Old school cooking with a Maui attitude is what Pizza in Paradise is all about. We cook fresh food as fast as we can using time honored recipes as well as some chef special creations. We use locally produced fruits and vegetables. This is a family friendly restaurant. We do not serve alcohol but you are welcome to BYOB. We have won numerous awards, from Tripadvisor, Maui Revealed book. So if you are in the mood for a slice of paradise stop on down and give us a try!
No-frills parlor serving gourmet pizzas with house-made sauce & dough, Italian pastas & subs. Based on 264 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
Address:
60 E Wakea Ave #101, Kahului, HI 96732
Phone: (808) 871-8188
Website:
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Roberto Valdemarca
Awesome service (even gave us some extra Italian Knots to make splitting them easier)! Absolutely fantastic pizza! Some of the best I’ve ever had. The only thing I wish was that we’d found it sooner!
… more
Jayanth Anantharaman (Jay)
This place was a bit disappointing. The pizza was very soggy. We wanted to try their stuffed pizza but they were reluctant to take the order as it takes almost an hour to bake the stuffed pizza.
… more
Peter Wade
It was an order to go place, in an old metal building. However, if you order and wait it is well worth it. We got garlic knots and Popeyes spinach pizza. It was delicious, all made to order and melted in your mouth. Don’t be scared away. My wife and I split a small and it was loaded and more then we could eat!
… more
Sara Cousins
The pizza was amazing and the staff was able to accommodate my food allergy with no problem. The crust is hand tossed, crisp bottom and tender, chewy interior. Super fresh toppings and the least expensive meal on our stay so far! The Parmesan Italian Knots (and cinnamon ones too) were so good! We can’t even get pizza at home (Iowa) as good quality and pay that low a price!
… more
Roosha Nawaz
Nice people and ok pizza. Sauce recipe was weird. Had tons of chopped onions in the sauce. So it tasted kind of sweet, more fusion style. Tomato sauce doesn’t traditionally have onions pieces in it. I’d recommend the restaurant using onion powder instead if they still want that flavor.
… more
Will Wegert
STOP! Seriously just stop what you are doing and eat at this place. Don’t bother reading about other restaurants. You found “the one” …
… more
Caleb McCully
The Chicken Pesto pizza is incredible. Super relaxed atmosphere, super friendly staff. 10/10 one of my best experiences in Hawaii thus far.
… more
Molly Mandala
This is my favorite pizza place in island! Auntie is so sweet and I love supporting business that have been here for over 20 years.
… more
Vandana Kulkarni
The veg pizza was very soggy and the taste was not good at all!
… more
Peggy L
Very odd phone interaction when calling in my to-go order. Then was quoted 20-30 minutes but it took nearly 40 minutes.
… more
… View more
