Scarborough Fair Restaurant Menu – Sea Girt, NJ

Type : Fine dining restaurant

Location : Sea Girt, NJ

Special-occasion spot in a 19th-century farmhouse with romantic private dining & New American fare. Based on 594 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Scarborough Fair Restaurant 08750

Address:
1414 Meetinghouse Rd, Sea Girt, NJ 08750

Phone: (732) 223-6658

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–10 PM
Saturday 4–11 PM
Sunday 3–9 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

Dinner Menu
Charcuterie Board
chef’s choice of daily meats and cheese selections with traditional seasonal garnishes, toasted crostini’s
$20.00
Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
seared rare, Yuzu mignonette, seaweed salad, sweet soy drizzle
$14.00
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
red pepper and mango salsa, sweet chili sauce
$17.00
Crispy Calamari
pepperoncini, marinara, charred lemon, wasabi aioli, Thai chili
$13.00
Escargot En Croute
puff pastry cap, brie cheese, garlic-butter, scented with Pernod
$13.00
Baked Brussel Sprouts En Casserole
bacon, crumbled blue cheese, roasted shallots, and garlic marinade
$13.00
Burrata
roasted pepper, olive tapenade, pickled stone fruit, toasted pine nuts, fresh basil, baby arugula, EVOO, rustic bread
$14.00
Artichoke And Spinach Stuffed Portobella Mushroom
roasted red peppers, balsamic finish
$13.00
Spanakopita
phyllo pastry, spinach, feta cheese, fresh dill, Greek Salad
$13.00
Toasted Flatbread
melted brie cheese, grapes, toasted pine nuts, arugula, local honey drizzle
$14.00
Soup Of The Day $7.00
Seafood Bisque $9.00
Curry Roasted Fennel Salad
mixed field greens, sweet red pepper, crispy chickpeas, curried roasted fennel, with a rosemary tahini dressing
$11.00
Ruby Salad
roasted beets, red cabbage, red onion, baby spinach, crumbled Feta cheese, white balsamic vinaigrette, pistachios
$12.00
Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce, caesar dressing, herbed croutons, shaved parmesan
$14.00
Chop-Chop Greek Salad
romaine lettuce, red onion, diced tomatoes, cucumbers, Feta, Kalamata olives, pepperoncini, Greek vinaigrette
$10.00
Chicken Breast $8.00
Jumbo Shrimp $12.00
Sliced Angus Steak $16.00
Filet Mignon
Rosemary garlic roasted potatoes, grilled asparagus, port wine balsamic glaze. Alternate Preparations meats available upon request: Au Poivre, Bordelaise, Port wine balsamic, Fromage
$46.00
14oz Black Angus Strip
Whipped potatoes, sautéed spinach, brandy au poivre sauce. Alternate Preparations meats available upon request: Au Poivre, Bordelaise, Port wine balsamic, Fromage
$37.00
Grilled Rack Of Lamb Of Chops
Marinated in EVOO, fresh herbs & spices, whipped potatoes, asparagus, bordelaise sauce. Alternate Preparations meats available upon request: Au Poivre, Bordelaise, Port wine balsamic, Fromage
$42.00
Veal Osso Bucco
mushroom risotto, braised mirepoix vegetables, garden peas, natural pan au jus
$42.00
Grilled 10 Oz Boneless Pork Chop
sticky rice, stir fry vegetables, sesame ginger umami soy sauce
$30.00
Herb Roasted Airline Chicken
Murray’s breast meat, pan seared over asparagus-Manchego risotto, baby carrots, pan sauce
$27.00
Shrimp Athenia
egg fettuccini noodles tossed with jumbo wild shrimp, herbs, Italian plum tomatoes, white wine, feta cheese
$29.00
Oven Roasted Salmon
topped with tomato compote, Mediterranean olive couscous, Baby carrots, Pernod herbed butter sauce
$30.00
Pistachio Dusted Sea Scallops
parsnip cauliflower puree, fall vegetable, maple butter nut squash sauce
$38.00
Seafood Medley
local clams & scallops, shrimp, calamari, New Zealand mussels sautéed in butter with tomato, broccoli rabe over creamy polenta
$38.00
Wild Mushroom Ravioli
