Neighborhood mainstay turning out creative pizza, red-sauce pasta & fountain sodas in low-key digs. Based on 913 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
901 Post Rd, Wells, ME 04090
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tim O’Leary
The Sicilian pizza was great. It’s a unique and delicious pizza and it serves 4 easily. The charred crust corner pieces are the best. Always a smile and always attentive staff. Wells does not have a better pizza place. I have had the Large plain pizza ($16.75) and it’s delicious too. Daje!
… more
Robert Pace
First time experience. Overall it was very good. Very pleasant staff. I only had two slices of pizza. But they were very good. I had a first, lasagna pizza. Very good. I would highly recommend Seacoast. So far. I’ll be back.
… more
Ally Fraser
Deeeelicious!!!! Wow. We got two pizzas and both were phenomenal. Definitely coming back. Sicilian and chicken bacon ranch
… more
TA Baker
Couldn’t have been more disappointed in our food experience last night. After ordering a Hawaiian pizza, mozzarella sticks and onion rings, it took an hour for the food to be ready. Ok fine, great reviews so maybe it’s just busy. Sure enough, went to pick up the food and there was a line out the door. Very encouraging. Friendly staff who directed me to the order pickup area, I got the food lane they double checked to make sure it was right— great service. Got the food home two minutes later and we started to and reality set in. Mozzarella sticks were cold, pizza was low on sauce and flavor all around, and it lacked a crispness on the edges you’d expect from a thin crust pizza. Onion rings, can’t forget those. Chewy and cold, couldn’t even finish them. High hopes after reading reviews for this place but not sure what went wrong here— I’m inclined to think the food was sitting around for a while before I received a text notification but who knows.
… more
Review Time With Tim
NY style pizza was good. Had the cheese pizza. Had a good taste to it. It reminded me of the pizza place Pappa Genos cheese pizza. Also had the BBq chicken pizza. Nice zingy taste. The knots were a bit of a miss. Overall good service. You can online order and pay so that was nice.
… more
Timmy Heigel
For a pizza joint in the middle of New England Vaca spot this is a quick easy pizza night if needed. Always busy but timing has been accurate, they know what they’re doing.
… more
Wally
Nice little spot, their fries were incredible and so was their pizza. I tried the lasagna, and it was okay, nothing special. Overall prices/quality were good
… more
Vinay Kodavatiganti
It is a real struggle to get pizza from here at the time they say it will be ready even if you order several hours in advance. The first time we wanted pizza, we ordered via Slice app and the pizza was ready 45 minutes after the ETA on the app. That seemed silly — why give an ETA only to be off by 45 min? Another couple in our group learned from this and ordered 2-1/2 hrs ahead of time over the phone the next time we wanted pizza. We showed up to pick up at the designated time but it took them 20 minutes to find the pizzas after we asked 4 people repeatedly to find them. One server seemed upset we were asking him to find pizzas ordered 2-1/2 hrs earlier. The pizzas were on top of the ovens the whome time but the disorganization was so complete, it took them 20 minutes to find them and give them to us. By then, they were just lukewarm and not nearly as good as they should have been. The woman behind us was told that her order via Slice would take another hour past the ETA (our experience from before) and she just canceled the order as a result. The pizza is typically good here, but no pizza is good enough to warrant such a disorganized mess. Unfortunate.
… more
Cathie Schneider
Ordered 2 pizzas and 2 salads at 5:11 pm for 3 adults and 3 kids. Pick up went from 6:15 to 6:55. Went at 6:50 and told it would not be ready until 8 pm.
… more
James LaRonde
Normally great pizza, BUT… DO NOT USE ONLINE ORDER SYSTEM. After a *3* hour wait (originally quoted at one hour), pizza still not in the oven and we finally cancelled our order to figure out a plan B. AVOID.
… more
… View more