Based on 82 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
Address:
139 NJ-10 East, Succasunna, NJ 07876
Phone: (973) 341-3110
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Platypus
Little on the expensive side, but, the service is fast and friendly! Pizza is amazing! For sure our new go to place!
… more
Anthony Vecchio
I walked in for dinner a couple days ago and forgot my wallet. It was my first time here. Younger guy with spiked hair behind counter who making pizzas told me i could come back and pay him later. He paid my meal from his own pocket! I saw him do it. Just wow. This is a real family pizzaria. I highly recommend this place! This place A+.
… more
Tina Hoffman
I happened to stop in today and had lunch for the first time since ownership changed hands. I used to always order the pasta fagioli and I thought it was the best I’d ever had. WELL…the new owner makes it the same way the old owner did and I was SO HAPPY! I also ordered a salad and it was healthy and fresh. The new owner is super friendly and I’m definitely going back for my faves! I think the food is excellent!
… more
Stuart Floyd
One of many local Italian dine in, take out and another good one and not the same as the others which is what makes this area so good in that you can try and love the Italian dishes and pizzas at many local places and enjoy and compare. Here we have liked the meals, apps, and pizza of course. We have only done take out from here but always friendly and we have had delivery as well with no issues over the years.
… more
Dena Biamonte
We love everything about this place the food is always delicious, the pizza to the penne vodka, chicken parm, the eggplant parmigiana calzone and stuffed breads yum. My mom ordered seafood pasta came hot with salad and bread. They don’t get enough praise in our area. There alway kind even the delivery drivers fast, friendly!!! Thank you
… more
David McInerney
Pizza Nazis.
… more
Gary
Stopped by this afternoon for a quick slice and a coke. First time here. Guy at the counter couldn’t have been nicer. Wasn’t sure if the pizza was going to be good but it was. Definitely be back next time I’m in the area.
… more
Michelle
The pizza is delivered hot & quickly. It was made with fresh ingredients & is delicious. We ordered several appetizers & they were all great. We also ordered cheese cake & cannolis that were amazing.
… more
Munsey Rodriguez
Everything is beyond good!!! Lunch and dinner sizable lunches and dinners always on point… I went from eating lunch once a week to lunch, everyday and dinners enough for two people easy I at least get 4-5 dinners a week. Good affordable food at a reasonable price and owners are very friendly customer service rediculas and these guys make you feel like family when you walk in the door. Shout out to Big Albert and Jose!!! thanks again, for the experience from me and my family to you and yours. ✌️
… more
Michael Caulfield
Casella’s is definitely in contention for the best pizza I’ve ever had. Tangy, delicious sauce, great blend of crunchy and doughy crust, melty perfect cheese. The staff is incredibly friendly, accomodating, and helpful. All in all, an 11/10 pizza joint.
… more
… View more