Based on 71 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
Address:
420 Fayal Rd, Eveleth, MN 55734
Reviews
Lana Morrow
Great service! Even on their busiest day of the year, the 4th of July! They had several pizza fresh, hot and ready to go so you didnt even have yo wait for your order! The inside keeps its classic feel. The old booths left on the far and are a little worse for the wear but there are plenty other seating options that are new and comfy. Delivery is always fast and their pricess are reasonable!
… more
Yard Yeti
If you are visiting the Iron Range this iconic pizza place needs to be on your list of places to stop! The pizzas are amazing and you’ll definitely want to try the cheddar cubes! Smiling faces and great food! Highly recommend!
… more
Stephanie Bloomquist
Drove to Eveleth from Virginia for two large pizzas. One pizza was 1/2 sausage 1/2 pepperoni. On the sausage side there was barely any meat on it and what was there were very small pieces of sausage.. Both pizzas didn’t have cheese spread to the crust end and had very little sauce. Extremely disappointed with the poor quality of our order. We will start buying our food in Virginia until things go back the way it used to be at Poor Gary’s.
… more
Brenda Novodvorsky
Absolutely the best pizza we have ever eaten. Best price around for the best pizza and the most excellent service ever. (Seems under priced actually) Will definitely eat here again when we are in town. Thank you!!!!!
… more
Laurie Franko
I love the food here. Continually getting my order wrong and sub par service have caused me to no longer eat here. I used to recommend Poor Gary’s to family and friends but now we take our business elsewhere.
… more
Joshua Sanders
It was good pizza. A little expensive for what everything ended up being. The restaurant is extremely dimly lit and not in amazing condition. We were the only ones who dined in the whole time we were there. A lot of people were getting take out.
… more
Danyale Crisp
I had chicken strips and fries they were delicious! So good I came back the next night for more. The people working here are super friendly! Gotta try them!
… more
Sandy Bryant
These guys make good pizza! Thin, chewy crust, always consistent. You need to eat it with a tall cool one. 😉
… more
Chad Mathison
Staying the weekend at the Super8, had them deliver, priced Right, great pizza. Thanks for the good service!!!!
… more
Danielle DeFoe
Fast and convenient place to order dinner when you don’t feel like cooking. The food I’ve tried is very good and haven’t had a bad experience yet.
… more
… View more