Based on 339 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
322 N Commercial St, Neenah, WI 54956
Phone: (920) 725-2671
Website: https://www.sammyspizzaneenah.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jessica Jacobs
I did not like the pizza at all something was just weird or different with the taste but everyone has their own preference my daughter loved it. They offered ice cream sandwich with rhe pizza. Garlic bread was homemade and good but one of them was just toooo much garlic lol
Jeff Pergolski
Love their pizza. Thin crust is perfect. Don’t get more than 2 toppings if you want to keep it together. Really nice people and great service.
Pamela Taylor
Hands down the best pizza in fox valley. Don’t go anywhere else. Thin crunchy tons of cheese plus they deliver. This coming from the biggest pizza snob in Neenah.
Sara Johnson
Love their pizza! and the garlic crust is so good! I normally like thick crust pizza more but they have me hooked. A friend introduced me and now I’m addicted. They are also always so friendly when I go get my pick up order:)
Debra Jung
Best pizza in the Fox Valley! Run, don’t walk to get there! I am from Chicago, I know Pizza and still go EVERYTIME I am back in town. Such a nice family-run place!
Manuel Vivas
From the moment we entered until when we left, we were treated very nicely. The menu is simple and I felt that the prices were fair. While we waited, we played a few of the claw machines by the entrance, which was a nice time waster. To top it all off, the pizza was nothing short of amazing. I ordered the house special and enjoyed it thoroughly. I’ll probably be coming back here again. Also, if you save your receipts, your 16th order is free!
Nicole Smith
This is my favorite pizza place! Have been eating Sammy’s pizza since I was a kid. And if you dine in, the ice cream sandwich is always an awesome treat.
Christene Johansen
Sharp with their tongue, very in and out, and no one was waiting behind me to even say, “Good evening, how are you today.” Good customer service is important.
Tammy Stumpf
Please up date your hours on web site. It would be very much appreciated! Thank you! Love this place!!!
Maximus Max
Sammy’s has been one of my favorite mom and pop pizza places for probably 40 years or so. My wife and I “do” Sammy’s every year while we sit and watch the Neenah/Menasha 4th of July Light Parade, and have for the past ten years or more, and we served Sammy’s pizza at our wedding rehearsal back in August of 2021, which everyone in attendance enjoyed. Takeout is great, but if you dine in – free ice cream sandwiches for everyone in your group! Woot!
… View more