Pizza Supreme Menu - Garden City, NY

Based on 249 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Pizza Supreme 11530

Address:
678 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY 11530

Website:

Hours

Tuesday	11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11 AM–9 PM
Thursday	11 AM–9 PM
Friday	11 AM–9 PM
Saturday	11 AM–9 PM
Sunday	12–7 PM
Monday	11 AM–9 PM

Round Pie
Round Cheese Pie Classic cheese or create your own pizza.	$22.00
Round Extra Cheese Pie Classic double cheese.	$25.00
Round Mushrooms Pie Classic cheese and mushrooms.	$25.00
Round Pepperoni Pie Classic cheese and pepperoni.	$25.00
Round Sausage Pie Classic cheese and sausage.	$25.00
Round Onion Pie Classic cheese and onions.	$25.00
Round Garlic Pie Classic cheese and fresh garlic.	$25.00
Round Meatball Pie Classic cheese and all-beef meatballs.	$25.00
Round Fresh Peppers Pie Classic cheese and red & green peppers.	$25.00
Round Caesar Salad Pie Romaine croutons and caesar dressing.	$25.00
Round White Pie A sauce-less pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese.	$26.50
Round White Pie With Broccoli A sauce-less pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan cheese and broccoli.	$28.75
Round White Pie With Spinach A sauce-less pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan cheese and spinach.	$28.75
Round Vegetable Pie Topped with Broccoli,Spinach,Sauce and Mozzarella	$28.75
Round Fried Chicken Pie Fried chicken and mozzarella.	$32.00
Round Buffalo Chicken Pie Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese.	$32.00
Round Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Chicken, bacon, and yummy ranch sauce.	$35.00
Square Pie
Square Cheese Pie Classic cheese or create your own pizza.	$23.00
Square Extra Cheese Pie Classic double cheese.	$26.00
Square Mushrooms Pie Classic cheese and mushrooms.	$26.00
Square Pepperoni Pie Classic cheese and pepperoni.	$26.00
Square Sausage Pie Classic cheese and sausage.	$26.00
Square Onion Pie Classic cheese and onions.	$26.00
Square Garlic Pie Classic cheese and fresh garlic.	$26.00
Square Meatball Pie Classic cheese and all-beef meatballs.	$26.00
Square Fresh Peppers Pie Classic cheese and red & green peppers.	$26.00
Pizza by the Slice
Square Cheese Pizza Slice	$3.25
Square Extra Cheese Pizza Slice	$4.00
Square Mushrooms Pizza Slice	$4.00
Square Pepperoni Pizza Slice Classic cheese and pepperoni.	$4.00
Square Sausage Pizza Slice Classic cheese and sausage.	$4.00
Square Onion Pizza Slice Classic cheese and onions.	$4.00
Square Garlic Pizza Slice	$4.00
Square Fresh Peppers Pizza Slice	$4.00
Square Meatball Pizza Slice	$4.00
Neapolitan Pizza Slice Regular. Classic mozzarella and tomato sauce.	$4.00
Chicken Pizza Slice Classic cheese and chicken meat.	$6.05
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese.	$6.05
Chicken & Broccoli Pizza Slice Chicken, broccoli, tomato sauce and mozzarella.	$6.75
Veggie Pizza Slice Broccoli, spinach, tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.	$5.75
White Pizza Slice A sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese	$5.00
BBQ Pizza Slice Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat.	$6.05
Caesar Pizza Slice Romaine, croutons, caesar dressing and grated cheese.	$4.25
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice Chicken, bacon, and yummy ranch sauce.	$7.00
Salads
Salad Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, sweet peppers and olives.	$10.50
Salad With Grilled Chicken Lettuce, tomato, cucumber sweet peppers and olives.	$16.00
Salad With Fried Chicken Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, sweet peppers and olives.	$16.00
Antipasto Salad Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, sweet pepper, olives, salami, provolone, pepperoni.	$16.50
Caesar Salad Romaine, croutons, grated cheese and caesar dressing.	$10.50
Caesar Grilled Chicken Salad Romaine, croutons, grated cheese, caesar dressing and grilled chicken.	$16.00
Caesar Fried Chicken Salad Romaine, croutons, grated cheese, caesar dressing and fried chicken.	$16.00
Side Orders
Meatballs Ground meat prepared with bread crumbs, minced onion, and Italian seasoning.	$13.00
Sausage Who says sides are limited to just veggies? Get more meat & order a side of sausage.	$13.00
Garlic Knots A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.	$3.00
Pepperoni Pinwheels Pepperoni and mozzarella rolled in pizza dough.	$6.00
Broccoli Pinwheels Broccoli and mozzarella rolled in pizza dough.	$6.00
Spinach Pinwheels Spinach and mozzarella rolled in pizza dough.	$6.00
Mozzarella Sticks Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Served with a side of marinara sauce.	$10.50
Meat Rice Ball Chop meat and mozzarella and rice rolled in a ball fried golden brown severed with a side of sauce.	$6.00
Veggie Rice Ball Pureed broccoli, mozzarella, and rice rolled in a ball fried golden brown served with a side of sauce.	$6.00
Wings Deep-fried chicken wings with your choice of sauce.	$14.00
Specialties
Ricotta & Mozzarella Calzone Made with ricotta cheese and mozzarella.	$10.00
Ricotta, Mozzarella & Ham Calzone Ham, ricotta, mozzarella & parmesan.	$10.75
Veggie Roll Broccoli, spinach and mozzarella wrapped in pizza dough.	$10.75
Sausage & Pepper Roll Italian sausage with red sauce and mozzarella cheese.	$10.75
Meatball Roll Meatballs with red sauce and mozzarella cheese.	$10.75
Chicken Roll Strips of breaded chicken topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella.	$13.00
Garlic Bread Whole hero with fresh garlic and herbs	$4.50
Heros
Veal Cutlet Hero Veal cutlets, tomato sauce.	$15.50
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero Veal cutlets, tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.	$16.00
Chicken Cutlet Hero Breaded cutlet topped with sauce and cheese.	$15.00
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero Breaded cutlet topped with sauce and mozzarella cheese.	$15.50
Sausage & Peppers Hero Sausage and pepper and tomato sauce.	$13.00
Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana Hero Sausage, peppers mozzarella and tomato sauce.	$13.50
Eggplant Hero Topped with eggplant slices and marinara sauce.	$13.00
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero Topped with eggplant slices, mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce.	$13.50
Pepper & Egg Hero Pepper and egg omelet on toasted hero.	$13.00
Pepper & Egg Parmigiana Hero Pepper and egg with melted mozzarella on a toasted hero.	$13.50
Meatball Hero With marinara sauce and meatballs.	$13.00
Meatball Parmigiana Hero With marinara sauce, meatballs and mozzarella cheese.	$13.50
Sausage Hero With marinara sauce and sausage.	$13.00
Sausage Parmigiana Hero With marinara sauce, sausage and parmesan cheese.	$13.50
Cold Italian Hero Salami, provolone, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato and sweet peppers.	$13.00
Pasta
Pasta With Tomato Sauce Pasta tossed in our homemade tomato sauce.	$14.50
Pasta With Meatballs Pasta topped in our homemade meatballs.	$21.00
Pasta With Sausage Pasta topped in our homemade sausage.	$21.00
Spaghetti With Clam Sauce Spaghetti with chopped baby clams in a garlic and oil.	$17.00
Penne Ala Vodka Penne in vodka sauce.	$18.00
Penne With Chicken & Broccoli Penne with fried or grilled chicken in a tomato sauce.	$21.50
Penne With Chicken & Spinach Penne with fried or grilled chicken in a tomato sauce.	$21.50
Penne Alla Vodka With Chicken Penne in a homemade vodka sauce with fried or grilled chicken.	$23.00
Penne Ala Vodka With Chicken & Broccoli Penne in a homemade vodka sauce with sautéed broccoli and grilled or fried chicken.	$25.00
Penne Ala Vodka With Chicken & Spinach Penne in a homemade vodka sauce with sautéed spinach and grilled or fried chicken.	$25.00
Lasagna Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: Go for the crispy edge pieces.	$19.50
Stuffed Shells Classic ricotta stuffed shells with flavorful three-cheese ricotta filling and delicious marinara sauce.	$18.00
Ravioli Ravioli filled with cheese & tomato sauce.	$18.00
Baked Ziti Penne pasta with ricotta, tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese.	$18.00
Hot Dishes
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Veal cutlets, tomato sauce, and Parmesan cheese.	$21.75
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Fried chicken. cutlets, marinara sauce, and mozzarella.	$21.00
Eggplant Parmigiana eggplant topped with mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce served with pasta.	$19.00
Veal Parm Plate Veal cutlet, sauce and cheese no pasta	$16.00
Chicken Parm Plate Chicken cutlet, sauce and cheese no pasta	$15.50
Eggplant Parm Plate Eggplant, sauce, and cheese no pasta	$13.50
Drinks
Soda Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.	$3.75
Catering Menu
Baked Ziti Catering Ziti with ricotta, mozzarella and tomato sauce	$80.00
Ziti With Tomato Sauce Catering Ziti with mozzarella and tomato sauce baked to perfection in our oven. Supersized for your party.	$70.00
Chicken Parm Catering Grilled chicken breast, marinara sauce, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese. Supersized for your party.	$85.00
Veal Parm Catering Veal cutlets, tomato sauce, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese. Supersized for your party.	$85.00
Eggplant Parm Catering Slices of eggplant and tomato seasoned with mozzarella and parmesan cheese. Supersized for your party.	$85.00
Eggplant Rollatini Catering Seasoned ricotta and mozzarella cheese rolled in a slice of eggplant topped with a homemade tomato sauce.	$85.00
Sausage & Pepper Catering Sausage, pepper in tomato sauce.	$80.00
Meatballs Catering Ground meat rolled into small spheres, prepared with bread crumbs, minced onion, eggs, butter, and seasoning.	$70.00
Salad Catering Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, sweet peppers, and olives.	$75.00
Caesar Salad Catering Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, and grated cheese. Supersized for your party.	$75.00
Antipasto Salad Catering Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, sweet pepper, olives, salami, pepperoni, provolone.	$75.00
Grilled Chicken Salad Catering Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, sweet pepper, olives with grilled or fried chicken.	$85.00
Chicken Caesar Salad Catering Romaine, croutons, grated cheese, caesar dressing with grilled or fried chicken.	$85.00
Penne Vodka Catering Penne with our homemade vodka sauce. Supersized for your party.	$75.00
Chicken Wings Catering Whole chicken wings deep-fried. Supersized for your party.	$90.00
Rice Balls Catering Rice, mozzarella and chop meat or pureed broccoli rolled in a ball and fried to a golden brown with sauce on the side	$60.00
Party Heroes Catering Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato and sweet peppers. Heros need to be ordered 1 day before.	$79.00
Chicken Cutlet Heroes Catering Chicken, melted mozzarella, lettuce and tomato. Heros need to be ordered 1 day before	$90.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

J J

Grew up coming here with my family and still make trips out from the city. Many of square pies have been consumed and they are delicious. Makes me happy to see a local business that I’ve grown up with continue to thrive post pandemic.

… more

Daniel Kennedy

This pizza is actually very good. Everyone on LI knows what good pizza tastes like. If you give this place a try you won’t be let down.

… more

Dan Tyler

We got a supreme pizza from Pizza Supreme and it wasn’t your average supreme. It was WAYY above average, with slices soo big and toppings piled high. Their wings are also top notch! Ordered for delivery, they were super fast!

… more

Jay Malone

We ordered a cheese pie from this place fresh as you can get any also gave us 12 knots on the house very friendly people

… more

Dawn Hetzel

I found out by chance today that the pizza I raved about from my childhood still existed, brought a square cheese pie home and it is just as good as I remembered & everyone loved it. This will be my go to pizza even though I live 40 minutes away.

… more

Kevin Law

Great square slices. Always fresh. Garlic knots are some of the best I have ever had. Can eat just the knots with a side of sauce as a meal. Covered in oil, garlic and spices will have you wanting more. Great staff and great service.

… more

Bernadett Thom

Great pizza spot. Good I taste and service was great too! My nephews loves it.

… more

Gail Marques

Pizza was only okay, service and people were great, but overall not comparable to the many great pizza places long island has to offer

… more

Denice Dublin

I’ve been eating the square slides since I was a kid. Reasonably priced and always delicious. I live in Suffolk so any time I’m in Nassau, I get my Pizza Supreme fix!

… more

Andrew Green

Classic New York style floppy pizza. No black olives. Tastes unbelievable, the “sauce” tastes like broth from a Mexican soup called Sopita. Careful, the pizza likes to wiggle around causing the cheese to practically drip off.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Pizza Supreme Menu – Garden City, NY

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions