Sibley Gardens Menu – Trenton, MI

Type : Italian restaurant

Location : Trenton, MI

Longtime eatery offers traditional Italian & American fare in a wooden interior with leather booths. Based on 879 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Sibley Gardens 48183

Address:
916 W Jefferson Ave, Trenton, MI 48183

Phone: (734) 285-1707

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
 11:30 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday 3–9 PM
Sunday Closed

Menu

Dinner Menu
Goat Cheese Napoleon
creamy goat cheese, roasted garlic, roasted red peppers, basil pesto and pine nuts layered and served with toasted tuscan bread and olive oil		 $16.95
Brick Steak
tenderloin tips sauteed with garlic and wine, served with garlic bread		 $18.95
Bacon Cajun Shrimp
gulf shrimp wrapped in bacon, cajun spiced and broiled		 $16.95
Italian Sausage
sauteed with peppers and onions		 $12.95
Escargot
Sauteed in garlic bacon butter, with sliced sea scallops and musroom caps		 $19.95
Mushrooms Or Zucchini
Lightly coated and deep fried		 $7.95
Onion Rings
Hand dipped and deep fried		 $7.95
San Marzano Bruschetta
Toasted San Marzano tomatoes, marinated with basil, garlic and a blend of Italian cheeses, served with toasted garlic bread and balsamic glaze.		 $10.95
Calamari
Tender cuts of Calamari steak, lightly breaded and fried. With our remoulade sauce.		 $15.95
Antipasto Platter
Italian meats and cheeses served with a variety of accompaniments. Serves two		 $14.95
Shrimp Cocktail
Wild caught, poached and chilled with our house made cocktail sauce.		 $15.95
Mozzarella Caprese
Slices of fresh mozzarella and Roma tomatoes, over mixed greens, basil pesto and garnished with roasted shallots, pine nuts and balsamic glaze.		 $12.95
Mediterranean Salad
Mixed greens tossed in an olive oil, lemon vinaigrette with feta cheese, tomatoes, red onion, Kalamata olives, beets, and pita chips		 $15.95
Mandarin Shrimp Salad
Fresh arugula tossed with almonds, oranges, diced red peppers, cucumbers and a sesame ginger vinaigrette. Topped with panko fried shrimp		 $20.95
Citrus Salmon Salad
Grilled salmon, Mandarin oranges, red bell pepper, shaved red onion and toasted almonds on mixed greens with Mango Chardonnay vinaigrette		 $22.95
Atlantic Salmon
broiled, citrus beurre blanc		 $27.95
Coconut Shrimp
gulf shrimp in a coconut batter served with marmalade sauce		 $26.95
Lake Perch Fillets
Lightly seasoned and fried, with our tartar sauce and lemon		 $32.95
Gulf Shrimp
Lightly breaded and deep fried		 $26.95
Brown Butter Icelandic Cod
Fresh Atlantic Cod, broiled with a browned lemon herb butter		 $26.95
Shrimp Bruschetta
Gulf Shrimp, rolled in garlic and bread crumbs then broiled, garnished with marinated San Marzano tomatoes, capers and lemon		 $28.95
Seared Scallops Classico
Beautiful sea scallops, lightly dusted with paprika, pan seared and served over an extra virgin olive oil lemon herb citronette		 $36.95
Lobster Tail
a beautiful 8 ounce cold water tail, broiled and served with drawn butter.		 $59.95
Surf & Turf
A broiled 8 ounce cold water tail and our 8 ounce Filet Mignon		 $89.95
Sonoma Chicken
breast medallions simmered in a white wine sauce with lemon, capers, artichoke hearts and sun dried tomatoes		 $24.95
Chicken Leelanau
breast of chicken with dried cherries and walnuts in a marsala cream sauce		 $24.95
Chicken Milanese
a boneless breast lightly coated with our unique blend of parmesan, breadcrumbs and herbs, served with a stuffed broiled tomato		 $26.95
Marsala
tender medallions sauteed with marsala and mushrooms		 $24.95
Piccante
tender medallions sauteed in wine and lemon		 $23.95
Parmigiana
breaded and fried, then baked with two cheeses and tomato sauce		 $24.95
Tosca
with a parmesan and egg batter, sauteed and served with lemon		 $24.95
Roberto
Sauteed with lemon, white wine, and sweet and hot peppers.		 $24.95
Tortelloni Palomino
Italian cheese filled pasta in a tomato cream sauce, topped with fresh basil.		 $22.95
Fettuccini Alfredo
creamy parmesan sauce over fettuccini		 $21.95
Homemade Ravioli
hand made and filled with meat, served with our savory tomato sauce		 $24.95
Meat Lover’s Pasta
hope you’re hungry! penne with meat sauce, meatballs and italian sausage topped with mozzarella and baked		 $26.95
Mediterranean Pasta
Penne tossed with roasted red peppers, sun dried tomatoes, spinach, goat cheese, tomatoes, pine nuts kalamata olives, basil and garlic olive oil.		 $24.95
Pasta Bolognese
Our old world Bolognese sauce slowly simmered with braised tenderloin. Served over pappardelle pasta.		 $24.95
Linguini Aglio Olio
Linguini noodles sauteed with roasted garlic oil, San Marzano tomatoes, chicken stock and fresh herbs		 $21.95
Penne Arabiatta
A devilishly blend of ground Italian sausage simmered in a spicy red sauced and tossed with penne pasta. For an extra kick add hot peppers!		 $22.95
Steak Sammy
a customer favorite! medallions of beef tenderloin sauteed with wine, garlic and parsley		 $29.95
Filet Mignon
a center cut choice filet served with cabernet demi glace		 $44.95
New York Strip
A 14 ounce Certified Prime New York Strip. Add a side of zip sauce.		 $52.95
20 Ounce Bone In Ribeye
A 20 ounce Prime center cut beauty. Char-grilled.		 $54.95
Sibley Burger
our famous 1/2lb ground sirloin broiled to order and served on a toasted sibley roll		 $14.95
Steak Sammy Sandwich
our own steak sammy served on a sibley roll with the sammy sauce on the side for dipping		 $25.95
Special Baked Potato
Our famous twice baked potato, loaded with sauteed onions, bacon, cheese and sour cream. Big enough to share.		 $6.95
Sibley’s Wedge Salad
A generous wedge of Iceberg lettuce, with crumbled bacon, grape tomatoes, and topped with our house made Roquefort dressing		 $8.95
Lunch Menu
Goat Cheese Napoleon
creamy goat cheese, roasted garlic, roasted red peppers, basil pesto and pine nuts layered and served with toasted tuscan bread		 $16.95
Bacon Cajun Shrimp
gulf shrimp wrapped in bacon, cajun spiced and broiled		 $16.95
Antipasto Platter
italian meats and cheeses served with a variety of accompaniments		 $14.95
Brick Steak
tenderloin tips sauteed with garlic and wine, served with garlic bread		 $18.95
Italian Sausage
sauteed with peppers and onions		 $12.95
Calamari
tender cuts of the steak, lightly breaded and fried with peppers. remoulade sauce		 $15.95
Onion Rings
hand dipped and deep fried		 $7.95
Shrimp Cocktail
with lemon and cocktail sauce		 $15.95
Mushrooms Or Zucchini
lightly coated and deep fried		 $7.95
Soup Of The Day $2.95
French Onion Soup Au Gratin $4.95
Citrus Salmon Salad
grilled salmon, mandarin oranges, red pepper, shaved red onion and toasted almonds on mixed greens with mango chardonnay vinaigrette		 $20.95
Mandarin Shrimp Salad
Fresh arugula tossed with almonds, oranges, diced red peppers, cucumbers and a sesame ginger viniagrette. Topped with panko fried shrimp.		 $19.95
Salad And Soup
your choice of a half sammy caesar, half michigan cherry or a tossed salad with a bowl of soup		 $9.95
Sibley Burger
our famous 1/2lb ground sirloin broiled to order and served on a toasted sibley roll		 $13.95
Classic Club Sandwich
Choice of white, rye or wheat toast with our sliced roas turkey breast, bacon, lettuce and tomato. With mayo. Served with fries.		 $13.95
Steak Sammy Sandwich
our own steak sammy served on a sibley roll with the sammy sauce on the side for dipping		 $25.95
Over Roasted Turkey Breast Sandwich
Our oven roasted sliced turkey breast on white, rye or wheat bread. With lettuce, tomato, Havarti cheese, and mayo. Served with fries.		 $11.95
Chicken Picante Sandwich
Two breast medallions, sauteed in our picante sauce and served on a Sibley roll.		 $15.95
Meatball Hoagie
Our house made beef tenderloin meatballs, with melted mozzarella on a Sibley Roll		 $14.95
Pasta Bolognese Pappardelle
Our old world Bolognese sauce. Slowly simmered, made with beef tenderloin. Served over fresh Pappardelle pasta.		 $21.95
Penne Arabiatta
A devilishly blend of ground Italian sausage simmered in a spicy red sauce and tossed with penne pasta. For an extra kick add hot peppers!		 $18.95
Mediterranean Pasta
penne tossed with roasted red peppers, dried tomatoes, spinach, goat cheese, tomatoes, pine nuts, kalamata olives, basil and garlic olive oil		 $21.95
Linguini Aglio Olio
Linguini noodles sauteed with roasted garlic oil, San Marzano tomatoes, chicken stock and fresh herbs.		 $18.95
Fettuccini Alfredo
creamy parmesan sauce over fettuccini		 $18.95
Homemade Ravioli
hand made and filled with meat, served with our savory tomato sauce		 $21.95
Lake Perch Fillets
lightly seasoned and fried		 $26.95
Coconut Shrimp
gulf shrimp in a coconut batter served with marmalade sauce		 $22.95
Chicken Leelanau
breast of chicken with dried cherries and walnuts in a marsala cream sauce		 $19.95
Chicken Marsala
Breast medallions sauteed in our Marsala, mushroom, wine sauce.		 $19.95
Chicken Piccante
tender breast medallions sauteed with wine, lemon and a touch of garlic		 $18.95
Steak Sammy
a customer favorite! two medallions of beef tenderloin sauteed with wine, garlic and parsley		 $29.95
Atlantic Salmon
A broiled fresh fillet, with our citrus beurre blanc.		 $22.95
Brown Butter Icelandic Cod
Lemon pepper, coated fillet on a bed of sautéed spinach, with citrus beurre blanc.		 $19.95
Bass Ale Fish & Chips
Icelandic Cod, fried in a Bass Ale batter and served with our fries, lemon and tartar.		 $19.95
Sonoma Chicken
In a white wine, lemon sauce. With capers, artichoke hearts, and sundried tomatoes.		 $19.95
Family Style Dinners Menu
Bruschetta
toasted tuscan bread with roma tomatoes, mozzarella and basil
Mixed Greens
with our balsamic viniagrette
Italian Sausage
with peppers and onions.
Chicken Piccante
breast medallions sauteed with a lemon wine sauce.
Chicken Scaloppine
sauteed in a tomato mushroom wine sauce.
Chicken Tosca
breast medallions in a parmigiana and egg batter, sauteed.
Grilled Salmon
with citrus beurre blanc.
Steak Sammy
medallions of beef tenderloin sauteed with wine, garlic and parsley.
Veal Scaloppine
with a tomato mushroom sauce. add an item for an additional
Veal Marsala
with a marsala cream sauce.
Sonoma Chicken
With capers, sun dried tomatoes, and artichoke hearts, simmered in a lemon wine sauce.
Veal Tosca
In our parmesan, egg batter.
Mostaccioli With Tomato Sauce
Spaghetti With Garlic And Oil
Fettuccini Alfredo
Fettuccini With Pesto Cream
Ice Cream

