Simply Greekalicious Menu

Based on 132 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Simply Greekalicious 11793

Address:
1274 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793

Phone: (516) 679-1313

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday	12–8 PM
Wednesday	12–8 PM
Thursday	12–8 PM
Friday	12–9 PM
Saturday	12–9 PM
Sunday	12–8 PM
Monday	Closed

Appetizers
Feta Cheese Drizzled in EVOO and oregano.	$10.25
Falafel (6) Vegan. Ground chickpea balls with herbs and spices served with hummus and tahini sauce.	$10.55
Dolmathakia (6) Vegan. Stuffed grape leaves with rice and herbs.	$8.55
Loukaniko Greek pork sausage with leeks. Served with lemon and tzatziki.	$13.65
Mini Souvlaki (4) Marinated pork or chicken skewers. Served with pita bread and tzatziki.	$18.20
Pita Chips Served with tzatziki sauce or tyrokafteri.	$9.10
Chicken Fingers (5) Served with honey mustard or BBQ sauce.	$12.50
Mozzarella Sticks (6)	$11.35
Zucchini Sticks With tzatziki sauce.	$11.35
Greek Sampler Lamb and beef gyro, chicken doner, loukaniko, marinated pork and chicken cubes, fresh cut fries, served with pita and tzatziki sauce.	$51.25
Buffalo Wings (6) Regular, crispy or glazed in our Buffalo sauce. Served with Bleu cheese.	$11.35
American Sampler 6 Mozzarella sticks, 6 Buffalo wings, 6 chicken fingers served with fresh cut fries and dipping sauces.	$45.55
Spinach Or Cheese Pie Triangles (4) Served with tzatziki sauce.	$11.35
Greek Nachos Pita chips with lamb, beef or chicken topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, Feta, olives, pepperoncini, and tzatziki.	$19.35
Keftedakia Greek seasoned meatballs served with lemon and tzatziki.	$13.65
Fried Calamari Kalamarakia. Served with lemon and red sauce.	$17.05
Grilled Shrimp With pink sauce.	$12.50
Greek Tacos Chicken, pork or shrimp.	$12.50
Soups
Avgolemono Soup Traditional Greek egg and lemon chicken soup.	$7.70
Lentil Soup Vegan.	$7.70
Salads
Greek Salad Romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, peppers, dolma, Kalamata olives and Feta cheese served with our house extra virgin olive oil vinaigrette. Served with pita bread.	$11.35
Horiatiki Salad Traditional Greek salad. Tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, Kalamata olives, peppers, and Feta cheese tossed with EVOO and oregano. Served with pita bread.	$13.65
Mixed Greens Salad Mesclun, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, Kalamata olives, and peppers, served with our house extra virgin olive oil vinaigrette dressing. Served with pita bread.	$10.25
Caesar Salad Romaine, croutons, Parmesan cheese tossed in our Caesar dressing. Served with pita bread.	$11.35
Grilled Veggie Salad Vegan. Our grilled veggies over mesclun and cucumber. Served with pita bread.	$11.35
Skewers
Pork Skewers Served with pita bread.	$6.80
Chicken Skewers Served with pita bread.	$6.80
Lamb Skewers Served with pita bread.	$9.10
Sandwiches
Lamb & Beef Gyro Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$12.50
Chicken Doner Gyro Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$12.50
Pork Souvlaki Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$12.50
Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$12.50
Lamb Souvlaki Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$14.80
Grilled Chicken Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$12.50
Loukaniko Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$12.50
Grilled Shrimp Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$14.80
Falafel Sandwich Vegan. With hummus and tahini. Served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$11.35
Lamb, Beef Gyro & Chicken Doner Sandwich Combo Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$13.65
Skirt Steak Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$18.20
Keftedakia Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$12.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$12.50
Skepasti Sandwich Gyro panini – choice of beef and lamb gyro or chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, red onion, tzatziki, French fries and Mozzarella all pressed between 2 pitas. Sandwiches served with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tzatziki.	$19.35
Crispy Chicken Pita Sandwich Served with lettuce, tomato, onion and BBQ sauce.	$11.35
Wraps
Gyro Lovers Wrap Gyro, lettuce, tomato, red onion, and tzatziki.	$12.50
Athenian Wrap Chicken doner, lettuce, tomato, red onions, and tzatziki.	$12.50
Falafel Wrap Lettuce, tomato, onion, hummus, and tahini.	$11.35
Mediterranean Wrap Grilled chicken, Romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, olives, Feta cheese, and our house vinaigrette.	$13.65
