You can truly taste the tradition in every dish we serve here at Rosey’s Italian Cafe. That’s because when owners Rick and Rosey originally opened up in 1997, they made it their mission to cook the way they grew up eating — real Italian food that’s been passed down from one generation to the next. Our menu features classic dishes like chicken parmesan and homemade lasagna. Stop by our cozy restaurant in Penfield or order takeout to enjoy at home. Either way, our welcoming staff and authentic cuisine will make you feel like a part of the Rosey’s family.
Unassuming family-run Italian eatery serving sandwiches & homestyle mains, plus beer & wine. Based on 485 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2133 Five Mile Line Rd, Penfield, NY 14526
Phone: (585) 385-5600
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday |
3–8 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday |
Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Julie
Chefs kiss! The sauce was perfect. Bread dipped in sauce, amazing! The gnocchi so soft and pillowy! I enjoyed the flavor! Atmosphere was gorgeous and service was welcoming and kind. Thank you!
… more
Linda Latorre
I called at closing and they were happy to take my order. I picked up my food 10 minutes later, and it tasted AMAZING!!!!!!!!! Love your food-always. I am a big fan. Such a nice staff too. XOXO
… more
Amy Sakmyster
I met a friend for lunch during the week on a very hot day, and as I pulled into the parking lot I realized this little place tucked in a small plaza, I worried if we’d get a seat, as it was packed. When I arrived, a lovely table was cleared for me as I awaited my friend. Now, it gives me more of a diner feel, considering the prices for the food. I’m a Celiac so this was a bit difficult to order, but I was able to get Gluten-free pasta, and the Chicken French. I have to tell you this was a large meal and I’m just over 100 lbs, and I ate the entire meal, and it was absolutely fantastic. The chicken came in three tenderloins with the perfect sauce. My friend ordered a Chicken Ceasar salad with Cajun rubbed chicken and enjoyed as well.
… more
Jeff Visco
Now I know why I don’t try new restaurants. 4.5 rating? I don’t ever leave reveries but the food was so bad and the ratings are so good I don’t have a choice. It isn’t right to advertise theses types of ratings. Literally the absolute wordt sauce I’ve ever tasted in my life. Almost threw up in the parking lot. You def have fam and friends jacking up the rating, as this food was AWFUL….Thanks god for Wegmans on the way home. disgusting wow……never ever will be back. Even if you paid me….disgusting wow
… more
hello hi
My wife had the bada bang shrimp and linguine special. Both were delicious, but my favorite was the chix parm. Nice little place with charm and great food. Prices are really reasonable too. Definitely be back.
… more
Carla Georgetti
I ordered a kids portion of the angel hair with oil and garlic. Pretty good! I’d like some green seasonings in there like basil, parsley, oregano, something. But thats me being picky lol
… more
Barbara Markarian
This is the best kept secret in town. Tha food is plentiful and so delicious. I had chicken and artichoke French over angel hair pasta that was amazing. Service was spot on also. I highly recommend this restaurant.
… more
Megan Pedersen
I order for pick up, it was ready within 10-15 minutes. Their food is delicious, first time ordering from them. The customer service is excellent. I ordered the Chicken and Artichoke French meal with linguine and an appetizer is Fried Calamari. Highly recommend when you have that Italian craving.
… more
Just Me
I cannot rate the food, as I have never tried it. But the inside is a small restaurant, but very cute, warm, and welcoming. The owner is in the front and welcomes everyone and is very friendly and nice.
… more
Dave Weston
The food was great. We had reservations and I definitely recommend doing that as well. Food was priced well and tasted great. The calamari was so delicate and cooked perfectly! Service was efficient, food rooks some time to come out but there was bread and our apps to hold us over. Will be back to try other varieties of dishes.
… more
… View more
