Based on 138 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
9 Main St, Otisville, NY 10963
Phone: (845) 386-1010
Website: https://www.facebook.com/pizzamaniaotisvilleny
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jackie Talmadge
Great Pizza ! Friday Nights were Pizza Mania Pizza usually! Sausage & Mushroom & Peppers for my Sister & Myself! Brian & Cindy the nicest people!
Krysta Idel
Out of the two pizza places in town, this is definitely the one you want to go with. Friendly staff, affordable prices, fast delivery times. Overall just great customer service, where Nick’s just always acts like you’re inconveniencing them by calling.
Audra S
Just had 2 delicious pizzas! Called in order, was told about 20mins. Arrived early, told maybe 5mins more, was less that that. We had a plain cheese and a sausage. Crust and sauce were both delicious. And the sausage was really good too. It was good tasting and not spicy or zippy at all. There was a nice amount of cheese on both pies. It was also good quality cheese as it wasn’t greasy at all. Nice balance of sauce, cheese & sausage. Both were perfect!
Anthony Schifano
Love the pizza, love that they deliver, but will never understand how they wouldn’t be open on Super Bowl Sunday, probably the biggest money maker of the year. I get they’re closed on Sunday’s, but that day…that’s our place and that’s where I wanted to order from.
L Gage
I have always said that pizza should be its own food group I love pizza but the past few years I have not been able to find a good pizza my favorite pizza place changed hands and that was the end of that well I went to Pizza Mania today OMG what a awesome Pizza the best pizza I have had in years I just moved into the area and I am so happy I have a pizza place that I love a bar that I have to try out and a liquor store that I love in the same Corner OMG I am so happy try Pizza Mania it is awesome and the guys are really nice
Marymbw
We went to pick up our pizza last night. None of the employees were wearing masks. There weren’t any signs posted stating that you must wear a mask when entering. None of the people waiting inside for food had masks on except for my husband. We have been eating from this restaurant for years. But we will never eat here again.
Mike DePolito
Love the Christian ✝️ atmosphere. Food very good and Brian and Cindy very nice
Priestly Canty
Excellent Grilled Chicken, & Crispy Chicken salad; Seasoned well.
matthew eugenio
I ordered from here about 3 weeks ago. The pizza was undercooked and loaded with too much cheese. My friend adon called it “un eatable” because of the quantity of cheese. However, i would like to compliment the delivery service! Very polite young man named zachary was a great deliverer!
Alayna F
Horrible experience! When I entered to pick up my pizza neither the owner nor the other women behind the counter was wearing a proper mask and had their faces mostly uncovered. Then an apparent friend of theirs walked in and also did not have a mask on. when I asked why they don’t require customers to wear a mask the owner said ” It doesn’t matter to me, i don’t believe in the masks”. My pizza was also dry and the broccoli was burnt. Nick’s pizza in Ottisville is far better anyways!
… View more