Based on 217 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4013 W 41st St, Sioux Falls, SD 57106
Phone: (605) 499-2111
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Skyler Paulsen
It’s an understatement when I say that this was genuinely the absolute BEST pizza I’ve ever had!! We ordered the Il Capo to go, and holy wow it was magnificent!! The fresh crust was amazing and the sauce is so rich and delicious. I actually can’t find the proper words to describe how good this pizza was. I’ve been looking for authentic New York style pizza since I first moved here from CO last year. I was always disappointed when I would order so called “New York” pizza, and it wasn’t even made in a NY style. THIS PLACE IS SO WORTH THE MONEY!! The 19’’ pizza is HUGE and worth every penny it costs! Don’t be deterred by the high prices, because the price is actually reasonable considering what you get- especially in this economy. Thank you so much PizzaShop for fulfilling my long awaited need for NY pizza! I will be ordering from here every single time I crave an authentic, made by hand pizza! The picture is from after I reheated it in the air fryer since I waited awhile to eat it once my boyfriend arrived home with it. Wow!! A pizza that is THIS DELICIOUS even after being reheated is crazy!!!
… more
Makayla V
Yum! I love the wood fired taste of the pizza!! I ate dine-in and only waited 15 minutes, which wasn’t long at all. The 12” is about the perfect size to share- I took home half of it and the pizza does reheat well in the air fryer. I love all the different options and the price is reasonable for what you get- my pizza was $15
… more
Dylan Jasper
Went in Sunday 05/21/23 and it was amazing. The wait wasn’t too long but it was worth the wait. We got 1 cheese slice and 1 pepperoni slice along with 10 garlic pesto knots with a drink and the total was around 22 dollars but it was worth it. The crust is amazing and it’s complimented by the delicious toppings. THOSE PESTO GARLIC KNOTS…..they were out of this world. The cook personally asked how much pesto we wanted and we got a lot of pesto and it works so well with the garlic knots I would probably get more pesto lol. If you are in the area stop here and get those pesto garlic knots and a slice, you won’t regret it.
… more
Jennifer Rerick
Aaaa-mazing pizza!!! The El Capo pizza is like if a pepperoni & margarita pizza had a baby- plus garlic. Wow!! And staff were so friendly!
… more
e
First time here and was very impressed. Great food, friendly staff I’d say best east coast style pizza in or around Sioux Falls hands down. Take a slice or customize that slice to grab and go. Order at the counter takes about a half hour and it’s worth the wait. I’ll be a regular here.
… more
Steve Lydick
In town for a few days, wanted a good pizza that wasn’t chain or take and bake. Got the plumber pete and il capo, both were great pies. Best pizza I’ve had in a while. Would love to go back when I return to town. Otherwise, come to Lincoln, Nebraska, please.
… more
Adriana Rocha
I have visited Pizzashop twice now and must say the crust is wonderful overall the taste of the pizza is great. However I wish I could give it five stars but I just personally can’t get over customer service treatment. First visit I was not even acknowledged by a wave or a smile but a simple stare in silence waiting to input my order. As it was my first visit I naturally asked what was recommended and the response was here is our menu. I ordered IL Capo which was very generously portioned with pepperoni which I can’t complain off overall taste of the sauce was delicious , if your unsure what to order I would say this is a good place to start. Second visit also just got a stare as I walked in and someone standing in silence to take my order. My second visit I ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza and again overall satisfied with taste.
… more
Dylan Reid
First off, If you are looking for an authentic slice of NY pizza, this is the best you will find in Sioux Falls. We ordered the large El Capo (fancy pepperoni with parmesan and basil). The crust had the perfect ability to fold in half in true NY style and was loaded with toppings. We ordered a large, which was like most XL pizzas in town. The price is the only slight knock as I can’t afford to eat it weekly like I want to!
… more
Carolin Paulson
Terrible experience! Don’t believe the marketing. We went here on a Wednesday night and ordered 4 slices of pizza. Seemingly an easy do right? Well we ended up getting the twice reheated cheese pizza previously delivered to another customer that was prepared wrong. They simply threw sausage on top and put it back in the oven and 10 mins later it was served up… not so fresh. After telling them that that’s not what we’ve ordered and that’s that not ok, we were told “they always would do that this way”. Staff was rude and unapologetic. Absolutely disappointing! Hope the owner would find this unacceptable…
… more
Joseph Torres
This place was incredible. My wife had celiac disease and they were able to accommodate gluten free and did a great job at watching for cross contamination. The gluten free pizza tasted amazing too! Their service was friendly and welcoming. The pizza taste and quality was equally as great. Only downside was spending $45 for two people. Although, we will definitely be going back.
… more
… View more