VOTED BEST PIZZA iIN THE HUDSON VALLEY IN 2020!!! Pizza Mia is a gourmet Italian pizzeria that offers delicious traditional New York-style pizza, homemade Italian cuisine and unparalleled service! The pizza is made using 100% natural mozzarella, the handmade, hand-tossed dough is prepared from scratch daily and all of our sauce is made in house!
Pizza Mia has won BEST PIZZA IN THE HUDSON VALLEY 10 times over the last 15 years!! Stop by to experience Love at 1st Slice!!
We also offer takeout & delivery service!!
Sandwiches, pasta & other casual Italian eats served in a classic pizza parlor with custom pies. Based on 234 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3650 US Highway 9W # East, Highland, NY 12528
Phone: (845) 691-4545
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
kimberly peeters
Okay so, the garlic knots were the best thing. I ordered the penne ala vodka which would have been good if there was enough sauce. They give you a piece of bread with no sauce to dip it in. The side salad only comes with shaved carrots and a slice of tomato, no onions or olives. The food came a half an hour earlier than expected. I give only 3 stars due to lack of sauce and no utensils after specifying to add those. Otherwise the food was good just lacking things other Italian restaurants provide…first time ordering from there but I’ll have to check out the other spots around here you gotta be competitive in the food industry
Brandon Polley
I’ve had pizza all over the country and would consider myself a connoisseur of pizza, if there was such a thing. With that said, this was an excellent pizza! I don’t want to call the pizza simple as that may be offensive, but I just like a good ole pizza, and this was it. Good crust, cheese, sauce, and pepperoni cooked to a golden brown. Also the sauce for the knots was amazing!
Gina Longo
My husband and I have been coming here for food for so long now, always hot, fresh, and delicious. The crew is always very nice and friendly + knows us now when we come in. Looking for a great pizza spot, look no further!
Adriane Champion
Food is always so random. Some days it’s great and tonight it sucks. The salad came with lettuce and meat. Where are the seasonal veggies? Lol it’s not like you can’t tell me have the pizza toppings are veggies too?? Maybe hire some men over 18 and actually make eye contact with customers and say please and thank you.
Ralph
So inconsistent, it is now frustrating. Where the heck is the vodka sauce ??? Why is it always a coin toss if the food will be good ? It’s not worth the money anymore. ✌️
Ed Felicia
First time ordering from this place, I see it got best in the Hudson Valley, I ordered a large pizza with Jalapeños, Mushrooms, Pepperoni and extra cheese, The pizza was delicious and made with good quality ingredients, The only complaint that I have is that if I’m paying almost $40.00 for a pizza with toppings I should get just that, There wasn’t enough toppings on the pizza for the price that I paid and at least three slices didn’t have all of the toppings that I ordered, I will be a repeat customer however any orders placed in the future I would expect to get enough toppings to justify the price, Maybe a discount next time fellas?
Shipper Enthusiast
Me and my family always order pizza from here and have for as long as they have been open. When trying to order pizza tonight the employees put me on hold and said some disturbing things about my family, saying we don’t tip and more. Which is so unprofessional and not true whatsoever. As someone who works in the food service industry I understand how important tips are and always make sure to fairly compensate my drivers. This gave me a bad taste in my mouth, like how do I know that those employees won’t do something to my food next time. Very disappointed in the establishment and how the employees treat their long time customers. I will not be returning after this.
… more
Cliff
The pizza has been more spot on than ever. It’s become my favorite for this area.
Julie Bills
The staff at Pizza Mia in Highland are so friendly and welcoming and the pizza is GREAT! Gino went out of his way to make my husband the perfect Vegan pizza. We go to Pizza Mia every time we’re in town.
shaun mcguire
Really, really good pizza joint. Chicken noodle soup on point, pepperoni roll unique and HUGE. Best pizza in the Hudson Valley? I don’t know about that… But definitely worth your time!
… View more