Based on 285 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
650 1/2 W German St, Herkimer, NY 13350
Phone: (315) 866-2600
Website: http://salvatores-herkimer.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Robert
Very good pizza, the cheese was incredible. First time ever I’m thinking next time I’ll have to say light cheese. Everything was so good.
KIMBERLY INGERSOLL
Jade, our waitress was very friendly and had great energy to want to order and feel good about trying a new restaurant.
John D Valasek
Had dinner ordered for pick up from here (7/25/22). We ordered a large pizza and 30 everything wings and an antipasta salad. When we received our order, the wings were not crispy at all and there was not any sauce in the containers. The pizza looked and tasted old. The antipasta was half full. When we called to complain, the owner was very rude and gaslighted us and said “we only cook the wings long enough to cook them through, if you wanted them crispy, you need to ask for them crispy and ask for extra sauce.” After we drove down for the second time, we arrived to pick up the sauce, the owner continued to be rude and handed us two wimpy containers of sauce, all the while he said “I have been doing this for 30 years, I know what I am doing” and claimed to tell his staff to add more sauce to the containers. I would not recommend this place at all. Their service was horrendous and there are plenty of other pizzerias in the area that you can go to that offers better quality service and food.
… more
Robyn P
Waitress was quick and friendly. Pizza wasn’t anything better than take n bake walmart. Ceasar salad was good. Kids Mac n Cheese looked like discount Kraft but it was dry and all stuck together. We got a replacement that was less dry but still meh. Blue cheese dressing was especially bad.
valerie jochum
Very pleasant, calm atmosphere. Was worried it would be full of loud college kids. My two friends and I were pleased overall. Glad we weren’t rushed. We’re old and move slow these days. My eggplant parm was prepared perfectly. Waitress was just as sweet as could be in a natural way.
Nancy Baker
Great dinner with friends. My calzone was wonderful. Husband had a chicken parm with greens. He wasn’t crazy about the breading on the chicken, but devoured everything else. Couple with us both had the fish fry. Piece of fish was a little smaller than expected, but delicious. Salads were very fresh. Waitress was great. Very affordable for a meal out.
david gutowski
Really had an enjoyable quick meal. Staff were very courteous and my steak sandwich was delicious. The roll was toasted and topped with garlic butter and parmesan. The roll was crisp but nice and light. Fries were crispy. Perfect! My bride had a mediterranean sandwich which she enjoyed. Grandchildren enjoyed their meals also.
Pat Jackson Mattucci
Best homemade pizza I have had in years. The sauce was fresh and flavorful, the crust was golden brown and crisp on the bottom but the inner crust was light and airy, with a hint of sweetness. Worth the time to dine..
Loving Alaska
This is a wonderful little gem in herkimer. I enjoyed it very.much. if you guys can take a little constructive criticism from an Italian family that has two pizzarias in the family…your dough needs more salt. If you do that your pizza will be spot on.
Kimberly Pepper
Pleasant atmosphere with great service. Food was good and plentiful. Service was friendly and helpful. Order sauce on side for garlic knots it takes things to the next level. A house salad is huge I’d recommend sharing.
… View more