Based on 130 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
110 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454
Phone: (585) 243-3690
Website: https://www.pizzapauls.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Justin Wirth
Perfectly cooked pizza and wings. Fast service. Great prices. Can you ask for anything better? I love the flavor of the BBQ wings and the crust is PERFECT. We get pizza here weekly. We have never had a bad experience. I miss the late owner but his crew is still going strong. See you next week!!
… more
joe dagostino
What happened to the pizza I grew up on?
… more
Katrina Maloney
Very good. The calzone was huge and really full. Everyone who had pizza in my group said the crust was great. Guy working there was friendly.
… more
wja2012
A great little place, and most importantly: more than solid pizza. A cheese slice the size of a plate for less than $5.00, and you won’t regret it for a second. Also has a ton of other options besides pizza, including calzones and subs.
… more
justin koschara
Sadly this place has gone down hill. Wing sauce was really lacking… no Buffalo favor or body at all. And the sheet pizza hardly any pepperoni except for the couple pieces they dumped a pile on. This was a childhood treat that is not the same anymore!
… more
James Shattell
Was hoping for an open pizza place in the old business district of the charming college town of Geneseo New York. I wanted to take a group of young elementary and middle school students for pizza after a good day of launching rockets at the National War Plane Museum fields which is the launch site for the Monroe Area rocket Society (MARS). We found Pizza Paul’s. We order up a couple of larges, one with pepperoni and the other one just plain cheese. The sauce was okay. The crust was the fluffy doughy style which is okay with me as long as the bottom is crisp and lightly brown which it was. The dough actually had a really good taste which means whoever makes the dough tmust use good quality semolina. We ate inside thpugh there was no air conditioning. I wish they would have had tables outside. Fountain soda is always a nice touch to a pizza parlor. Too bad this place only has can or liter bottles. Me and all the kids ate our slices down. It is likely I will stop here again as I often launch rockets in Geneseo.
… more
The_Rock_Painter 1
I was told they don’t take phone orders except for Saturday and Sunday. They don’t offer their pizza / wing combos on line . I was told over the phone how to do this , which probably took longer than it would than to have just taken my order. I hung up the phone and dialed j and t pizza where they take phone orders !!!!!!! Lost my business
… more
Joshua Peter
Been coming here since 2010 and still the best pizza joint in Geneseo.
… more
Michelle Davis
I was stopping in town to get some food and this place was one of the only options open on Sunday. The pizza (I ordered double thick crust) was decent. But I was excited to try ‘pauls balls’, basically fried balls of dough with toppings. I ordered the sweet balls, with powered sugar and raspberry drizzle,but was completely bummed when I went to chow and the middle of the ball was raw dough. I was under the impression that it would be cooked throughout. It was disappointing and a complete waste of money. Below is a photo of the damage.Raw balls.
… more
racerpoet
As a commuting student, this used to be my go-to spot when I didn’t bring a lunch with me. I’m a big pizza lover, so when Pizza Paul’s was recommended to me by one of my professors, I had to try it. I got my first slice here on my first week attending Geneseo. The pizza was a little different than what I was used to, but I kept coming back and it really grew on me. The Buffalo slice was my favorite.
… more
… View more