Or Savory: pulled Iowa pork and Carolina mustard sauce
$10.50
Fried Chicken ‘N’ Poblano Waffles
Homemade apple syrup
$13.75
Monte Cristo
Pulled ham, Dijon mustard, white cheddar, jam, brioche, apple syrup, served with home fries
$13.50
Plain Jane
2 eggs, biscuit or English muffin, bacon or andouille sausage link and home fries
$9.75
Nueske’s Bacon $3.00
Sweet Potato Pancake
With homemade apple syrup
$3.00
Andouille Sausage Link $4.00
Scratch Biscuit Or English Muffin $2.50
Home Fries $3.00
Bloody Mary Three Ways
Flight of our Soon-To-Be-Legen (wait for it!) dary Bloody Mary mix flavored with Tito’s vodka, Jack Daniel’s, and Sauza Tequila, each topped with its own garnish, and choice of beer chaser
$14.00
Classic Bloody Mary
Vodka, bloody mary mix, cheese and sausage garnish
$10.00
Bloody Jack
Jack Daniel’s, bloody mary mix, cheese and sausage garnish
$10.00
Spiced Agave
Sauza silver, bloody mary mix, cheese and sausage garnish
$10.00
Jack’s Iced Coffee
Jack Daniel’s, chocolate liqueur, hazelnut liqueur, iced coffee cream
$9.00
Bourbon Brunch Punch
Four Roses, sparkling wine, orange juice, pineapple juice, Sierra Mist, mint
$9.00
Classic Mimosa
Fresh squeezed orange juice, sparkling wine
$7.00
Mule-Mosa
Tito’s vodka, sparkling wine, ginger beer, fresh squeezed orange juice
$9.00
Peach Mimosa
Peach liqueur, sparkling wine, fresh squeezed orange juic
$8.00
Kids Menu
BBQ Sliders (2)
Pulled Pork / Pulled Chicken / Brisket Sloppy Joe
$7.50
Hot Dog
Kosher, premium all-beef
$6.75
Mac & Cheese
Our signature white cheese blend
$6.75
Nachos
Tortilla chips with melted white cheddar
$6.25
Grilled Cheese
American cheese on panini bread
$6.25
Cornbread
Kettle Chips
Sweet Potato Fries
Fried Corn On The Cob
Vanilla Custard Sundae
Served with housemade chocolate sauce and a cherry on top
$3.00
Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie $2.00
Sprecher Root Beer Float $5.00
White Milk
Chocolate Milk
Soda
Sprecher Root Beer
Add $3
Drinks
Bud Light
Coors Light
Miller Lite
Pabst Blue Ribbon
Lakefront East Side Dark
Lakefront IPA
Lakefront Seasonal
Lakefront New Grist
Louie’s Demise
New Glarus Spotted Cow
New Glarus Seasonal
Surly Furious
Lagunitas Pils
Lagunitas IPA
Left Hand Milk Stout Nitro
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale
Rogue Dead Guy Ale
Blue Moon (16 Oz Can)
Crispin Hard Cider
O’douls
Lakefront Riverwest Stein
Outboard Cream Ale
City Lights Mosaic Pale Ale
Good City Pils
New Glarus Seasonal
Rotating Selection
Erath Pinot Noir $40.00
Zolo Malbec $36.00
Foxglove Cabernet $40.00
Cliffhanger Pinot Grigio $40.00
Otto’s Constant Dream Sauvignon Blanc $36.00
Matchbook Chardonnay $32.00
Texas Mule
Texas-made Deep Eddy grapefruit vodka, fresh lime, ginger beer
Bourbon Smash
Smashed lemon and mint, bourbon, simple syrup
Jack & Jill
Jack Daniels, lemonade, blackberries, Sierra Mist
Memphis Iced Tea
Long Island Iced Tea with a southern drawl
Classic Old Fashioned
Bulleit Bourbon, sugar, bitters, orange peel, club soda
Southern Belle
Tito’s vodka, muddled lemon and strawberry, lemonade, Sierra Mist
Peach Sweet Tea
Peach and citrus liqueur, vodka, iced tea, lemon
Kentuckitiki
Bulleit Bourbon, orange and pineapple juices, almond syrup
Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Sierra Mist
Ginger Ale
Mountain Dew
Dr. Pepper
Lemonade
Iced Tea
Coffee
Sprecher Root Beer $3.50
Catering Menu
Picnic In The Park
Pulled Iowa pork, pulled Amish chicken, cole slaw, skin-on kettle chips, slider buns, selection of our housemade BBQ sauces
$12.50
Mac & Meat
Pulled Iowa pork, pulled Amish chicken, decadent mac & 4-cheese, skin-on kettle chips, slider buns, selection of our housemade BBQ sauces
$14.50
Brisket Supper
Black Angus beef brisket, pulled Amish chicken, decadent mac & 4-cheese, cole slaw, slider buns, selection of hosuemade BBQ sauces
$17.00
Starters
Kansas City Eggrolls, Smoked Wings
From The Smoker
Spare Ribs, Black Angus Brisket
Sides
House Salad, Decadent Mac & 4-Cheese, Sweet & Spicy Beans, Homemade Cornbread, selection of housemade BBQ sauces
Cornbread $1.50
House Salad $2.50
Side $2.50
Sub One Side $2.00
Sub Brisket $2.50
Sub Ribs $3.50
Salted Caramel Brownie $1.75
Chocolate Chip Blondie $1.75
Pecan Sandy Bar $1.75
Mini Bacon, Bourbon Brownie $36.00
Kansas City Eggrolls
Premium lowa pulled pork, monterey jack cheese, cabbage, and Kansas City BBQ sauce
$19.00
Chicken Wings
Slow smoked and juicy, not fried and crispy. Rosemary wet-rubbed Amish chicken wings with housemade blue cheese dressing
$19.00
Decadent Mac & 4-Cheese $20.00
Seasonal Veggies $20.00
Sweet & Spicy Beans $16.00
Skin-On Kettle Chips $14.00
Cole Slaw $10.00
Fried Corn On The Cob $7.00
Cornbread $7.00
Baked Russet Or Sweet Potato $18.00
House Salad
Spring mix, red cabbage, radish, cucumber and tomato with balsamic raspberry dressing
$20.00
Smoke Shack Salad
Romaine, Nueske’s Bacon, red cabbage, hard boiled egg, tomato, cucumber and blue cheese crumbles with honey mustard dressing
$28.00
Pulled Premium Iowa Pork $39.00
Pulled Amish Chicken $39.00
Black Angus Brisket $53.00
Brisket Sloppy Joe $49.00
Housemade Premium Iowa Pork Sausage $44.00
Vegetarian BBQ Seitan $39.00
Spare Ribs (Includes Tips!) $74.00
Baby Back Ribs $59.00
Kansas City
Sweet and smokey
House BBQ
Well balanced, versatile, some kick
Texas BBQ
Tomato based with a little kick
Carolina Gold
Mustard based with a vinegar bite
Kick-24 Habenero
Hot and full of flavor
Salted Caramel Brownie $1.75
Chocolate Chip Blondie $1.75
Pecan Sandy Bar $1.75
Mini Bacon, Bourbon Brownie $36.00
Package One: Buzzer Beater
Choose Amish Pulled Chicken or Iowa Pulled Pork, Slider Buns, Decadent Four-Cheese Mac, Two Housemade Smoke Shack Sauces. Feeds 8-12
$99.00
Package Two: Full-Court Press
Choose Amish Pulled Chicken or Iowa Pulled Pork, Slider Buns, Decadent Four-Cheese Mac, Cornbread, Kettle Chips Four Housemade Smoke Shack Sauces. Feeds 8-12
$129.00
Veggie Tray
Fruit & Cheese Tray
Kettle Chips & Dip
Kansas City Egg Rolls
Premium Iowa pulled pork, Monterey jack cheese, cabbage, honey mustard and Kansas City BBQ sauce
Smoked Wings
Rosemary wet-rubbed Amish chicken wings slow smoked and fried crispy served with celery and housemade blue cheese dressing
Pork Belly BLT Sliders
Candied pork belly, cherry aioli, lettuce and tomato
Scratch-Made Desserts Trio
Salted Caramel Chocolate Brownies
Pecan Sandies
Chocolate Chip Blondies
Third Party Desserts
Cake Cutting / Dessert Service
2 Meats & 3 Sides
3 Meats & 3 Sides
Pulled Premium Iowa Pork
Pulled Amish Chicken
Black Angus Beef Brisket
Brisket Sloppy Joe
Housemade Premium Iowa Pork Sausage
Vegetarian BBQ Seitan
Premium Iowa Pork Ribs
Choose Spare Ribs or Baby Back Ribs
House Salad
Spring mix, red cabbage, radish, cucumber, tomato, balsamic raspberry dressing
Smoke Shack Salad
Romaine, Nueske’s bacon, red cabbage, hard boiled egg, tomato, cucumber, bleu cheese, honey mustard dressing
Baked Russet Potato
with butter
Baked Sweet Potato
with butter
Cole Slaw
Cornbread
Decadent Mac & 4-Cheese
Fried Corn On The Cob
Seasonal Veggies
Sweet & Spicy Beans
Skin-On Kettle Chips