Grilled Shrimp Wrap Grilled shrimp, Romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, peppers, avocado, and pink sauce.	$13.65
Chicken Caesar Wrap Romaine, Parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing, and grilled chicken.	$12.50
Chicken Club Wrap Grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and pink sauce.	$13.65
Honey Mustard Chicken Wrap Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard.	$12.50
Greek Salad Wrap Our Greek salad all wrapped up.	$11.35
Philly Steak Wrap Our Philly steak all wrapped up.	$13.65
Grilled Veggie Wrap Grilled veggies with lettuce.	$11.35
Steakhouse Wrap Skirt steak, Romaine, tomato, red onion, and Bleu cheese dressing.	$18.20
Greek Burrito Chicken, spicy Feta, rice, avocado, tomato and onion.	$13.65
Grecian Wrap Chicken souvlaki, lettuce, tomato, red onion, and tzatziki.	$12.50
Platters
Lamb & Beef Gyro Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$22.75
Chicken Doner Gyro Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$22.75
Pork Souvlaki Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$22.75
Chicken Souvlaki Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$22.75
Lamb Souvlaki Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$27.35
Grilled Chicken Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$22.75
Loukaniko Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$22.75
Grilled Shrimp Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$28.45
Falafel Platter Vegan. Served with hummus and tahini. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$21.65
Lamb, Beef Gyro & Chicken Doner Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$23.70
Souvlaki Combo Pork & Chicken Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$22.75
Skirt Steak Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$29.60
Surf & Turf Platter Skirt steak and grilled shrimp. All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$31.90
Keftedakia Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$22.75
Moussaka Platter All platters come with choice of rice, lemon potatoes, veggies or French fries. A side of Greek salad or soup. Tzatziki and pita bread.	$25.05
Char-Broiled Angus Burger
Cheeseburger Choice of American or Mozzarella.	$10.25
Classic Burger Lettuce, tomato and pickle.	$9.10
Greek Burger Feta, tomato and onion.	$10.25
Grilled Chicken Burger	$9.10
Philly Steak Burger Peppers, onions and cheese.	$10.25
Falafel Burger Vegan. Hummus, lettuce, tomato and pickle.	$8.55
Greekalicious Combos
Souvlaki Feast Combo 10 pork or chicken skewers, pita bread, tzatziki, fresh cut fries, Greek salad, and 1.25 liter soda.	$79.75
Gyro Lovers Combo Choice of 4 gyro sandwiches (lamb, beef or chicken doner), fresh cut fries, Greek salad, and 1.25 liter soda.	$68.35
Family Style Combo 1/2 tray lamb, beef and chicken gyro, 1/2 tray rice or French fries, 1/2 tray Greek salad, pita bread, tzatziki and (12) loukoumades with honey cinnamon.	$113.95
Kids Menu
Kid’s Gyro & Fries Plate	$13.65
Kid’s Chicken Tenders (3) & Fries	$13.65
Kid’s Mozzarella Sticks (4) & Fries	$13.65
Kid’s Box Choice of meat, lettuce, tomato, onion, Feta, rice or fresh cut fries.	$17.05
Kid’s Hamburger & Fries	$13.65
Kid’s Souvlaki & Fries Plate	$13.65
Sides
Fresh Cut Fries Vegan.	$6.80
Greek Fries With crumbled Feta and oregano.	$9.70
Curly Fries	$7.95
Onion Rings	$7.95
Lemon Potatoes	$9.10
Rice	$6.80
Lamb & Beef Gyro Shaved spiced lamb and beef served with tzatziki.	$11.35
Chicken Doner Marinated shaved chicken served with tzatziki.	$11.35
Grilled Chicken Marinated by Greekalicious.	$11.35
Cheese Fries	$9.10
Bacon Cheese Fries	$12.50
Philly Steak Fries Philly steak, onions, peppers and cheese sauce.	$17.05
Grilled Veggies Vegan.	$9.10
Greek Salad Jr	$7.95
Sweet Potato Fries	$7.95
Dips
Tzatziki Dip Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.	$8.55
Tyrokafteri Dip Spicy Feta dip. Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.	$10.25
Hummus Dip Vegan. Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.	$8.55
Dip Combo (4) Served with toasted regular or whole wheat pita.	$31.90
Extras
Tzatziki Small.	$1.15
Pink Sauce Small.	$1.15
Red Sauce Small.	$1.15
Pita Bread	$1.45
Whole Wheat Pita Bread	$1.75
Desserts
Baklava	$6.80
Rice Pudding	$5.65
Greek Zeppoles Loukoumades.	$5.65
Greek Yogurt	$6.80
Fried Oreos (5)	$7.95
Galaktoboureko Custard pie.	$7.45
Revani Semolina cake.	$7.45
Beverages
Canned Soda	$1.75
20 Oz. Bottled Soda	$3.40
Snapple	$3.40
Bottled Water	$1.75
1.25 Liter Soda	$4.30
Coffee	$2.00
Greek Frappe	$5.15
Stewarts	$3.40
Iced Coffee	$4.60
Greek Specialty Drink	$3.40
Classic Glass Bottles	$3.40
Fresh Lemonade	$4.00
Sour Cherry Lemonade	$4.60

