At Rincón Tolteca Mexican Restaurant, we bring to each table a taste of Hidalgo Mexico! Our culture shows through our food and the Toltecas influenced our unique taste. Everything from our spicy Chile de arbol salsa, the bread for our Tortas, and delicious desserts & everything in between is made in house! We have 2 very close families invested in our kitchen and front house and with over 60+ years of kitchen experience combined, they are capable of creating masterpieces from various cultures. This is more than a job for us, this is our dream. I assure you every taco, dinner, or dessert is prepared and crafted with great love and skill. So i say, if u love Mexican food, crave something spicy, or your vegan, try us, we won’t disappoint.
Based on 301 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4607 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL 34231
Phone: (941) 279-5560
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday |
9 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
9 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
9 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
9 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
9 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
9 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
9 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brian Vinson
A really great place I’d never been to. Kind of a hole in the wall that you need to know where it is but once you visit, yum!
… more
Geraldin Rueda
It was so good totally recommend to everyone. Well definitely be back whenever I’m up in Sarasota. We drove up from Naples and my family and I randomly decided to stop by. So glad we did. I found my New Mexican restaurant because they had the best chilaquiles I’ve had at a restaurant. My sister had a grilled chicken Torta which she also loved. My mom had tinga Gordidas which I would also recommend! The restaurant overall was super clean and quiet as well. Not to mention the staff was super helpful and offered the best service:).
… more
Jonny Muren
Absolutely delicious!!! The only thing better than the food are the people. Jose was such a great guy and took such good care of us, we came back the next day for the Sunday special. Susanna help us out Sunday and she was equally as amazing. Great atmosphere, fantastic food and friendly people. We absolutely love this place. Wish I could give more stars.
… more
Jeniffer Arboleda
Visiting out of town and was looking for a dinner spot. Drove by and said why not! The staff was friendly and the service was great. The bocalitos with steak was the best! The beef in the taco salad needed a little more seasoning but overall was a cute little place. The desserts are good too!
… more
b smith
Delicious and authentic homemade style Mexican food. Everything was very fresh and well prepared. The Huarache’s were excellent. As were the chicken Fujita, tostadas, enchiladas. The red chilli sauce is homemade and excellent very hot! Dine instead or outdoors. Very reasonably priced.
… more
Kari B
This place is so freaking good! I’m from California so I’m picky about Mexican food. The veggie tostado is amazing, roasted cauliflower and so many veggies. I had them not put green peppers for me and extra cilantro. they have 3 homemade salsas and they are all so good. Watch out the light one is ridiculously spicy. The service is really slow and to go orders get served first. Sorry but you need to hire a new waitress.
… more
Natalie Estrada
Best authentic Mexican restaurant I’ve visited. Fresh chips and salsa and amazing staff + chefs. The red salsa is the perfect amount of heat and flavor! Everything on the menu is flavorful especially the fajitas dish that come beautifully presented. Great atmosphere with music and a pretty dining area outside!!
… more
Halina Zdanowski
The food was delicious and fresh which is very important to me. Very friendly staff. It was pleasure to be there. They also have homemade deserts that I could not try unfortunately due to diet but looked very delicious.
… more
Alexander Caraballo
Food was great, but the service was upsetting. Natalie had a hospitable vibe but wasn’t very pleasant in her service. She didn’t greet herself, nor offered me napkins and eating utensils. She offered me tortilla chips with salsa and I never received it. She never checked on me, only time she did is when I was finished with my meal.
… more
Greek Mike
Welcoming staff, delicious food, fresh bakery options, and delicious homemade daily desserts. I was greeted and served by a smiling young lady named Eva, I believe she is from Venezuela. Overall amazing experience. They were very busy and it seems to be a family-owned establishment, so I was patient with the service, as there was minimal staff on duty. Eva was doing Uber orders, answering phones, and serving tables in both dining rooms and the patio! She must be a very valued employee as she is quite the multi-tasker. Loved every minute of my visit. I will definitely return and recommend to all.
… more
… View more
