Based on 223 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600, New Windsor, NY 12553
Phone: (845) 569-8888
Website: http://pizzaheavenny.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jahnny Crespo
This was my first time trying out Pizza Heaven’s giant pizza once I took the first bite it felt like I was in heaven.
… more
Zeus Almighty
I decided to stop here since people in the area of this shop rave about it. It’s been hit or miss for the two times total that I’ve stopped here. The first time the pizza wasn’t (a huge slice) but it was fairly decent. The second time it was an actual huge slice, but had a huge puddle of oil in the middle of the pizza. Not exactly a deal breaker, but I definitely had to sop all of it up with a napkin first. I’d give the pizza a 3/5. I believe a single “jumbo slice” is $4.
… more
A G
1st visit here for pickup. Ordered pizza and garlic knots. Didn’t know this place makes a good regular cheese pie. Garlic knots were made perfect not overly toasted. Friendly staff. Will Def be returning.
… more
Enrique Cruz
The food is good. The giant pizza is $4. If the husband could have a better attitude and smile more. I think it’ll be a better place
… more
Linda Brown
Normally I wouldn’t give this place a 1 star at all because the pizza is fantastic. This review is strictly for the service of the young blonde lady with a bun on top her head at the counter. Her attitude towards me specifically was rude. I simply asked her for two extra cheesy slices and two calzones and just separate it in two boxes. She tells the cooks I wanted two LARGE PIES. I told her no I asked for slices and instead of apologizing for the miss-hap she gets argumentative about it!! Telling me I said something different when I didn’t. Then proceeds to charge me and then instead of handing me my receipt she just drops it in front of me.
… more
Kevin Martin
This is the closest I have ever come to Bronx pizza. Pizza Heaven also has the fluffiest and crispiest Sicilian slices I have ever had anywhere. Plus the garlic knots are the freshest and tastiest I ever had; just the right amount of garlic and fluffy as well. There are other pizza shops closer to me, but this place is worth the extra time. I must also add is they have one of the best customer service ethic and friendliest attitudes I have ever experienced at a business.
… more
Rachel Milito your Realtor
WOW !!! The slices of pizza here are massive!! It really is PIZZA HEAVEN. They are more then double of what a normal slice usually is. My nephew and I popped in for a quick slice in between his taekwondo classes. Pizza was delicious as well. The staff is super friendly and the restaurant is very clean and comfortable ! Thanks for a great dinner !!! We will be back
… more
Kevin C.
Their giant slice is the best Brooklyn style slice in the area. Nice thin crust with a slight crisp to it. Sauce is awesome – not too acid. Just delicious. When I first had one – it was like flashbacks to when I was a kid. Regarding the reviews on here about the pizza having no taste – I’m not sure what the deal is with that, but I guess if you’ve grown up thinking the average pizza around here is authentic Brooklyn style – you’re wrong.
… more
Alex goebel
Amazing!! They have the best pizza in the area in my opinion and they have this amazing large slice of cheese pizza that is like 2.5 slices for only $3.50!
… more
Rachel OREILLY
Our fave place for pizza and salads and everything is good here. They also have the best staff so helpful and friendly. Highly recommend the food here is fresh and delicious!
… more
… View more