Relaxed, intimate storefront for oysters & New American fare with craft cocktails & outdoor seats. Based on 259 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$$
Address:
15 2nd St, Troy, NY 12180
Phone: (518) 510-0747
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Robert Ross
The upside is the oysters are delicious and they offer some decent drinks, haven’t seen a Michelada on the menu since Mexico! I was pretty underwhelmed by the brunch and the service however, the black bean burger was pretty heavy with little flavor, just mashed up black beans. The burrito was pretty decent though and their potatoes were probably the high point. Service pretty slow, got the oysters before the drinks… and they seemed overwhelmed when the place wasn’t busy at all for a 12:15 brunch. I’m sure in the evenings for drinks and oysters it’s 5 stars but in terms of my brunch experience I’m giving it 3.
… more
Lauren S
What a great dining experience! The decor, atmosphere and music were on point and the waitstaff were very pleasant, attentive and helpful. We started off with some oysters, which were really great (my first time trying them!), and we ordered the cauliflower steak with coconut risotto & the fried chicken sandwich for our entrees. The chicken sandwich was tender and not too heavily breaded, and the rosemary parm fries were delicious! The cauliflower steak was a unique entree and really tasty; for me, the coconut risotto was the highlight of the dish. The prices seemed comparable to similar fare in the area, if not slightly less. We will definitely be back!
… more
George Wheeler (Wheelercub)
Blown away! Plumb Oyster Bar is high quality, well thought out, dining at it’s best.
… more
Lisanne Fredericksen
This place is special. Phenomenal food, the General Manager and Bartenders were amazing and you can tell they really take pride in everything they do. Highly recommend.
… more
Angie
The bartenders were very professional and friendly. The drinks were amazing. Looking forward to going back to try the food. This is not a place to go if your looking for a cheaper place to eat, however they have good happy hour drink specials.
… more
Hanh Nguyen
Good food and vibe. Started with curry egg. Main dishes were mussels and seafood roll.
… more
Ted Ngai
Oysters are fresh, mignonette sauce is just ok. Very friendly staff and pleasant environment. Prices are high for the level of food and services offered.
… more
Josh Meppen
This was by the far the best experience my wife and I have had in a very long time….By chance we spent the evenings with the owners and their very exceptional and inventive bartender, Colin (photo-right)… Although all (3) were extremely talented. They gave my wife and their full attention and spent most of the evenings coming up with custom out of this world cocktails…
… more
Patrick Kiley
This food was pretty bad. I’ll considered, poorly made. Overpriced. The wine was good though. The deviled eggs were good. The lobster roll our friends got looked good. Menu entrees though. A chicken sandwich isn’t that hard to get right. Does not require candied bacon or a fried egg or weird deep fried bread. Does require chicken not made of grizzle. Fries are better than weird wet potato block things. I remember this place being fine but I think it’s gone downhill.
… more
Mel J
Very nice, cute place located near the Troy Music Hall. We stopped there before a show. Menu is limited, but the items we had were delicious. The potatoes are delicious . Our waitress was awesome when around, but she kinda disappeared on us a few times.
… more
… View more