Based on 490 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3717 Lake Emma Rd, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Phone: (407) 744-9044
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: pizza1905lakemary.com
Reviews
Saulo Simoes
Pretty good, you can eat in at one of the few tables or take out. Nice folks serve the deep dish Chicago style pie, which is very large and tasty. I like my pizza piping hot and next time I will ask them to keep it a little longer in the oven. For take out it is perfect since it’s probably going to be warmed up at home.
Juan Rosario
I keep saying this is my favorite pizza spot please come and try what’s new now ask for the pulled pork sub wednesday to friday let’s support local and what originates from them as the best pizza in town. The picture is the 24” pizza
Dominick Hardman
1905 has the best pizza in lake mary and anywhere else around! knocks everyone else out of the competition. the bianca pizza is my favorite also their garlic knots are to die for! i travel 20 minutes away to and from at least once a month or whenever i can just for some yummy pizza i swear! and ontop of that the staff is always full of smiles and so friendly! i went in during a hurricane and they were open and told me to take a free soda can and told me to stay safe! they truly care for their food and their customers!
Brittany Lane
Very good pizza and garlic knots! Friendly staff very welcoming! Definitely will be back!
BEATRIZ BERRIOS
Sad to see this place look so blah. The pizza was flat no crust at all. No conversation nothing. The lady at the register looked so tired and had no customer service skills. Sadly as much as I referred actual New York pizza to everyone I will not be doing that any longer. The didn’t even have paper towels they had a roll of hard hand towels like who uses those as napkins.
Ribhia Sulieman
Really mean. Don’t bring kids and don’t eat in. Pizza is not bad but quite expensive. I’m never going back though because of the revolting attitude of the owner. Opposite of welcoming.
Lori
Tried Pizza 1905 due to the great reviews. We ordered an 18” Uncle Tony NY cheese pizza with no toppings. UNFORTUNATELY! this was one of the worst pizza’s we have tried in Florida. It was like it was under a heat lamp all day, which you can see in the picture. The cheese was hard, and when taking a bite, it turned out the cheese was not even attached to the pizza! The dough under the cheese was gluey. On top of that, it had zero flavor. Whole pizza went in the garbage! May as well have picked up a $5.00 Hot & Ready pizza from Little Caesars! Sorry to the owner this is FAR from New York Pizza, don’t bother replying!
Mr. Blake
The Pizza is bland. As a New Yorker we love pizza must be fresh must have seasoning and taste. The only reason I knew I didn’t have Covid was because I could taste the sprite. The staff was friendly but pizza… no go.
Angel Harwell
I LOVE this place!! The staff is so friendly and make you feel at home. I am from NY and half Italian and had no idea FL had authentic Italian. The pizza is great!! My new favorite place 🙂
Kim G
Quick service,I got the two slices and a water, with extra cheese. One of the few places that actually gave me extra cheese, so much it was all melted and yum. The slices were really huge, especially for the cheap price. The pizza was so good too.
… View more