Plaza Pizza is the place to go in Newark, Ohio for a handcrafted pizza. Try one of our specialty pizzas or create your own. Each pizza we create comes with hand-tossed crust and a zesty family recipe sauce for a fresh taste. For something other than pizza try our giant torpedo subs, garlic bread, or apple pie dessert pizza. No gluten? No problem! We’ve got you covered with our cauliflower crust. Join us today at Plaza Pizza for a home town feel and a mouthwatering pizza!
Based on 668 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1130 Mt Vernon Rd #1, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 366-5627
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Monday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 4:30–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
justine swan
I’ve been in Newark for over 50 yrs. I grew up in this pizza. Since new owners took over a couple years ago it just hasn’t been good. Ive given them chance after chance hoping that I would get that pizza I used to love… NOPE! This last time I ordered an XL pepperoni mushroom, had to ask for extra cheese just to make sure it even had any on it. The time before you could barely see any cheese on it. The crust was so undercooked I had to fold it and put it in a cup! I ate a piece and was sick afterwards. I tried heating in oven to try and cook it a bit, to no avail, still tasted awful! I have tried several different times, it just is not the same, the workers obviously don’t know how to work the oven properly, this was all at the Newark location. Now I will say the Heath location has a better pizza closer to the one we all used to know. So sad!!!
… more
Kimberly West
Plaza pizza is delicious and worth the drive from where we live which is about 20 minutes away. We loved the first one so much we ordered it again the very next night!
… more
Richard Risbon
Last time I ordered pizza here, the people were extremely rude to me because I arrived a couple minutes before the time they said. I vowed never to enter the establishment again. Now over a year later they start sending me advertising texts? I didn’t give you my number so you could text me advertisements. Especially since your pizza isn’t ANYTHING near the quality that the previous owners produced and I have no interest to come in and be insulted by your rude staff!
… more
Sara Castro at Fox And Beans
The best pizza I’ve found in Newark! I love a good crispy thin crust and have a preference to cauliflower crust. This one is so good! Great cheese, sauce, spices, and toppings! (Pepperoni and mushroom…classic :D) I will order again for sure! My husband got a large regular crust with pepperoni and pineapple and he loves it too!
… more
Georginia Fortune
Ordered a few weeks ago they screwed up our order so they said we get a credit called yesterday and ordered it again figure we give it another try well only gave us 50% credit and told us it be ready one time sat there for another 15mins a
… more
John Nairn Smith
This is the best pizza in Newark, possibly the best pizza anywhere. Thin, flakey crust, perfectly spiced sauce, lots of fresh toppings… If you have never tried Plaza Pizza you need to try one today. Your life will not be complete until you do.
… more
Jason Green
I’ve been eating Plaza Pizza all my life, and it has been a staple in our home since before then. Y’all still have good pizza, but it is not the same. At the Newark location there is no consistency in flavor, texture or presentation other than the name.
… more
Gavin Rigel
Don’t have a mess up they will only give you 10% off your next when it’s their fault! Will be disputing this charge! They didn’t even offer for money back for recking our dinner
… more
Patrick
BEST PIZZAS IN NEWARK OHIO I APPRECIATE YOUR BUSINESS QUALITY PERSONAL AND I KNOW THAT NOW
… more
Karen Reynard
This is our new favorite pizza place! My husband loved the pepperoni pizza and the BBQ chicken pizza is like none I have had before… simply delicious!
… more
… View more