Old-school counter-serve pizzeria also serving hoagies & wings in unpretentious surrounds. Based on 273 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3404 Fifth Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15213
Phone: (412) 687-9287
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10 AM–7 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jonathan Smith
Stopped in at the beginning of the lunch rush, visibly busy but was greeted with nice personable counter staff. Tangy slightly sweet sauce, chewy, light airy crumb. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese, perfectly cooked. Amazing food as always Tim and staff!
… more
Lauren
I’m happy I tried them a second time because it was absolutely delicious!! I first ordered from here about 2 years ago & honestly I didn’t see why they were so popular. To be fair it was in the middle of the lunch rush, they were very busy when I came in to pick up my order but they were so nice that I didn’t have the heart to give a bad review…everybody can have an off moment or day and good customer service goes a long way. Fast forward to the other week, I was craving a meatlovers pizza, they popped up in my Google search as a near by restaurant so figured why not give them another try for pickup after work. I ordered a small specialty pizza (which as you can see from the pics is very generous in size and toppings) I’m so happy I did. Everybody there was super nice including the owner, I’d told them about my previous experience & that I’d let them know how this turned out. Once I got home and tried it I called immediately to tell them how incredible it was! I have returned several times since & experienced great food and great people each time. The family like dynamic they have is genuinely heartwarming. I see now why they have such a great well deserved rating. Highly recommend!
… more
Nancy Ho
I got delivery from Slice, so I cannot comment on in person services, but this pizza is heavenly. Also, the delivery came 30 minutes early!!! The dough is nice and chewy, and it has its own flavor. Most pizza places put no love into its dough, so you can tell this place puts a lot of love into the food they make. The pepperoni and the mushrooms are cooked so well, and I asked for it to be crispy/well done, which it was! I asked for extra pep, and they delivered more than enough! Pairing these toppings with the beautifully risen dough makes for a wonderful flavor profile. The delivery driver was really nice as well. My dog keeps begging me for more!!! The price is so good too, very reasonable, as a kind of broke college student, and you get a LOT for what you pay for :)!!! Hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had in PGH, possibly my life, ever!
… more
Lexi Waltz
Had the pan pizza for the first time. It was sooooo good. Extremely cheesey and flavorful. Highly recommend!
… more
Matt Miller
Absolutely amazing pizza joint in Pittsburgh. Thehave got to be one of the best I’ve ever eaten. Definitely a go-to when in the Pittsburgh area. A lot of food for a very good price.
… more
Russ Waltz
Old school shop that also sells booze. We got the pan pizza, and it was great. Highly recommend if you are in the area.
… more
ginnaericka
Took my picky eating small appetite toddler after a doctor’s appointment on the recommendation of a friend. I ordered a 4 cut pizza with pepperoni and a lemonade. The pizza was yummy! My daughter actually ate almost half of the pizza, and that’s a lot of food for her. Great pizza, great prices.
… more
Carole Vankirk
First time I ate here, will not be the last. The Sicilian pizza is so very good! Crust, baked perfect. Sauce, very flavorful not bitter. Cheese and toppings were fresh and plenty. Staff was great, friendly and helpful. Prices are amazing. Can’t wait to go back! Great daily specials.
… more
Megan D
Wanted pizza so we stopped in for a quick bite to eat. Never been there and we ordered the 4 cut Sicilian. We easily could have gotten 2 pieces to share between the 2 of us, the pieces were huge and very good. We also got 2 20 Oz pops and our bill was $11. Great food, great prices and I love the old atmosphere in the shop. Definitely will be
… more
Eddie Fail
I’m in town from South Florida for a week with my 4 year old son for the Steelers game this Sunday. We were feeling lazy (he was) and decided to stay in for the night tonight. I looked online and saw this place and decided to give them a try after looking at their menu and pictures. I had to get on here and give them a review even after calling them as well. Their pizza was delicious and mouth watering. We got a large pepperoni and mushroom. It was so cheesy and so fresh. Perfectly made with the sauce. I just couldn’t help but scarf down 3 pieces right away. My 4 year old picky son even ate 2 pieces and it’s not easy to please this kid at all. The perfect cherry on top was the excellent customer service. The guy on the phone was so genuinely pleasant and friendly. The delivery was so fast. The girl who delivered it was also a friendly person. This is the kind of place that needs recognition. I am so full and satisfied. I highly recommend this place of business. If I decide to have another pizza before we leave, I will 100% not waste my time and go with anybody else. I don’t have time to experiment when I know what I’m getting with this place. Thank you guys! -Eddie
… more
… View more