… View more

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Scott
Have lived downriver for 40 years and have never been in here. We decided to eat here for my 40th birthday and it was a good choice. I got the veal parmigiana, my wife got the chicken piccante, and our daughter got the Alfredo with grilled chicken added. We all thought the food was delicious, only issue is that it was a little over priced. This is definitely one of those special occasion restaurants. Not sure why it took us so long to give it a try but I’m sure we will be back soon for another special occasion.

Lynn Kowalske
The food was good. The average prices for a meal was between 30 and 40 dollars. Steaks were between 47 and 59. It was the type of restaurant you go to for very special occasions. It will not disappoint. The only thing I had go wrong with our visit was the amount of time it took to get our food. Many people who came at the same time were served and left and tables reseated and were also served before we received our food. Our wait time was 1.5 hours. I almost paid for our drinks and decided to leave. The waitress was kind and very professionable. Yes I would recommend but I am not sure I will return.

katie fay
The napoleon appetizer and calamari were a great start. The bolognese was a real treat.

Janet Leski
Good food, greeters were great coming in the door, super friendly. Server started out strong but was slower as the meal went on. Atmosphere was nice but loud because of a nearby table. Wine list could improve with more Old World wines. I’ll return to try out again though.

Douglas Bassett
Flew in from Phoenix to visit my dad and it’s been a couple years since I’ve been to Sibley Gardens. I had the perch and my wife had the walleye. Both dishes were amazing. Definitely would recommend. Nicole was great. All around great experience.

DeeRae xxx
My husband and I just went there for the first time tonight and we were both absolutely BLOWN AWAY by how delicious everything was, and how friendly, fast and welcoming all of the staff we encountered were. We will definitely make this place somewhere we go often for dinner because even hours after, we can’t stop talking about it. We’ve been telling family and friends all about the experience and just how delicious it all was!

Melissa Behring
Great date night in a secluded corner booth. Fantastic service. Cold martini. Perfectly seared scallops… and a side of spaghetti. Old school Italian done right. Love this place

Jessica Hallock (Jess)
The food was simply divine. Everything was hot, fresh, and cooked perfectly. The atmosphere was charming and elegant without being too fancy. I’ve raved about this place to every one I know. Can’t wait to go back

Gabrielle McCarthy
We had a large party for my moms bday. We ended up having more guests than expected and they were extremely accommodating and polite.

Gebo’s Garage
The one thing that keeps us coming back is consistency.

… View more

Related:

  1. Ramsey’s Family Restaurant and Coney Island Menu – Trenton, MI
  2. Tim Hortons Menu – Trenton, MI
  3. Maria’s Mexican Grill Menu – Trenton, MI
  4. TV’s Grand Event Menu – Trenton, MI

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch
×
Photo Image