Pizza is billed as “New Jersey-style” at this family-oriented parlor with subs, pastas & drinks. Based on 24 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
Address:
1448 Florida A1A, Satellite Beach, FL 32937
Phone: (321) 426-7069
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Spencer Sansouci
The waiter was very nice, and personal which made the overall experience very laid back, but he was still professional. The atmosphere made us as a family feel very comfortable, and not too high strung. The food was fantastic, especially the custom calzone that I ordered. I asked for it with chicken and spinach, and they had no problem making it taste superb. The mozzarella cheese paired with the ricotta was heavenly and to top it off, all smothered in olive oil with a browned crust made it number 1 on my list of best Italian foods I’ve ever eaten. That being said, this is one of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever been to, and I highly recommend it to anyone.
… more
Alex Wolfe
Not sure why this place is getting such good reviews. Got a large pizza and salad for take out. $28. Looked like a couple handfuls of cheese were just thrown on the pizza, not evenly spread, just a clump of cheese in the middle of the pizza. On top of that the pizza didn’t even taste good. The salad was also smothered in way too much dressing. The management was friendly though. I would give it 2 stars, but the inflated rating needs to be brought down.
… more
Keefer Zeller
We took a day trip to Melbourne and picked Pistilli’s to eat at. We were not disappointed. I had the baked spaghetti and my wife ahd the veal parm and they were both excellent! Our server was very polite and quick to get us anything we needed. Very Attentive. While the restaurant itself is not the best decorated or located(strip mall), I was very happy with them and if I am ever in the area again, I won’t hesitate to go there again! Awesome food!
… more
James Sutton
On the evening of 08-02-2012, my wife took our family to Pistilli’s Indian Harbor Beach restaurant. I did not go with them. She ordered baked ziti and a salad take-out for me and brought it home. I ate the salad and it was very good. When I opened the baked ziti I found that the cheese and pasta on the top was burned black and the ziti was inedible. The blackened cheese had been covered up with red sauce so that anyone looking in the box would not see the burned cheese. It was bad enough that their cook served burnt the food, but then he or she tried to cover it up so that no one would notice until my wife got the meal home. We live near this restaurant have been there several times and we always enjoyed our meals, but we are not likely to return if this kind of dishonesty is typical of their kitchen staff. Why would anyone trust them to maintain a sanitary kitchen.
… more
Judd Grover
Firstly, I was frustrated by the fact that it took over 7 minutes to place an order over the phone for delivery because the gentleman had a difficult time communicating on the phone. By the time, the order was placed I was already skeptical but, thought not much of it. Secondly, Despite being about 2 miles away and the gentleman saying that as there were no deliveries currently, it should be out to Me right away– it took them about 40-45 minutes which happened to leave me with less than ten minutes before my lunch hour was over and I had to continue working. Finally, I unwrap my “Godfather” sub and– it looks amazing. Key word: Looks. Upon further inspection it has a very thin single line of Prosciutto and about 80% of the sub was lettuce and bread. Maybe, I just caught them on an off day– or maybe, they just suck thoroughly on a consistent everyday basis. I don’t know. What I do know, is that first impressions are everything– and you guys blew it so hard that not only will I never do business with you again, I felt so strongly dissatisfied that I actually took time to write this scathing, negative review online. DO NOT EAT AT PISTILLI’S. I spent over ten dollars on one of their subs and it’s quality was so much worse than a 5 dollar sub at Subway. If you want a sub, go to one of the three subway’s conveniently located about 5 miles away in every possible direction (North, South and West.)
… more
alan z
EDIT: IM SO EXCITED! Pistilli’s is COMING BACK if not back already! Not sure of the location.
… more
Mark “Handsome Mark” Sarno
Its one of those places that the first time you go, youre not quite sure what to order. The server recommends a few things, all of which seem a little out of place for a local pizza parlor, but you go with something thats close to “generic” like spaghetti. Whatever you order, its excellent.
… more
jena techoueyres
Our take out Pizza was horrible. The cheese didn’t even cover 1/2 the pizza, way too much sauce, and basil. And the taste was just plain bad. We didn’t even eat it and made a sandwich for dinner.
… more
Jeff Clevenger
My wife and I ate here for lunch today and it was good! Both of us had the “Hoffa” Sub, which was delicious! Want to try the Grandma’s Antipasta soon!
… more
James Ward
Incredible Pizza and salad. Service is always great, fast and courteous. We’re in town 3 or 4 times a year and we always make time for this place.
… more
… View more