Based on 355 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$$
Address:
999 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Phone: (631) 526-9779
Website: http://www.primiitalian.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
#SmartHomeSecurityNY
Great venue for birthday parties. You can book the second floor for you and all of your guests. Food was good…our kids couldn’t get enough of the skirt steak! I got the sea bass with butter and capers.
… more
Glenn
Wonderful cocktails! The rest of the experience was acceptable, but a disappointment for the price. Service was friendly, but sparse, not up to what one would expect for a restaurant with such a strong reputation. Food was well prepared, but not served piping hot, perhaps will have to “redo.”
… more
Lorenzo V
Love this place. Found out about Primi from an event a family member had that was perfectly executed. Great event spot! Been here a few times since then for dinner and can’t get enough. The food, service and atmosphere can’t be beat. The food is so fresh and delicious. The staff is very attentive and friendly. Great atmosphere and vibe. Highly recommend!
… more
Daniela K
Loved the place and the ambience. Service was top notch super attentive and personable.
… more
fone Anan
Love this place, especially at the Bar
… more
Chris Tutone
Me and my girlfriend went to Primi for our 5th anniversary and I was slightly disappointed. For the prices you are paying, you should expect some things that weren’t offered. For example, they should ask if we are celebrating anything or refill our wine when our glasses are empty. The food was pretty good, I got the dry aged Strip and my girlfriend got the filet mignon with crispy onions and whipped potatoes. The prices are too high for what this place is, the quality of the food just wasn’t on par with their competitors. Overall 82/100
… more
Sal Alessandro
The service was very good,
… more
angelo miaris
Had dinner on a Tuesday night it was my first time dining here . I was greeted by valet parking right by the front door ,Score !!!! The restaurant is beautiful inside offering a cozy warm environment , beautiful decor ! Our server was Amanda. She was very attentive, The food was amazing we had 4 apps I highly recommend the fried barata , calamari, fried artichoke hearts, and the grilled octopus , they were all delicious for the main course I had the special fettuccine pasta with the truffle mushroom cream sauce. It was delicious. I shared it with my brother and they were kind enough to split it in the kitchen. That portion was more than enough after all those appetizers. Lol , for dessert, I had the peanut butter pie which was amazing and a chocolate martini which was also delicious. Unfortunately that is all I was able to take a picture of as I was too busy eating the food to take pictures of it. I do recommend this place. It was delicious and I will be visiting again and taking photos of my food next time
… more
chalooter
Good, fresh Italian food and aged steaks. Daily specials, wine and drink lists. They even have mocktails for the designated driver! It’s pricey, but what isn’t these days. Yummy desserts. No problem splitting a pasta dish for an appetizer. They bring it in 2 dishes without asking. Servers are attentive and helpful. When there’s a party upstairs, it sounds like a stampede running by! Lol. I don’t really like the mandatory valet parking, though. I can park my own car, thank you. Overall, it was a great place. Enjoy!
… more
Virginia Nanni
My date had been talking up this restaurant when deciding where to take me, and he was right to do so. This place was perfect in every way, from the ambiance to the service and through to the last bite of our tiramisu. Our server Christine was awesome and her recommendations on what to order did not disappoint (although I doubt anything on the menu would). They had my favorite wine (Montepelucci) which made me very happy. Salads to start (wedge for me arugula for him) set the meal off right. The blue cheese was spot on. We ordered streaks (filet and ribeye) of courses cooked perfectly. Our sides were roasted potatoes and grilled asparagus. Dessert was a shared tiramisu with tea, double espresso & port. I’m still thinking about this night 3 days later…not only cause it was a great date, but it was a great place to have the date.
… more
… View more