Pretty Toni’s Cafe Menu – Valley Stream, NY

Type : Soul food restaurant

Location : Valley Stream, NY

Intimate soul food restaurant with classics like chicken & waffles, plus happy hour specials. Based on 238 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Pretty Toni's Cafe 11580

Address:
759 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580

Phone: (516) 285-8664

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 4–8 PM
Friday 4–8 PM
Saturday 12–8 PM
Sunday 12–4 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

SUNDAY BRUNCH 12:30PM-3 :00PM
BELGIAN WAFFLE BRUNCH
Belgian Waffle, Two Eggs, Turkey Bacon and Turkey Sausage
$23.00
LOBSTER , SHRIMP AND GRITS
Creamy Grits topped with Lobster and Shrimp in a Lobster Butter Sauce, Two Eggs, Home Fries
Please add egg preparation to notes
$41.00
HEART HEALTHY OMELETTE
EGG WHITE Omelette w spinach, onions and bell peppers
Served with Home Fried Potatoes, Turkey Bacon, Turkey Sausage
$25.00
FRIED WHITING BRUNCH
Fried Whiting, Two Eggs, Grits, Home Fries
$23.00
STEAK AND EGGS
10 oz Strip Steak, Two Eggs, Home Fries, Grits
$41.00
BREAKFAST BOWL
Home Fried Potatoes topped with: Two Eggs, Turkey Bacon, Turkey Sausage
$23.00
FRENCH TOAST CROISSANT & 2 EGGS
Topped with Fresh Mixed Berries, whipped cream, turkey Bacon, Turkey Sausage, Two Eggs
please add egg preparation to notes
$24.00
Starters
Deep Fried Chicken Strips
Plain, buffalo,
$12.00
Whiting Strips
Deep fried with tarter and hot sauce.
$12.00
Catfish Strips
Deep fried with tarter and hot sauce.
$12.00
Wingettes
Fried, buffalo, jerked
$12.00
Grilled Shrimp Skewer
Plain, BBQ, jerked
$13.00
Pan Seared Crab Cakes
With spicy mango drizzle.
$18.00
Fred Macaroni And Cheese
10 pc Fried Macaroni and Cheese Wedges drizzled with Ranch Dressing
$12.00
Salads
Baby Spinach & Strawberry
With raspberry vinaigrette, croutons, red onions.
$11.00
Kale Caesar
Romaine with Caesar dressing, croutons, parmesan cheese.
$11.00
Hot Plates
Red Velvet Waffle & Chicken
Belgian waffle drizzled with cream cheese icing and deep fried half chicken.
$25.00
Belgian Waffle & Chicken
Belgian waffle and deep fried half chicken.
$23.00
Deep Fried Half Chicken
Choose any two side orders.
$23.00
Catfish
Deep fried, grilled or blackened. Choose and 2 side orders.
$23.00
Smothered Chicken
Deep fried half chicken with gravy and onions. Choose any 2 side orders.
$25.00
Shrimp
One dozen large, fried, grilled, BBQ, jerked or blackened. Choose any 2 side orders.
$29.00
Salmon
Grilled, BBQ, blackened, jerked Choose any 2 side orders.
$33.00
Fried Whiting
Whiting filets. Choose any 2 side orders.
$23.00
New York Strip Steak
12 oz. grilled, blackened or jerked. Choose any 2 side orders.
$41.00
Deep Fried Red Snapper
Whole fish. Choose any 2 side orders.
$33.00
SOUL BOWL
MAC N CHEESE, YAMS, VEG. GREENS, PLANTAINS

NO DOUBLES

$23.00
Side Orders
Sweet Plantains $5.00
Vegetarian Greens $5.00
French Fries $5.00
Sweet Potato Fries $6.00
Candied Yams $5.00
Cajun Fries $6.00
Mac & Cheese $6.00
Desserts
Organic Banana Pudding Cake $14.00
Sweet Potato Pie $7.00
Peach Cobbler $7.00
Organic Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake $14.00
Banana Pudding $10.00
Beverages
Coke $4.50
Diet Coke $4.50
Sprite $4.50
Seltzer $4.50
Ginger Ale $4.50
Iced Tea $4.50
Lemonade $4.50
Flavored Iced Tea $5.50
Flavored Lemonade $5.50
Poland Spring $3.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Tall Tray
The service and food were amazing. The ambiance was comfortable and relaxing. The food was very fresh and delicious! The kale cesar salad was awesome and plentiful!

… more

Terri Thomas
We were in town visiting a friend and looking for a good place for chicken and waffles. Pretty Toni’s was the perfect place for a Sunday Brunch. Small place but cute, great personal service, excellent food and easy parking.

… more

Jam Montero
Had dinner with my coworker here & we both agreed that the food was amazing & authentic, service was fast & easy. The atmosphere was fun & lighthearted. Just looking at the names of the drinks & having family feud play in the background as we ate was enough for me to fall in love with the atmosphere. The lovely gentleman who served us was very receptive, friendly & efficient in service. It felt so homey, like eating at home with loved ones or attending dinner at your favorite auntie’s house. Would definitely recommend as a nice, easygoing, calm environment for anyone to dine in.

… more

Betsy Gardner
I called, and they were closing, so I didn’t get a chance to try the food. But this red velvet cheese cake will make me come back to try the food. It was delicious, not dry

… more

Teresa Roberts
Quaint.

… more

Toyin Ayeni-Swanston
Food was good & the drinks also if your looking for a great Black owner Restaurant in the Neighborhood here it is. Their standards have not changed in the atleat 15 years I have been patronizing them. New York city style and experience with out the hassle of parking & train rides. Love this place

… more

Reese
I’ve seen this restaurant around for years and I’m so happy I got the chance to finally come here. The guy who seated us was very nice. We ordered the shrimp lobster grits and catfish strips….. OMG not a single disappointment! The cocktails were delicious! The music was on point as well! Definitely coming back! Sorry I don’t have photos I was too busy eating lmao.

… more

Mechelle Rayford
Decided to stop for a bite. So glad I did..so bad, ate in, ordered to go and 2 slices of cake and a pudding. YUM!

… more

Trina S
As a new resident to the neighborhood, i would walk pass this restuarant everyday. This particular evening my sister I smelt a delicious aroma that drew us in and we knew it was time to check it out. As we entered we were greeted by a gentleman who was very friendly. There were so many great things on the menu it was hard to choose. I did a take out and I must say the food was amazing. I have found my new favorite spot and will definitely be a regular.

… more

Mohamed Darhan
I ordered from the catering menu and everything came out amazing. Not only was the food great but the customer service was also top notch. Highly recommend.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions