Based on 488 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
255 Riverside Dr, Tiffin, OH 44883
Phone: (419) 448-0100
Website: http://www.pioneermilloftiffin.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 1–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brent Johnson
Awesome steakhouse in a historic old mill over water. Excellent steaks, pastas were yummy and while we didn’t get to try, seafood is supposed to be pretty good. Cocktails were nice. The Moscow Mule was amazing. They do have a nice salad bar. This place has some cool history you can read on their website.
… more
V A Lew
I hopped in the car and headed east to find a place to eat. I started searching through Google and found this place, so glad I found it. This is a really cool historic building with a great background story. It wasn’t busy when we came in. It did take several minutes to get seated. Once we were seated, everything went well. The server was attentive. The menu was vast, even though they ran out of several items.The soup and salad bar was fresh with plenty of toppings for the salad. Both of enteess were really good. The twice baked potato was great. The baked potato was scorched. That was my only complaint for the evening.
… more
Paul Goodridge
Here training with Webster chain. Great food! Great people! Bartenders are awesome! Beautiful scenery! River running under the deck out back. Beautiful! Highly recommended!!!
… more
Angela Daugherty
We haven’t eaten at Pioneer Mill in years. A family member, from out of town, suggested it for dinner. I’m so glad that he did. We really enjoyed our delicious meals. I personally can recommend the steak au poivre. The filet medallions were so tender and flavorful. Plus the artichoke dip with bruschetta was very good. The service was fast and the staff was very friendly. I really enjoyed the atmosphere and the charm of the old building. We will definitely be enjoying more dinners there in the future.
… more
Brian Dible
I’ve ate at the Pioneer Mill in the past and from what I remember the food was good and the building was amazing. Just dropped by today coming back from Lake Erie and wanted to show my lady friend how cool the restaurant is. Was disappointed with the parking lot, there was a branch down and trash laying around. The outside looked like it could use a spruce up. Kinda feel that if the small things like that aren’t taken care of by the owners, how can food quality and service be good?
… more
Mike Holewinski
Valentines Dinner specials; Veal Parm Rosotto & Filet Mignon Oscar! Very good, in spite of being overwhelmed by holiday crowd.
… more
Jeff Lawrence
Real nice place with outstanding character! Beautiful old repurposed mill in Tiffin. Salad bar is very good, staff are nice and attentive. Lots of variety on the menu. My ribs were good.
… more
Lisa Elchert
Our server was great! I always love the atmosphere here. The food not much this time. The mill gravy on his food was too salty. My dish was swimming in sauce. The flavor was there, but I don’t like fishing in a bowl of sauce for my noodles.
… more
Malevolayntz
200 year old mill. Converted into a restaurant a long time ago. Could use a good dusting and an update. Peeling wallpaper, burnt out bulbs everywhere. Almost seems to add to the charm of the place! Decent prices, creative menu, and a PROPER salad bar! I look forward to checking out Tinks!
… more
Travis Crum
I’ve only been here 2 times. The food was great. Cheeseburger soup was awesome at the salad bar. Saladad bar was fresh. Great service. I would dine here again.
… more
… View more