tomato concasse, caramelized shallots, wild mushrooms, peas, Parmigiano cream sauce
$24.00
Pan Seared Hearts Of Palm
sweet & spicy basil red curry, seasonal vegetables, quinoa blend
$24.00
Baby Carrots
Grilled Asparagus
Sautéed Spinach
Sautéed Forest Mushrooms
Whipped Potatoes
Mushroom Risotto
Rosemary Garlic Roasted Potatoe
Wine Menu
Villa Sandi, Italy $8.00
Rascal Pinot Gris, Oregon $34.00
Barone Fini Valdadige, Italy $12.00
Santa Margarita, Italy $54.00
Spellbound, California $9.00
Lohr Riverstone, Monterey $35.00
Josh Cellars Reserve, North Coast $13.00
The Calling, Sonoma Coast $16.00
Louis Jadot Pouilly-Fuisse, France $59.00
Simi Russian River, Sonoma $60.00
Emblem, Napa Valley $66.00
Jordan Russian River, Sonoma $75.00
Squealing Pig, New Zealand $10.00
Liquid Light, Washington $13.00
Peju Province, Napa Valley $42.00
Charles & Charles Riesling, WA $9.00
Villa Pozzi Moscato, Italy $9.00
Ogier Artesis Cotes Du Rhone, France $32.00
Don Olegario Albarino, Spain $40.00
Gentilini Robola Wild Paths, Ionian Islands $49.00
Bieler Sabine, France $10.00
Ruffino Sparking, Italy $9.00
Gerard Bartrand Cote De Roses, France $39.00
Chateau Beaulieu Cuvee, France $49.00
Spellbound, California $9.00
Louis Jadot Beaujolais Villages, France $36.00
Chemistry, Oregon $13.00
La Crema, Sonoma $18.00
Meiomi, California $50.00
Maison Champy Cuvee Edme, France $61.00
The Calling, Russian River $70.00
Twomey Cellars, Anderson Valley $93.00
Hess Alomi, Napa Valley $24.00
Spellbound, California $9.00
Lohr Seven Oaks, Paso Robles $13.00
Borne Of Fire, Columbia Valley $43.00
Bonanza, California $17.00
The Calling, Alexander Valley $69.00
Mt. Veeder, Napa Valley $80.00
Raymond Reserve, Napa Valley $94.00
Stags Leap Artemis, Napa Valley $115.00
Spellbound, California $9.00
Decoy, Sonoma $48.00
Oberon, Napa Valley $52.00
Crios, Argentina $10.00
Zuccardi “Q”, Mendoza, Argentin $40.00
Terra D’Oro Deaver Ranch, Amador $49.00
Baron Riscoli Chianti, Italy $10.00
Tenuta Di Ghizzano ‘IL Ghizzano’, Italy $40.00
Villa Rosa Barolo, Italy $53.00
Piccini Brunello Di Montalcino, Italy $79.00
Ruffino Classico Reserva Chianti, Italy $85.00
Marques De Riscal Reserve Rioja, Spain $42.00
Shatter Grenache, France $46.00
Intrinsic Bordeaux Blend, Washington $53.00
Mondavi Maestro Bordeaux, Napa Valley $69.00
Stag’s Leap Petite Sirah, Napa Valley $78.00
Girard Artistry Blend, Napa Valley $90.00
Prisoner Red Blend, Napa Valley $110.00
Jordan Cabernet, Alexander Valley
Wine Enthusiast: 92 points
$120.00
Silver Oak Cabernet, Alexander Valley
Wine Advocate: 98 points
$165.00
Caymus Cabernet, Napa Valley
Wine Spectator: 91 points
$190.00
Opus One “Overture”, Napa Valley $195.00
Opus “One”, Napa Valley
Wine Spectator: 94 points
$490.00
La Contesse Prosecco, Veneto Italy $8.00
Freixenet Cava Brut Negro, Spain $7.00
Avissi Prosecco, Italy $35.00
Piper Sonoma Brut, California $39.00
Piper-Heidsieck Cuvee Brut 1785, France $68.00
Moet & Chandon Imperial, France $100.00
Dom Perignon, France $315.00
Budweiser $5.00
Bud Light $5.00
Coors Light $5.00
Yuengling $5.00
Bass Ale $6.00
Heineken $6.00
Corona $6.00
Stella Artois $6.00
Angry Orchard Cider $7.00
Dogfish Head Seasonal $7.00
Miller Light $5.00
Guinness $6.00
Sam Adams Seasonal $6.00
Coney Island Mermaid Pilsner $6.00
Kane Brewing Cloud Cover $7.00
Toms River Brewery IPA $7.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Steve X
This is an elegant fine dining restaurant. There is a large seating area near the bar, a more secluded room known as the Octagon, and private tables along the stairway known as “stair seating”, which must be specifically reserved in advance. We ate in the Octagon room, which was very nice, but will request stair seating next time we return.

