Based on 558 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
3767 9 Mile Rd, Allegany, NY 14706
Phone: (716) 372-9606
Website: http://www.randysuptheriver.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Monday | 11 AM–2 AM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
sheldon klinger
The service was spectacular. This is a red neck bar, with great drinks and better service. Definitely do not pass up a chance to visit here. My bartender, Jeanette was terrific!! Visit here, for a drink and ask for Jeanette or Cheyenne. You will enjoy your visit!
Sarah P
We ordered take out from Randy’s Up the River last night. On the phone we were told 20-25 minutes, so we decided to just go and wait at the establishment. 45 minutes later, one of the bartenders came out telling us our food was done, but they ran out of salt potatoes to go with my 1/2 barbeque chicken dinner, so she gave me a choice of potato. Ten minutes later our food finally came out. While the bartender was ringing us up, we decided to check our food and make sure it was right. My dinner was missing two sides. When the bartender came back I was polite about letting her know my dinner was incomplete and she told me they only do rolls and butter on Thurs- Saturdays. Like what? What about my beans? I asked her why I was paying full price for the same meal on the menu, but it was missing two sides. She started getting a little attitude with me and told me she would see if they could grab me a piece of bread, and she sped off towards the kitchen. Quite some time later, she came back with the tiniest roll and a little container of macaroni salad, which she said they were supposed to be giving that out with the meal instead of the other sides. UPDATE YOUR MENU IF YOU DON’T HAVE THINGS AVAILABLE, OR IF THEY ARE ONLY AVAILABLE ON CERTAIN DAYS. OR AT LEAST TELL CUSTOMERS OVER THE PHONE WHEN THEY ARE ORDERING. ALSO, DON’T TELL CUSTOMERS AN ESTIMATED TIME AND THEN TAKE TWICE AS LONG. Say “we are a bit busy right now, it could even take up to an hour,” or something along those lines. My boyfriend said his steak sub was the worst he’s ever had. The bun wasn’t toasted, the steak was overcooked, there was hardly any dressing on it, and some of the potato chips were undercooked. Poor service, poor food, way overpriced for what you get. Will not be returning.
… more
Adam C
My girlfriend and I were able to put our orders in before a 11 top party put there’s in and we waited an hour and twenty minutes for 15 chicken wings and a fried chicken special they had going for a Saturday night. I’ve had the same problem at Randy’s Fireside and the same issue happened twice in a row where the staff had cut our order down to be cheaper. I’m very aware it’s a blessing they do that for us but I’d rather pay full price for food and good and fast service than pay cheaper price for a dinner that took 2 and a half hours. Randy if you see this, fix your restaurants
Bruce Raterink
Waited almost a half hour for waitress to take our order. Another 45 minutes to get food. My burger was OK, wife’s BBQ chicken was without BBQ and did not look like it was done and missing sides. Overall service was poor, food a little better than poor. Would NOT recommend eating there.
Jeff Lemay
Amazing place, great staff (barmaid & waitresses), super friendly customers … delicious food… and great stories
Cody Bay
Randomly chose this place for lunch. It was amazing! One of the best burgers I’ve ever had. Creative stuff on the menu (that works great) and an open patio to enjoy it on. Loved it!
Michelle Franklin
Omg I got the Gorilla burger and man it was so good. I couldn’t even finish it. I’ll have to go back and try all their burgers lol. Fat girl here I come haha. Serves was great. I would recommend trying if you haven’t yet
Michelle Westfall
The food was excellent! Ribeye steak grilled vegetables and French fries, everything was great!! I will DEFINITELY go back to eat there . Next time will be the prime rib!! Yummm
Ross Ward
Good food and service we had a big group of ppl lot’s of selection on the menu.
Alyson Amendola
Food was amazing. Our server was so friendly and attentive. We will definitely be back!
… View more