Based on 226 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
222 N Michigan St, Plymouth, IN 46563
Phone: (574) 936-8855
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Pizza-Bills-121374771209811/?fref=ts
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Paul Stanko
I was introduced to Pizza Bill’s pizza and sandwiches just a few months ago. Pizza is truly outstanding, especially the crust. I prefer thin, crisp crust that allows the sauce and toppings to shine. Their range of sandwiches is enough to satisfy any taste. A half sub is plenty for a lunch on the go. I’ve enjoyed everything I have tried on their menu so far.
… more
angie wilson (coolassang)
The best thin crust pizza for miles and best pizza, in general. The Deluxe is a can’t miss!
… more
Brian Van Duyne
Great spot for lunch or dinner love the deluxe pizza.
… more
True Blue
The wet burrito and chicken alfredo are good. The pizza is not to my taste, with “cardboard crust” that tastes like it came from the freezer.
… more
Orion Lemler
Pizza Bill’s comes very close to my favorite pizza. Their fresh ingredients make all the difference. The sauce and crust is among the best I’ve had too.
… more
Ryan Jackson
The food was amazing! We all loved everything we ordered. I had the beef and bean wet burrito which was great. My fiance had the vegetable pizza which was right up her alley and she loved and our daughter had the taco salad and really enjoyed it. You order drinks in the back and food at the front. It’s a great experience and we definitely will be back.
… more
Sean Turner
The last time I was at Pizza Bill’s, was back in 2001. I moved back to Indiana after 20 years, and was so excited to take the family there. We were looking for a place to eat, and had little to no success in finding a place that was still open. Lo and behold, Google said that Pizza Bill’s was open; or at least was SUPPOSED to be open. We got there, right in front of the building and saw that there was no dine- in seating. No problem. We saw workers inside, and so decided to call in our order, only to find out that the decided to close about a half hour early. I was so excited and talked up this place to my family, only to be disappointed and let down. Not sure if I even want to go back at this point. I haven’t decided. I left upset. My family left upset. *sigh*
… more
richard heiman
Great pizza! Can be a little pricey, but definitely worth the price tag. They have plenty of seating for dining in. They have variety on food too, not just pizza. Some Mexican style dishes and pastas too. Highly recommend the wet burritos!
… more
Mr. B.
Nachos and soft tacos were underwhelming at best and did not help that the nacho chips were stale and buried under two inches of cafeteria grade beef. The young lady that helped me microwaved my soft tacos and the $9.00 nachos deluxe. Yes folks the microwave is located directly where you pay for the food. I would never recommend this place to anyone unless their pizza is a world above the subpar Mexican menu that they offered. Wasn’t even given silverware or napkins and they put my food in a beer box top so I could carry it out. This might have been fine in the 80s but it is 2020 and I’ll pass with my hard earned money. Try harder folks.
… more
Chris Perras
We were nervous at first, as when I asked the young man behind the counter for a recommendation for first time visitors, he looked scared! A quick look around and noticed nachos on almost every table. Okay, we’ll play your game. Deluxe Nachos it is, we weren’t disappointed at all! Now, the pizza, reminded us of high school/ bowling alley pizza. Not horrible, but not what we wanted. Sauce was okay and it was definitely cheesy. Not sure if we’ll be back, but it was good.
… more
… View more