… more

Clark Neumany
Enjoyed a great meal everything was very flavorful and cooked just the way we liked. Only thing that was off was the food didn’t come out hot it was warm. I like my food piping hot.

… more

Leah
one of the best restaurants I’ve ever eaten. it was beautifully decorated for Christmas. there are a ton of stairs so you should be aware of that. the food is absolutely phenomenal. our server was incredible. it’s rather expensive but completely worth it. a great place for an anniversary dinner or other special event.

… more

Alexander Gribtsov
What a wonderful little gem with delicious food. This is one of those times where I wish the Google review system had 4.5 or 4.75 starts. It was almost a flawless Mother’s Day brunch. This was our first time at this restaurant and I must say the atmosphere is very chic, romantic and not over the top. Our waitress was friendly and very much on top of her game when it came to adjustments that were requested by my girls. We will definitely be back for a romantic dinner.

… more

Taylor
We recently dinned here for my birthday. The parking was easy, walking up to the restaurant was beautiful. The hostess was sweet and prompt. We had a reservation. The hostess sprinkled happy birthday confetti on the table as she sat us which was so unique and fun. Our server came over to us and asked for our drink order. She then came back a minute later and said, “You know I’m going to have to ID you guys right”.. that wasn’t the issue at all, it was the way she said it as if we were trying to get away with it? I understand we may look young but we are 26 & 27. There’s no way I looked under 21 for her to treat us like that. Now that was the start of it. She barely interacted with us. We didn’t receive bread, when we noticed all the tables she had around us did, and they sat after us. The appetizer was delicious, bacon wrapped shrimp with mango! Now our entrees took between 30-40 minutes. She came over to us at an empty table and asked if we were waiting to eat or if we ate already… we said we were still waiting for our entrees. After we ate more than half our steaks, with two bites left, with no steak knife, no check in to see how we were until two bites left I’ll say again, she comes over and notices. Then proceeds to bring the knives over. The lamb rack and filet mignon we had were very good and luckily soft.. the food was wonderful. We didn’t get dessert because at this point we were almost there for two hours. We each had one drink and one glass of water. She never refilled our waters or asked if we wanted another drink, as we noticed that she did for her other tables. We weren’t even told her name. It would of been nice if she brought out dessert for my birthday, on her, for the way out dinning experience went with her. I recommend this restaurant if your celebrating something or just to dine at, as long as she isn’t your waitress!! Sorry we weren’t even told her name. We just felt so belittled from the start.

… more

WCH *
The hostess doesn’t know a thing about kindness or professionalism. Immediately told us “no we can’t do that for you” very condescending and arrogant. Thumbs down…..

… more

Rich Fetterly
Never had a bad meal here. Cute & unique looking restaurant with the main dinning hall upstairs and tables off the stairways going up.

… more

Howard S
Had an amazing meal. Food was absolutely delicious and drinks were also very good. I had the seafood medley which was outstanding and my wife has the snapper special which was seriously delicious. Loved the food, cocktails, ambiance, and the decor made for a wonderful night out. Can’t wait to come back.

… more

Maryann Bast
Always a great meal and beautiful atmosphere. Loved our waiter, Ivan! Will always be my go to restaurant for a special occasion.

… more

Christine Chang
The atmosphere beautiful and food selection looked great but we never got that far. The restaurant appeared to be only a few tables occupied but after 10 minutes i had to get up and get their attention for a menu. Once we placed a drink order, the waitress never returned, the bartender brought over the drink. She did mentioned she was the only one on the floor but with limited people in the restaurant, it still shouldn’t have taken almost 30 minutes and still not even place an order or see the waitress again. We already got up to get their attention once, wasn’t going to do it again… so we left.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions