Long-running eatery serving Mexican & Southwest cuisine in a charming cottage with funky decor. Based on 247 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
279 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110
Phone: (206) 842-1999
Website: http://www.sancarlosgrill.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Thang Phu
The food was hands down delicious and the saving grace of this review.
… more
Christopher
Multiple errors in phone and pickup orders, despite the receipt appearing correct and us reiterating the order. Then I ask for them to correct something they missed, they thank me for catching it, then I realize they missed something else once we get home. This has happened MULTIPLE times and it’s exhausting. I realize we pay premium prices for almost everything on the island, but the product should be at least decent, right?
… more
Dan Schaffer
On Bainbridge and looking for delicious food and a tasty margarita? Hit up San Carlos. I had the tacos and my son a burrito. Both were delicious and generous portions.
… more
Lida Nay
Food was not the best. My refried beans had no flavor. Just bland. I got a “Build your own taco” with the Machaca Beef and the Beef was Very salty. The rice that came with it was mushy. When they handed my plate it was pretty hot which I thought was odd as if they warmed my food in the microwave. I can say my partners “Herbed Crab Chimichanga” was pretty good. For Service, it was whatever. Our wait for food was almost an hour and it wasn’t too busy so not sure why it took so long. The atmosphere inside was whatever but they do have a nice outdoor atmosphere.
… more
Jaiden Williams
A good restaurant if you’re looking for a more quiet and relaxed atmosphere away from large noisy groups. Their deck is great for sitting out on and relaxing while having your food. Their burgers Arnt great as they are a bit burnt but it is a Mexican restaurant no an American diner.
… more
Keith Hopper
Nice place, drinks were interesting, but two margaritas plus a surcharge and tip was $40. Sounds a bit above market price even for Bainbridge Island. Probably won’t go there again.
… more
Ismail baker
Absolutely the best fajitas I have ever had. Wonderful staff. Very friendly and welcoming. When I asked for a box, they even made an extra margaritas to go. These guys are above and beyond. Absolutely recommend and will definitely come back. Thank you.
… more
Melissa Dingmon
House burrito and house margarita. DONE. Heaven.
… more
Eris Griffon
The nest Mexican food I’ve ever had, hands down. The smoked chicken and sour cream enchiladas were divine.
… more
Elizabeth Higgins
The food is amazing and there is lots of it. No skimping on the quality of ingredients or portions here. I had dinner, lunch, and a snack from my plate; my wife had dinner and lunch from her plate. I ordered the enchiladas and my wife got the fajitas.
… more
… View more