Based on 742 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
213 E Lake Ave, Auburndale, FL 33823
Phone: (863) 229-5342
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Damaris Gonzalez Mendez
I ordered a New York style veggie pizza . When I got home the looked as if a kid in kindergarten did it. The veggies were either raw or over cooked. When I called to complain, they told me to go Domino’s or some other Pizzeria like that. It was very disappointing because it was not the first time I ordered from. I think that there is a new owner and he doesn’t know how to make a New York style pizza. Their were pretty good, the time we went there and ate in. Now it’s the Pizzeria from hell.
… more
nicholas perkins
I will never be back. We ordered the NY supreme. The dough was bland, they used canned mushrooms, the pepperoni had no taste (by itself or on the pizza). They decided it was a smart idea to pile 70% of the onions and peppers in the center of the pizza which made it soggy. There was almost no cheese and the sauce was thin. Honestly if you cant be bothered to use fresh ingredients you should not be in the restaurant business.
… more
Kimberly Reddick
We usually enjoy Sal’s but today was very disappointing. Ordered New York style and crust was not thin but thick (def not NY style) and bottom was burnt. Ordered an individual pizza with mushrooms and black olives. $2 extra per topping and 2 of the 4 pieces had no mushrooms with minimal olives, sauce and cheese. We also ordered a side salad with ranch and received Italian dressing instead.
… more
J Davis
This was my first time ordering from this restaurant we wanted pizza and decided to support a local company first and foremost. We got a personal sized pan, pizza meat, lovers, chicken, Caesar salad, and an order of calamari. The food was very tasty. However, there was hair in my calamari, and when the young lady delivered my food, she took the money from my kid, and did not return my change and I requested for my change to be returned so I can give her the tip that I wanted her to have. She had a attitude and did not wait for me to give her the tip that I wanted her to have overall the food was OK. Well I come back to this place not sure.
… more
Leea Hansen
Unless you want dollar store cheese on your pizza. Don’t order the four cheese pizza. They literally tore in half cheap sliced cheese and popped it on top and guess what. The sliced cheese DIDN’T MELT. It did however have brown burn bubbles on it though. As someone who comes from NJ their sauce isn’t bad, the crust isn’t bad but the cheap cheese is a complete turn off. The basic pepperoni pizza we also ordered was okay. But the garlic knots had zero garlic on them. I had to put my own. Not a good first impression.
… more
lisa lear
So I’ve been trying to find a good pizza in FL, being from Jersey I find fla pizza mostly disgusting. My son is here in collage and I generally bring 2/3 jersey pizzas to him when I drive and smaller amounts when I fly… Well Sal’s is pretty good . Not 100% but very close! And very near to the collage. It’s a small place but cute, clean and the owner/ workers are very nice… They do a great job… Highly recommend Sal’s… Yummy
… more
BE AMAZING
Great NY Pizza. Great friendly staff. Love the Italian moped in the restaurant. They are the only pizza place open on Sundays in town. Looking forward to trying their Zepolles next week. Simply delicious food! Plus they have seating outside and are located on a quiet street down from the circle. They speak Italian!!!
… more
Cody
Order take out, do not dine in. We dined in for a NY Style Pizza and waited nearly an hour (49 minutes to be exact). By no means does this pizza spot slow down however, they WILL prioritize take out over dine in so if you are going for an experience, make sure you time yourself well. With that being said, the pizza itself was amazing and absolutely delicious! The crust was just something else that I can’t even compare (and I don’t like the crust so that’s saying something). The service is subpar at best and the table wasn’t touched by our server to let us know the pizza would take some time to come out. Conclusively, I would order pizza from this place again but I’ll pass on dining in next time.
… more
Steve Humphries
I went here with my son, daughter and her boyfriend. I was not disappointed. Not only was the food delicious, but the portions were very large for what you pay compared to other NY pizza places. Friendly service and relaxed atmosphere. I’ll be coming again.
… more
Stan Orelove
First time visitor. Lunch with a friend. We each had a couple slices and a soft drink. Nice job on the pizza! Chewy and flavorful crust. Tasty sauce. Generous amount of cheese and toppings. Funky, eclectic decor. Ample seating. Friendly people. If this were a little closer to me it might well become my go to joint.
… more
… View more