Based on 223 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
520 E Sheridan St, Ely, MN 55731
Phone: (218) 365-3688
Hours
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dillon Novak
Sir G’s stirs up a lot of fantastic, Northwoods nostalgia for me. It reminds me of a delicious pizza place in Eagle River WI that is now closed. Thankfully, Sir Gs fills that gap.
… more
Meme Critic
Always a good experience. Never disappointed with the food unlike… mediocre sammys, salt… I mean olive garden, or worst of all valentini’s barf club. (nothing authentic about those places). Do yourself a favor and drive to SirGs. Or learn how to cook.
… more
Theresa Jankovec
Had dinner there last night. Salad excellent as always. But when our pizza came realize something was off with the sausage on the pizza. Turns out it’s pork sausage seasoned with Italian seasonings. It was awful. When the menu says Italian sausage you expect to get Italian sausage very disappointed.
… more
Tess Gartenberg
Homemade pasta is great as well as the meatless red sauce. Very kid friendly as well. White sauce was a bit watery but flavor made up for it. Support this local restaurant over Dominos!
… more
Amanda P.
This place was a hot mess. They were clearly understaffed, but our waiter did his best. They didn’t have any pop or beer because they were out of CO2 (Carbination), they were out of salad dressing, and had to check if they were out of chicken. They were out of many things. The pizza was ok, my daughter liked her Chicken Alfredo, but for the price, the food was not worth it.
… more
Ben Klepzig
Just okay. It feels like they’re making an effort, but it just didn’t get all the way there. They boast of homemade noodles, but my shell pasta was watery and overcooked. The Alfredo sauce tasted more of chicken broth and Italian spices than cream and parmesan. This was true across the board. The food was filling and fine but not great. The portions are ridiculously large, so none of us are more than half, but none of us took leftovers.
… more
Ross Reishus
Delicious home made pizza! We built our own 13 inch chicken Alfredo garlic and spinach and it was amazing!! We will be back!
… more
Katy Friends
Pleasantly surprised! Great food & service. Get the salad and beans app!
… more
Anders Swanson-Lane
We came out of the BWCA looking for a real meal and were super excited for pasta and pizza. The service was nice (Cindy was our server and she was really great!) but the food was so disappointing. The veggie pizza was decent- exactly what I expected, 6/10. The white sauce for the pasta had absolutely no flavor. The mozzarella sticks were fine, the breadsticks were fine. The salad was super low effort. They claim to use only the highest quality ingredients but in reality it is just massively overpriced freezer food at best. I feel bad because the service was good and the people were so nice and I really wanted to like this place, but the food is just so embarrassing. If you want pizza I would just go to Domino’s. The pizza is better and it’s way cheaper.
… more
Krista Holle
I’m sorry to say our family was largely disappointed. Food is less than mediocre and poorly seasoned. Frozen rolls but tasty. Salad is a bowl of lettuce with mozzarella cheese on top. Server brought the wrong food to a member of our party and then argued that the item was what she ordered. The garlic toast was enjoyed but please rethink the pre-frozen veggie appetizer sampler. It was obviously not fresh and would have been better served with a homemade ranch. Everything seemed to come with the same marinara sauce.
… more
… View more