Homey restaurant whipping up pizzas & other Italian specialties in a straightforward space. Based on 277 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
321 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: (845) 791-7662
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Reviews
Stefan H
Got $250 worth of food for a client lunch. Chicken wings were awful! Chicken Parmesan and pizza were okay. Baked ziti was actually good. Service was adequate. I will try other places before returning.
… more
Nyk L.
Yikes. Greasy, dirty, and the food is gross! The servers were the only good thing about this place. Nothing Italian feeling about this. The pizza was floppy and loaded in oils couldn’t even fold it. Tried getting a haiwaii style and was just slapped with cold deli meat smacked on my pizza and a single pineapple. The pasta sauce was barf worthy. Definitely do not eat here!
… more
Nancy Lopez
Pizza is decent probably the best choice in the village of Monticello. Wings are not good. Tastes like old fry oil. Service is adequate. They recently changed their dining room to the other side. Lots of stuff changing in shopping center. I never ate here always take out. No atmosphere really.
… more
Christy
All that I can say is Wow!!! Siena’s, not sure what magic you use to make the sicillian pizza’s but they are amazing!! I travel all the way from Maryland and when I am in the area, Siena’s is always a must visit for the sicillian pizza. It has the flakiest crust and is almost croissant like, the mozzarella cheese is top notch and of good quality. The sauce is a perfect blend of sweet yet savory and is made with real tomatoes. The pizza is a perfect balance of a breakfast and a dinner as the crust is almost identical to a croissant. I’m highly impressed with Siena’s and also enjoy the ability to order via their online app and pick up curbside. Very friendly staff and consistently amazing food! The large sicillian is big enough for several meals. You definitely get your money’s worth. Thank you Siena’s, I will continue to visit when I am in town
… more
barbara V
Nice pie. $12.96 for a 14-in Neapolitan pizza pie. Hard price to be and the flavors just great.
… more
Denise Hogan-Gennaro
The Pizza here is in the top 2 best in Monticello however the rest of the menu leaves much to be desired, the options are ok the menu is neither lack of options or extensive it’s adequate to say the least. However for what they do offer the food is not of the greatest quality could be much better just to bring it up to satisfying the one exception beside the pizza that is of a top quality is the Chicken noodle soup it’s actually quite impressive for a pizzeria how good this freshly made homestyle chicken noodle soup is. Also they are very good with delivery in every aspect from meeting the time they say to the price asked for the service and I highly accredited them for staying with offering this delivery service directly through them from in house instead of switching over to one of the many other new delivery services offered online now such as door dash and Uber, that raise the cost of the order by a 30-50% mark up by the the me you get done paying delivery tax and fees and tips. The fact that Siena’s offers the service directly and at the low cost fee excuse any lack in food taste or options as it is decent food great pizza that you can order out and afford.
… more
Melissa Hendrickson
Delicious food and friendly service! We loved the chicken roll and were really impressed by the lovely presentation of the mozzarella caprese appetizer which we also enjoyed.
… more
Jasmine Russell
they are immature and have bad customer service. they laughed in my face and said they wouldn’t sell to me because i told them that their employee was rude.
… more
Lil Lamont
Food is mediocre pizza was really greasy this order but..better then broadway garlic knotts were so small
… more
James Elphingstone
Food is great. The service is friendly and quick.
… more
… View more