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jen Peters
Pretty good, not amazing. The meat was very tender and didn’t seem to have been sitting on a steam table, but very fatty and the dry rubs were not very flavorful. The sauces are pretty good, the mac and cheese very creamy but could be a little cheesier, the cornbread was bland, I liked the brussel sprouts a lot.

… more

Paul Koenig
First time here. We ordered a selection of appetizers to sample all the food.

… more

Sameer Sheikh
Fast service, food is good. You get a tray of sauces and you can mix n match however you want, so be prepared to experiment! The bacon brownies weren’t good.

… more

Becky L
Had the burnt ends and they were super flavorful and yummy! Would have given 5 stars but the fried green tomatoes I ordered were very tough, which was disappointing since the breading and accompanying remoulade sauce were delicious! Fun, funky atmosphere and attentive waitstaff.

… more

Darryl Johnson
When your day started early and you spend time with good company no better place I could of picked tonight meal was the smoke house sampler it was so worth it! Can you say demolished! Looking forward to next cheat meal even if it’s a week away!

… more

Melissa
Refreshing cucumber drink. Chicken fried Ribs were very tasty and very tender. Cannot wait to try the end cuts, guys at work swear they are above and beyond. Nice atmosphere. Great happy hour specials

… more

Mason Lugo
Tried this place since we always miss the one in downtown and it was worth trying. They were also on my drinking app so well worth it. Food was flavorful and great

… more

ATG “Aleksandr The Great”
Places of very unique and different with having a style of ethnicity and rustic look. Has very good meat choices with the sampler and pretty unique desserts . Service was amazing. By far. Felt very informed of everything.

… more

Richard Colvin
I have no complaints about the staff or the facilities. Everything was nice and everyone was more than kind. I was just really let down by food. Everything felt like it was pulled out of a warmish chaffing dish and lightly seasoned. At least for the pork and the brisket, I can’t speak for the rest of the menu. I also can’t say that they served Mac and cheese but they do serve buttered noodles with some peppercorn and cheese shaved on top. And finally, I know that they use quality ingredients, but their drink menu is too expensive. Will I come back or recommend the place, probably. Will I revisit my review at that time, absolutely. But as I write this, I feel like me and my wallet would have been better off with grocery store hot bar equivalent.

… more

Road Trips With Yogi
First time dining at this establishment. Service was good. Prices are about average. Food was good as well, and arrived in a timely fashion. I ordered the 2 meat plate, choosing the Sausage and Brisket, along with one side, which was Mac & Cheese. I also ordered Cornbread, at an additional $3. When I looked at the plate placed in front of me, I was suprised at how small the portions of the meats were. I had one sausage cut in half that when placed together was about 4 inches long. The brisket was a total of 3 slices about 4 inches long as well, with the thickness of a bread slice. The meat and mac & cheese were good, and the sauces were also pretty tasty. Overall, a good experience with the exception of the meat portions. I’m glad I ordered the cornbread muffins which tasted more like a cake than a muffin, or I would have left hungry. $18.50 seemed a bit steep price wise for the amount of meat.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions