Based on 692 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
N56W15560 Silver Spring Dr, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
Phone: (262) 781-9400
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–2 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Evan Toebe
Our visit was on a Saturday around 1pm. The buffet was not well stocked. They never brought any new food and the same five stale cold pizzas were still there when we finished. The food may be good but it’s hard to tell when you have had cold pizza that has been sitting out for what looks like at least an hour. They had a few shriveled up bread sticks as well. They have no straws and looked at me like I was speaking a foreign language when I asked for one so I just gave up trying to acquire one. They have several staff standing around doing nothing but expect you to clear off your own dishes and put them in some bins near the buffet. I would recommend you avoid this place it’s just not worth it. I feel like I would have better off just buying a hot pocket and heating it up in a dirty gas station microwave. At least it would not have cost me $15 a person.
… more
Edward Brockman
I would definitely agree with the other reviews of nothing available to choose from. 50% of the counter was empty with three people behind it. No interaction from any of the staff. If you have ever been to a cici’s pizza, this place makes it look five star. I will never come again or at all recommend this place.
… more
Shalini khare
This is such an amazing buffet pizza place. Wonderful salad bar and variety of pizza options. Staff was friendly and food was delicious.Buffet is reasonably priced too.
… more
Some guy
Pizza Crafters reminded me of Tazino’s in Oak Creek. Great spot for a get-together or just to go for the day.
… more
Amber Sherry
I took my kids and grandparents here at 1pm on a Tuesday for lunch. When we came in, I was ready to leave immediately when I seen every table – was terribly dirty. I felt I had driven all this way so I told the desk person of this issue and proceeded to pay over $50 for all of us (5 people). We found a spot prior that was near a section of what looked like a workspace. The buffet was very scarce and I asked if they will ne making more food. I was told that they were slow and they weren’t going to make any more for an entire section. (See in photos). I said that if I am to come in and see an empty buffet, how will I try the food? They said they had garlic sticks and was fine with that. After they started making more pizzas and asked what we would like to try, which was nice. I Said again if I could try the macaroni and seems I was getting excuses of why the staff didn’t want to make any. I came back and seen there was one compartment filled (macaroni). I took back to try and it was cold :(. Salad bar was good. You have to clear off your own table of plates, and probably end up cleaning your table before you sit also. When we were leaving, they made a dessert. I am really surprised because there were good reviews here! There were about 5 workers here, one should be making sure tables are clean!!! No excuses!
… more
Jenni Jex
We enjoyed our family lunch here today. The place was clean and had a good selection of pizzas. I like that they have a specialty pizza of the week to add variety to their menu for returning customers. The salad bar was great! The kids also enjoyed the window where they could watch pizzas being made.
… more
shawn thiele
I stopped here today with my kids as it was close to where we were hiking. The kids and I definitely enjoyed it and would come back again if we were in the area. The pizza was as good or better than other pizza buffets we’ve gone to over the years. There was a good selection of pizzas, and they cooked up a pizza my daughter requested. They also had some tasty garlic cheese strips, and a salad area that I didn’t partake in so cannot comment on. The price was reasonable for the selection of food in my opinion.
… more
Drew Jefferson
I stumbled onto this place by accident. Had a bad experience one night with a pizza place next to Wing Stop on 124th & Capitol.
… more
Steph G
We have been coming here for years now and our most recent visit will be our last. For my family, it was almost $70 for dinner. I think it’s ridiculous drinks aren’t included in the buffet here. The food has really gone down hill. The selection of pizza is not good. We asked for a deep dish, but when we got it, it was burnt on the outside and doughy/undercooked on the inside. There’s no flavor anymore. The salad dressing bottle had HAIR on it. And the FRUITFLIES are so bad! My 6 year old came back from the buffet in tears because she couldn’t even get a brownie because of how many flies were swarming by them. Gross. The workers seem not to care either. Just swat them away. I killed 2 just while sitting at our table. I witnessed a child drop their pizza on the floor right by the front desk and no one cleaned up the sauce. That could have been very dangerous. On our way out, the cashier/hostess only paid attention to her cell phone and didn’t even acknowledge us or say goodbye, thank you, anything… this place isn’t the same. We will not be returning.
… more
Bhuvaneswari Muralitharan
Excellent food at a very good price. Very friendly and polite staff members, very friendly atmosphere to go and we enjoy the food with family, very cheesy yummy varieties of pizzas to choose on their buffet, excellent brownie dessert. Loved the place. They were refilling continuously.
… more
… View more