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

chuck norris

20 dollars for a gyro and small order of fries is crazy. With that being said the food was good. Gyro meat was very flavorful and fries were cooked just right. If it wasn’t so expensive I’d be back.

… more

M Joseph

Quite possibly some of the WORST Greek food I’ve ever eaten. Ordered a Greek salad to go and the bottom of the plastic to go tray was filled with easily a Quarter inch of water, who the hell serves salad with water like that???? The lettuce was all soggy and the salad was ruined. Friggin Gross. The chicken that came with the salad had the consistency of a rubber band too. Just flat out disgusting food. NEVER again. Garbage.

… more

Andrew Taylor

I’ve been here a couple times now and enjoy it each time

… more

A. V.B.

The lunch specials really helped the cost to be more reasonable. The chicken gyro lunch special was a great size and was delicious. Gyro had a lot of tzatziki if you like that (I do). The lunch special with spinach pie and greek salad was good too but definitely a lot less food compared to the gyro. The spicy feta app was good but the chips were too aggressively seasoned. I probably would skip that next time. Service was friendly and fairly quick. A few small tables available for dine in.

… more

Francesco Pipitone

Average gyro. Shredded lettuce was straight from the bag and brown, tasted like plastic.

… more

Brian Morgan

Wow! This little place is awesome! Try the #8 for lunch. Gyro and fries. The gyro is perfect, moist and tastes wonderful and the fries are excellent. Wash it down with a fresh squeezed lemonade and you’re in Greek heaven!

… more

Andrew

Ordered online. Food was great. Portions were on the smaller side for the platter. A bit expensive when ordering online because of Grub Hub.

… more

SAVN PRODUCTIONS

Did a uber eats order and was disappointed with the food. Only thing that I would say i enjoyed eating was the salad. I ordered a lamb and chicken gyro with an order of fries. The fries were all burnt btw and the chicken was over done and dry. Had to toss most of it because it was just not enjoyable. What a waste of my $34.

… more

david stacey

After going to Abe’s for the past 30 years. Lately it’s been going way down hill so we decided to try this place out. My favorite new place! The food and service is wonderful. Thanks guys.

… more

Carlito Campiglia

I’ve been here once with my best friend. Food was amazing and staff was so polite and respectful. The young girl, Morgan, who took my order was so polite and friendly. If your looking for some great food definitely visit Simply Greekalicious. Will for sure be back!

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Simply Greekalicious Menu – Wantagh, NY

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions