Sherrilli’s Pizzeria Menu – Sellersburg, IN

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Sellersburg, IN

Based on 724 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Sherrilli's Pizzeria 47172

Address:
496 N Indiana Ave, Sellersburg, IN 47172

Phone: (812) 246-3346

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 12–10 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–10 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM

Menu

FOOD
Breadsticks Single (3) $3.10
Breadsticks Family (6) $5.85
Garlic Toast $2.75
Hot Wings/BBQ Wings (10) $16.25
Hot Wings/BBQ Wings (5) $8.15
Pickles & Chips $1.75
Nachos & Cheese $3.10
Giant Pretzel $2.25
Garlic Cheese Bread (4) $4.25
Garlic Cheese Bread (8) $8.05
Buffalo Chicken Bites (5) $7.10
BBQ Chicken Bites (5) $7.10
Buffalo Chicken Bites (12) $12.25
BBQ Chicken Bites (12) $12.25
Sherrilli’s Gold Bites (5) $7.10
Sherrilli’s Gold Bites(12) $12.10
Chef Salad $6.23
Tossed Salad $2.99
The Rob $10.50
10″ Cheese $9.00
10″ Deluxe $11.00
10″ Bar-B-Q $9.50
10″ Bar-B-Q Chicken $10.00
10″ Chicken Bacon Ranch $10.00
10″ Buffalo Chicken $10.00
10″ Veggie $10.50
10″ Supreme $14.49
10″ All Meat $13.49
Cauliflower Crust $11.00
14″ Cheese $13.50
14″ Deluxe $16.50
14″ Bar-B-Q $15.50
14″ Bar-B-Q Chicken $15.50
14″ Chicken Bacon Ranch $15.50
14″ Buffalo Chicken $15.50
14″ Veggie $15.75
14″ Supreme $21.49
14″ All Meat $20.49
16″ Cheese $15.89
16″ Deluxe $20.15
16″ Bar-B-Q $19.25
16″ Bar-B-Q Chicken $19.25
16″ Chicken Bacon Ranch $19.25
16″ Buffalo Chicken $19.25
16″ Veggie $18.99
16″ Supreme $25.99
16″ All Meat $24.50
16″ The Rob $32.00
Half Stromboli $5.10
Whole Stromboli $8.99
Half Veg Stromboli $4.99
Whole Veg Stromboli $8.10
Half Texas B-B-Q $4.99
Whole Texas B-B-Q $8.99
Half Steak Hoagie $5.10
Whole Steak Hoagie $8.59
Half Hot Ham & Cheese $4.50
Whole Hot Ham & Cheese $8.49
Baked Spaghetti $7.65
Half Chicken Bacon Ranch $5.10
Whole Chicken Bacon Ranch $8.49
Crust Less Pizza $8.99
Whole Pizza Roll $12.50
1/2 Pizza Roll $7.50
Nacho Cheese $0.61
Marinara $0.61
Jalepenos $0.50
Banana Peppers $0.50
Garlic Butter $0.37
Dressings $0.61
Parmesean $0.25
Crushed Peppers $0.25
Pizza Paste $0.25
Pan Cookie $7.99
Pan Brownie $7.99
14″ 1 Top, F Bs, 2 L1r $20 $20.00
16” 2 Top F BS 2 Ltr $25.00 $25.00
16″ One Top 2 Ltr $20.00 $20.00
2-16″2 Top F BS $40 $40.00
The Rob 16″ All Meat Xtra Sauce Xtra Cheese $30.00
16″ 1 Topping $15 $15.00
16″ 1 Topping With FBS $20.00
DRINKS
2 Liter Cherry Coke $2.99
2 Liter Coke $2.99
2 Liter Diet Coke $2.99
2 Liter Sprite $2.99
Bud $3.00
Bud Light $3.00
Busch Light $3.00
Miller Light $3.00
Coors Light $3.00
Blue Moon $4.00
Seagram’s $3.50
Beer $2.50
T-shirts
Small-Xl Hoodie $30.00
2XL $40.00
3XL $45.00
S-LG T-Shirt $15.00
XL-3XL $20.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Bob R.
Ordered delivery, even though I live in a different city the pizza arrived quickly and hot. The driver was awesome and the food was amazing. I had never had their chicken bacon ranch pizza before and almost finished the entire thing by myself. I can’t say enough Good Things based on my first experience I’ll definitely be going back.

… more

Stephen
My family has been eating here for years. A unique style of pizza. It’s definitely worth check it out if you’re going to be nearby.

… more

James heath
Dudes working here are very friendly… Try the house flavor wings!!!! They are straight money!! The pizza didn’t look anything special but it was cooked perfect, then the crust was thin and crispy, just right on point!!! My kids absolutely loved the large soft pretzel with warm cheese…. Again props to the owners/management as these young dudes working were right on point with everything… Can’t wait to stop back in next time we’re in the neighborhood

… more

Chris Williams
The service we’ve gotten here is great. The food however is very hit-or-miss. I’ve gotten the buffet and special ordered pizzas and had two very different flavor experiences. The salads are nothing special, just bagged iceberg lettuce and a few generic salad bar toppings. The spaghetti looked terrible so I didn’t try it; I could hear my Italian ancestors crying. The pizza didn’t taste great either (the sauce didn’t have the right acid/sweetness balance) and looked like it had been made by kids. The special order pizzas were ordered much later in the day a few weeks after the buffet experience, and were much tastier. It’s not a terrible place to get a meal, but there’s definitely better pizza out there.

… more

Steven Johnson
They have a Monday through Friday lunch buffet, and like 11:00 to 4:00 on Saturdays and all day Sunday buffets.

… more

Kris Osborne
Been driving past this place for literally 2 years. Finally I took my 3yo and 5yo girls for the buffet. It was great. They tore it up. Great prt, great food and great service!

… more

BlinkOnceArmy2012 ehh?
Worst tasting cheese pizza ever. You would think you couldn’t go wrong with classic cheese but you can. The pizza was so bland and the sauce was oddly sweet. Not very good at all the cheese wasn’t even completely melted!

… more

Leslie Byerly
The employees are outstanding and take their time to help you know all the ways to save money ( joining their text messaging etc). The pizza is amazing, lot’s of toppings and great carry out specials. They also have a fantastic buffet! I highly recommend them! My family loves all of the items on the menu. Check them out online or stop in and enjoy the buffet.

… more

The Traveling Man
My first time here since Covid hit. Back then it was Sir Danos. The pizza was ok but the dining area and buffet are not following Covid protocols. Numerous people inside, nobody wearing a mask not even employees, people coughing not covering their mouths plus using the same plate on multiple trips to the buffet including employees of Clarksville Wastewater, there was 3 of them wearing the shirts driving city vehicles. People were eating the same old pizza that was out no new was ever brought out. Terrible experience. I’ll never be back.

… more

Tomi Abston
They used to be amazing, looks like they changed employees that are rude, we used to order their salads and a pizza every week and they cut the sizes down on the food with the same prices, no one can tell us what points we have earned without paying first so we can’t use them anymore, my husband grew up here and ate here for over 29 years and once he says he won’t be back he won’t…tonight he was done

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions