Based on 73 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
415 Noblestown Rd, Carnegie, PA 15106
Phone: (412) 502-7000
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
jarin clem
Came here after a company training.First time here,food was good,atmosphere is great,service was great,decided to spend $40 on the machines.won $140.
Emily Uzar
First time visiting Presutti’s for lunch. Great menu, clean restaurant, friendly employees. We ordered a grilled chicken salad, half basket of fries, chicken bacon ranch hoagie and eggplant parm hoagie. The salad is huge, basically two salads. My friends said their hoagies were good. Half basket of fries is large so I would assume the large is for a table of people plus some. Will definitely be back to try more items!
DJ Bill Bara
Presutti’s is a must-visit for pizza-lovers. It is no wonder they are getting Hugh reviews. Their pizza is delicious, and their attention to detail is impressive.
Carly Lescallette
Our first time here- Staff was so attentive and welcoming. We had some drinks and pepperoni rolls which were fantastic. Definitely recommend.
MJ
Received their menu in the mail. Pizza looked really good so we decided to try it. We got the Ultimate Veggie pizza. First time I’ve ever said this but way too many toppings on it, not the variety but the amount of toppings. The sauce was bland, the crust didn’t hold up. Cheese and toppings were falling off the pizza. Had to eat the toppings separately from the limp pizza. Probably the worst pizza I’ve had in a while even including national pizza brands. Really sucks to say that because their service was great. Pizza was ready in 20 minutes. I picked up and didn’t dine in but the atmosphere looked great as well. Full bar, TVs to watch games. Hard to give it more than two stars when the pizza was so bad. Might give them another shot and try something simple like just pepperoni. Crust needs cooked at higher temp so it’s not limp.
… more
Eric Smith
Stopped in for pizza and… damn! Amazing. Sauce homemade with imported tomatoes, cheese high quality, crust- so good. Baked to perfection with a nice crispness. Great service. Full bar. I will be back!!
Samuel Skaggs
Definitely some amazing food!! The pizza was great tasting and fresh, the pizza rolls looked great and tasted even better. We will be back for sure!! Special thanks to Steve and staff for providing such a pleasant experience!! We stopped by after a tough loss from a hockey tournament. This was just the thing we needed!
Meg Sepp
First time ordering from here….the pizza was ok, definitely not the best we’ve had. The 16” Italian sub was good in the middle but the ends were burned. The fried pickles were fine. The fresh cut fries were the worst! They were little burned pieces of fries that seemed to have been microwaved, Sadly definitely not worth the money spent.
Laura Muller
Ordered three different pies, all were cooked to perfection. I love a thinner crust and this hit the spot. We got wings which were super crispy and delicious and the cheese curds which were pillowy and cheesy. We will definitely be back!
Gary Phillips Sr.
Went there yesterday with co-workers for lunch and everything was amazing but you definitely got to try their Italian hoagie dip it’s a game changer!
… View more