Relaxed bar & grill featuring jumbo NY-style pies, Buffalo wings & Italian platters, with delivery. Based on 227 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
15501 Old McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908
Phone: (239) 689-5660
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 5–8:45 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
5–8:45 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 5–8:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–8:45 PM |
| Thursday | 5–8:45 PM |
| Friday | 5–8:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Melissa Rowe (Missy)
Love going here, chill place and love the pizza dough meatballs with the Alfredo sauce and the salads are bomb! Service is awesome! Owner Chrissy is usually there and always good to see her and being involved in her business! Try it out and have a beer and chill!
… more
kim willumsen
Best pizza in the world. We visit Fort Myers every year from Denmark and we always make sure to stop by Poppy’s, atleast once. We’ve recommented our friends back home to go to Poppy’s aswel and they all say the same thing. Amazing food.
… more
Rosemary Mcdade
Had another great meal at Poppy’s! What drew us here initially was the additions of our favorite gnocchi in a divine gorganzola sauce and the best lasagna from Yabo Chef. But we also discovered the excellent pizza by Poppy and bringing one home. They reheat to a crispy crust, yum. I had the really well presented salmon with mushrooms, asparagus, tomatoes in a beautiful sauce over the creamy parmigiana risotto. Hubby had the lasagna. To top it off we split the light and sweet tiramasu. Again, not disappointed with a single thing.
… more
Lynn Tincher
Horrible experience. When my Pizza showed up, all the toppings had slid off. When we called them they told us it’s because of the tomatoes and wouldn’t do anything for us. The crust was burnt and the toppings were very cold. Sad because it wasn’t over sauced or over cheesy like most places. Will not order again.
… more
Jonathan
delicious ny style pizza, the dough covered meatballs were actually amazing, and the sauce that comes with them was heavenly. the mediterranean pizza with artichoke hearts and feta also impressed.
… more
Ann Stranahan
The best service I have experienced in my very long life! I could see what we wanted on the Poppy’s website, but the complete menu would not show up on the delivery service website. Poppy’s took this as a challenge and stayed with me on the line, finally creating a workaround that got the gnocchi and wrapped meatballs to our door — in record time. What a rare and good-spirited gift of time and brains: thank you, Poppy!
… more
Reservations Majestic
This PIZZA! It’s delicious! Even the crust is like a mouth watering snack at the end of your meal! 10 out of 10!
… more
Patti Choby
I just ordered a large pizza – my toppings weren’t on my pizza. Slice service couldn’t resolve my issue and calling the provider – no answer – got me nothing! Warning! Don’t use this service and don’t tip until they show up with the right order! Ugh! I hate this!
… more
Kellyn Heller
We’ve been twice just this week as we really liked their pizza! Toppings were fresh (no canned mushrooms or mushy tomato chunks) and we liked how the crust wasn’t thick and was just done to the right amount of chewy. Enjoyed the staff and they had good wine and beer options. When we return to FM in a few weeks, we will try some of their other dishes.
… more
Mark Ellinger
The sausage pizza is so good!! We are going to have to try other menu items as it all looked good being delivered to other tables around us.
… more
… View more