Pizza Mia Menu – New Windsor, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : New Windsor, NY

Sandwiches, pasta & other casual Italian eats served in a classic pizza parlor with custom pies. Based on 142 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

Pizza Mia 12553

Address:
176 Windsor Hwy # 600, New Windsor, NY 12553

Phone: (845) 563-9100

Website: https://pizzamia-ny.com/

Menu

Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$10.50
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$17.99
Appetizers
Garlic Knots $4.50
French Fries With Cheese $4.99
Homemade Dough
Fresh Homemade Dough $3.99
Pizza Cheese Dough $6.99
Fresh Salads
Garden Salad
Mixed greens with garden vegetables.
$6.99
Side Salad $3.99
Desserts
New York Style Cheesecake $4.50
Homemade Fried Dough $4.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

William Gimeranez
Great pizza joint here. Amazing began options. Regular pizza and Italian food too. Friendly staff. I always want to eat the whole menu.

… more

William Gimeranez
Great place for Vegan and Regular pizza and Italian food. Amazing friendly staff.

… more

Kurt Robinson
It was great to come back home to a place that made vegan pizza. But that’s not all, garlic knots, and sandwiches too. I recommend the cheese steak(vegan) all the fixings. It’s a mouthful of flavor.

… more

R Garza
Delicious pizza! Crust is very unique loove it not 5 stars because could use some interior improvement

… more

Bryan Takeuchi
Love this place! The staff is always great and the service is quick. The pizzas excellent, I come here fairly regularly for a couple slices since it’s right down the road. Def one of the best pizza places in the area

… more

Stanley Zgrodek
Pizza Mia is the best choice for pizza in the New Windsor and Newburgh area. Their ingredients are always fresh, and they specialize in over 100 gourmet slices. Whether you’re coming in for lunch, or ordering for fast delivery, Pizza Mia puts customer service at the forefront of everything they do. I’ve noticed myself driving past several pizzerias in the area just to get there, because I know I will always be greeted with a smile by everyone. In the competitive field of pizza, Pizza Mia goes the extra mile to satisfy every customer and keep them coming back. Don’t forget to try some authentic Italian cuisine from the kitchen next time you stop in, and be sure to ask for a catering menu for your next big event.

… more

Robin Meyer
Been a few years since last visit, Food was good as remembered. Staff very friendly and extremely good at getting things just as asked for with several special requests that my family needed. But I do feel they need to bring it back up to the level of cleanliness that I remember. (I was noticing the appearance had become just a little run down and then saw a tiny bug on the counter.) This is not a major problem, but it does disappoint when other locations (same name) are in better condition. Try A good deep clean, some new paint maybe?

… more

Paden’s Place
One of my favorite pizza shops in the area. Great pies. Delicious pepperoni rolls and garlic knots. Dinner specials. Perfect place to stop in while on break. They also deliver. I would reccomend ordering the pie “well done” as they tend to undercook a tad. I also just like it really crispy.

… more

Justin Combs
This Pizza was like nothing I’ve ever had before. The sauce was AMAZING! I just wish this place was closer to me! The owner is also very friendly! Only complaint is that the inside was a little hot, but the pizza was THAT good that I didn’t care

… more

T LD
I have been to this pizza place several times, since Sal’s changed hands. The only thing that I can say on a positive note about this site is their delivery is fast. That could have something to do with only getting part of what you ordered due to staff that doesn’t seem to hear what you’ve ordering. There are too many places that will deliver what you ordered and their staff is competent. Won’t spend my money here again

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions