We’re Rusted Roost Restaurant & Bar, a restaurant in Menasha, WI, that has been providing the Fox Valley with great menu items, a great drink selection, and even better service since 2023. Our menu includes a variety of options for all tastes, including vegan dishes and an extensive selection of craft beers, wines, and cocktails. We take pride in providing our guests with a unique experience that blends both classic and modern flavors in a welcoming atmosphere. Join us today for your next meal.
Based on 60 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
192 Main St, Menasha, WI 54952
Phone: (920) 570-5703
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Adrienne Hartman
Tasty cocktails and great service in a cool atmosphere. As a vegan, I was excited to see a new place with vegan options on the menu. I’ve eaten here twice, once had the cornucopia plate (veggies and vegan mashed potatoes) and the second time cauliflower steak and vegan mashed potatoes. I loved the purple cauliflower, but it was florets not cut like cauliflower steak normally is. It also came with a sauce that just seemed like oil or margarine, I skipped that. Overall I really liked the flavors of the veggies and the potatoes, but I found the portions to be very small. My husband had a fish special and also found the portions to be small. Next time, we’ll add on salads for more food.
… more
Nat Mast
I was really excited to try this place out with my friends, as there was a vegan menu listed, and options for our dietary restrictions are limited in the area.
… more
Greta S.
My new favorite restaurant! Everything tasted amazing had so much flavor. Staff was so lovely and knowledgeable about the menu. Menasha needed the Rusted Roost! We will definitely be back! Congrats!!!
… more
Andy Wassmann
Really cool place and another nice addition to an up and coming Menasha. Went left field and got the beet/walnut salad yesterday which was very good.
… more
Ryan Williamson
Environment, atmosphere, and service were top notch. Although the flavors of the food were fantastic, my wife and I’s dishes were a little dry.
… more
Michelle Sorenson
My husband and I went on Saturday and loved it! I had the prix fixe and chose the Pollo en crema and it was delicious as was the salad and the mashed potatoes were to die for! My husband had the hay and straw pasta and it was also really good! We had the shrimp and frites as an appetizer while we waited at the bar (cocktails packed a punch ).They have some very minor new business kinks to work out, but the service was awesome and we loved everything we had. Servers were gracious when mistakes happened (it took a while to realize we were a table that hadn’t been waited on…but part of that is because we started at the bar and it looked like we had already been served – we blame ourselves). Everyone working there really seemed to take pride in their new restaurant. Oh…did I mention the strawberry shortcake with sugar biscuit???? Worth a trip back just for that!!! I hope you will give them a chance!
… more
Brittany McKenzie
Overall meh and definitely way overpriced. They’re new and maybe just need to work some stuff out, but I’m not willing to spend the money to get disappointed again. My pollo en crema definitely looked different than other pictures, it was bland, barely had any sauce, and super dry. Also only had a tiny amount of minced peppers and was missing onions. Salad was boring, definitely needs more to it than greens, tomatoes and cucumbers for the price. Turkey burger was missing the sauce too. Atmosphere is nice but doesn’t make up for the food, the place was quite loud even though it was barely half full. Waitress could have been more attentive too. They definitely have potential but should maybe do some reevaluating in the kitchen and make sure it is consistent and find ways to elevate what they’re already offering.
… more
DEATH13X DEATH13X
The food I have tried so far is amazing. The hay and straw pasta is really good, and the pork verde as well. As for the portions, I wish they were a little bigger considering how good they were. I also really liked how clean the place was compared to other places that barely clean the tables. You guys have to give me the secret on how you make the stainless steel really shine in the bar area. It’s mesmerizing to look at.
… more
Lane Groutage
Gorgeous new restaurant in downtown Menasha. Totally unlike any atmosphere around this area. Great staff and service. Food is amazing!!!!
… more
Kristi C
The Rusted Roost is a fantastic dining experience. The roast beef sandwich and chicken pot pie are delicious. And it might be a small thing, but the Caesar salad is so good! The drinks are reasonably priced and the metal and wood create a cozy ambiance. With great service and a great meal, we will be back! (There is so much more on the menu to try!)
… more
… View more