Humble, community-oriented pizzeria with East Coast-style pies & slices, homemade sauces & wings. Based on 987 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
126 W Laurel St, Fort Collins, CO 80524
Phone: (970) 221-9144
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joshua Leopold
I honestly used to love you, and you were my favorite pizza in town for years. But then I got this pizza delivered. It was supposed to be a medium extra cheese. Not only was it the wrong pizza, but it looked awful, and was cold. I called to ask for another pizza, but I was told I’d have to wait over an hour. So I asked for a refund. I was told that I could only receive a 50% refund and a coupon for the other 50% that I would have to pick at their location. I understand that you were busy, but this pizza shouldn’t have even made it out the door. And please, please figure out a better refund policy. Not only should my pizza have been refunded, I should have been given a coupon for another pizza or something.
… more
Aaron Decker
This is my favorite pizza in Fort Collins!
James Sheriff
This place is hands down the best pizza in foco. It’s local, the owner is amazing and the nicest dude. We got the double xl and it will feed me and my bro for two days easily. So freaking good! If you haven’t tried it, you absolutely need to. I’ve been to nyc multiple times and this is about as close as I’ve gotten to that.
Liv Stumbles
All of these visits happened within the last year.
Mia Daly
favorite pizza place in fort collins! Always super affordable! This place has amazing slices but also has GIANT pizzas that have fueled many of my drunk evenings. So delicious, everyone is so sweet, it seems like such a cool crew.
Mantis Robinson
I used to love this place, I would order pretty frequently but you better not call within the last 30 minutes of closing and order delivery. They won’t do it, even when I’m in the free delivery range less than 2 miles away that they’ve always done.
Michelle Meadows
I was very excited to try this place as reviews are excellent. I was disappointed. The dough tasted great. The pizza has a decent flavor overall. The pizza was not topped like the picture shows on the website at all. What we ordered was a Brooklyn deluxe. Barely any pepperoni and sparse basil that looked dried not fresh. We also ordered 12 wings and asked for them Xtra crispy. The wings had a decent flavor, but were not crispy and almost like the texture of baked wings. It was a little gross. So, three stars because the order was done fast and the flavor was decent. Will not go here again.
Rachel Brower
Pizza is okay. Very thin and very stingy on the cheese. Would not recommend meatballs on pizza – tasted like they were all breading and/or made earlier in the week.
Connor Hamp
Ordered the spicy mushroom pizza. Tasted like plain marinara with Tabasco or buffalo sauce in it, very greasy with a (too) thin crust, which was floppy in the middle. Reasonable price but bad pizza when chains are honestly better. Do not recommend.
AJ L
My first time for Pizza Casbah. Delivery. No disappointment here! For our family group of six I decided to go with three 18″ pies – the Athena, the New Yorker and the Bronx deluxe. We like traditional pizza so these three fit the bill. What was I thinking ordering three? Looks like we’ll be having pizza for breakfast tomorrow. These are truly 18″ pizzas. Very light with a thin crust, and well-developed flavors and very satisfying and filling. Pies were delivered exactly per the estimate contained in the email confirmation. Pies arrived HOT. Our delivery person called me from her vehicle to say that she was parked out front and would leave the pizzas by the door. Nicely browned and crisped crust, good flavors, not overly salty, just the right amount of cheese, and the flavor of the toppings came through nicely. Will be doing Pizza Casbah again.
… more
… View more