Based on 65 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
Address:
527 W Main St, Butler, IN 46721
Phone: (260) 868-0018
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sherry LaRoe
We had an excellent experience with Pizza Shack. We had pizza’s and a sub. The food was hot and delicious. Plus our delivery time was fast and prompt. Our delivery person was professional and polite. I highly recommend the Pizza Shack. We will definitely order from them again.
… more
Angela Buell
Oh my!! I have ate at Pizza Shack a couple of times now and haven’t had any problems, but have rather enjoyed some delicious pizza. The crust is soft and chewy- exactly how I like it, the sauce is wonderful, and they don’t skimp on the toppings. I definitely recommend this place!
… more
Joshua Wells
Service was smooth and the Pizza was GREAT. This takes my number one spot of white box (brown in this case) local pizza places I’ve ever had ever. Will be making trips here a part of my weekend routine. Seriously keep it up.
… more
Cullen Reed
Cheaper than dominos or other national delivery chains and with 90% less salt. Not amazing pizza by any stretch of the imagination, but typical savory, delicious Ohio/Indiana style pizza. The calzones are good and are more reminiscent of the WV Pepperoni Roll, which is a good if that’s what you’re looking for. Really friendly staff, no frills, great filling lunch at a reasonable price.
… more
David McGregor
Great 1/2 sub, chips, and drink lunch deal. I’ve had several different subs and they’ve all been great. Very friendly staff as well.
… more
John Vandyke
Pizzas are good, but prices are a little high for the area. Depending on who is working, the staff on most days are nice and seem to know what’s going on. Other days not so much.
… more
Karen Savage
Very nice and the pizza taste like home made from scratch and the subs were Awsome.
… more
DragonSteel
This place has some amazing food but I can never get an answer on the phone. I’ve called multiple times and they haven’t answered
… more
David Mann
Very good pizza that doesn’t hurt the wallet. Friendly service and a great place to eat.
… more
Dakota Hicks
Food is delicious and always hot. The workers are always happy and personable. Never disappointed.
… more
… View more