No-frills local chain known for pizza by the slice, plus extra-large pies & specialty toppings. Based on 526 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
311 N 3rd Street, Wausau, WI 54403
Phone: (715) 298-9079
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kimmie Up North
Huge selection of pizza by the slice or you can order whole custom pizzas to dine in or take out. Really spacious dining area. They have a few tables outside to eat as well. Best pizza around, if you had to compare it to a chain pizza company “Sbarro Pizza” would be simular in major malls but better. They do really good daily speciality pizzas like Philly cheesesteak & cordon blue. Really reasonably price & they do meal deals different days of the week too. Really wish they’d open a location in Rhinelander because all our pizza places literally suck. The only negative is parking can be tricky when they’re busy.
… more
Elizabeth McKenna
I wish there was a Polito’s in my town!!!! This is the best pizza we have ever had. In addition, even though I made a mistake and ordered from the wrong Polito’s, I was treated graciously, and assured that I was not the first to make this mistake. They called the other Polito’s, canceled my order and quickly made us two new pizzas. I will go back as soon as I can, taking extra care to order from the correct Polito’s!
… more
Michael Vincent
Excellent place for a quick, cheap and delicious piece (or couple pieces, recommended) of specialty pizza. Was sad when the Polito’s in De Pere closed so was thrilled when I moved to Wausau and found one downtown. I visit weekly if not more.
… more
Sherwood Is Here
lots of great and interesting choices of speciality slices. love their food but i will note that a lot of items on the menu have disappeared such as wings and some subs so it’s only worth going if you want their specialty slices
… more
Molly Kapping
We don’t live in the area, so every time we’re visiting relatives we have to come here. I absolutely love that you can get pizza by the slice, makes it easy to try different fun flavors (like the steak and fry, my absolute FAVORITE pizza EVER). And the pizza is SO GOOD. Like, some of my all-time favorite pizza. The staff has always been friendly and helpful and I love the low-key vibes. My dream is that they open one in the Twin Cities some day.
… more
Amanda Saunders
Amazing BBQ pork pizza and a large selection of others. Garlic knots to die for. If you can’t make it to Chicago….
… more
Malcolm Hargrave
Came for dinner with 2 friends, order meat lovers Dan the owner whiped it up, served nice and hot. During closing he offered us free pizza to go, he was excited he was having a baby girl, food outstanding.
… more
Aleksandr Peneshko
accepted the order, later refused to fulfill it. Don’t waste your time.
… more
Terri McKinney
Many varieties to choose from. I tried the Mac and cheese for the first time and wasn’t disappointed. It was super buttery and cheesy, just as I had hoped. There’s one that has French fries on it that has been popular in our house many times. Tuesday has the best deal of two slices and a drink for $6. Lots of seating with decor from local high schools.
… more
Jim
Nice place, cool chick at the counter. Will order from here again.
… more
… View more