Based on 179 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2600 Willow Street Pike, Willow Street, PA 17584
Phone: (717) 464-5693
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
rivera rivera
I was super surprised when I was there the other evening. The pizza isn’t how I remembered it! Are there new owners? I first went there about three years ago. The pizza reminded me of old school New York city pizza. It was thin and crispy and perfect with the cheese. Too my surprise, it’s now thicker, too full of cheese and soggy! I am so disappointed!
… more
Denise Moore
I ordered ham & provolone sub and would not even eat it. Lettuce was all brown and had 1 tomato, which was all on the bottom.. had @3 pieces of ham and the cheese was kinda melted. The sub was not even close to being cold or even cool… to me, this is totally unacceptable! Glad I wasted that money and my trash can gets a sub!
… more
Jesse Statler
I’ve been there before and the pizza is great. This time we ate in and the side salads were disgusting. The lettuce was wilted warm and brown and we mentioned it to our server and she said that she told the kitchen that they looked and smelled bad but they didn’t care. I ordered chicken and broccoli alfredo and they didn’t tell me they were out of grilled chicken so they just used frozen sandwiche patties so my alfredo tasted like honey mustard and alfredo sauce. Overall the best thing was the garlic bread and mtn dew. Disappointed
… more
ClarissaBell
The pizza smelled funny and tasted funny. It looked like it was old pizza that had extra cheese thrown on it and reheated. I called the store and she put the cook on the phone who said he could send me a video of him FRESHLY making the pizza and that it only takes 7 min to make, I was right around the corner when I called. Then I said it smelled funny and he said I could come in a smell the ingredients. I wasn’t looking for free food but I just paid for food that I have no desire to eat. They get 1 star for the TERRIBLE customer service and I won’t be returning to Sal’s pizza ever again!
… more
Shane Schelling
Pizza was terrible, cheese an pepperoni had a funny taste to it, the fries an chicken tenders weren’t any better!! I remember this place actually used to be decent, well not anymore!! A wasted 25$ just to throw away the food!! Sorry but il give my business to Two Cousins or Caruso’s!!! What a shame an waste!!
… more
Daniel Williams
The very worst pizza shop in Willow Street! Owner “Should not quit his or her day job”. Dreamt they closed down and build a cleaner, family- friendlier establishment.
… more
Tammy Cave
Called to simply ask them to fix my order as there were several things wrong with it, such as, hardly any cheese in my ice cold hard fries. Missing drink, cheesesteak had brown lettuce, and soggy bread.
… more
Kim Kenee-Diaz
This place is wonderful, best food great prices and awesome help. They have a drive thru window to pick up n pay!
… more
jesse holloway
Typical local pizza shop with pizza, subs, salads, meals, and more. Delicious food and friendly service. Reasonable prices. Clean facilities and comfortable seating.
… more
Wayne Kern
Food was awesome. Not sure of they have changes ingredients in pizza. But much better tasting . But buyers be weary and cautious and watch your prices verses what the bill should be . Order a medium pizza 10.25, 1 topping pepperoni and 1 drink 1.75 , and 1.95 more total 14.78 , bill 16.85 , so evidently they charge for ice water my wife ask for ,.otherwise the bill wouldn’t have been 16.85 and instead should have been 14.78 with taxes.
… more
… View more