Beyond a variety of pies, this homey cafe with red-checkered tablecloths offers a full Italian menu. Based on 264 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
811 S Pinellas Ave, Tarpon Springs, FL 34689
Phone: (727) 785-1400
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
maggie M
Very nice restaurant. They have great lunch deals. They don’t have soda refills, though, and only offer canned drinks. Their cannolis are probably the best I have had in the area.
… more
Mr. Boofman
Terrible service. My girlfriend ordered delivery and they gave us someone else’s pizza. When we called back the employee in the phone told us he would give our account a 1 topping pizza. When we came there the owner confronted us in a unprofessional way and said well what did you want? Im not giving you a free pizza. So he offered another order of meatballs to our order…not satisfied by the rude treatment we both said how we would not return.( she is a long time customer)Upon arriving home there was a hair wrapped in the meatball. Once again she called and he suggested it was our hair. Maybe this is the reason he went from a busy palm harbor location to a desolate strip mall in tarpon. As far as the hair im bald and my girlfriend has hair much longer than the one on the photo. Again it was wrapped in the meatball. I pulled it aside for visibility.
… more
Amy Thomas
The best NY style pizza around! We ordered tonight for delivery. It was so good i didn’t want to stop eating! We got a simple pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. It was so good I told my boyfriend this is our new pizza place. I recommend it to everyone!
… more
Liberty4All
The pizza was cooked perfectly. The crust was perfect and that is the most important factor in cooking a pizza in my opinion. The restaurant was clean when we visited, plus we received excellent service. It’s not on the busiest streets in town, so it has a nice large parking lot. I would definitely return in the future.
… more
Chris Stoneberg
Their food is excellent. I’ve had the pizza twice and a good friend had the meatballs and said they were awesome. Owner is a very nice guy. He came out from the kitchen and talk to me for 25 minutes. I would recommend this place to everyone.
… more
Anastasia Holt
I have to say.. with all the positive reviews I thought that I would walk out feeling happy about my experience but unfortunately that is not the case. I ordered a slice of pizza with pineapple and the pizza was old and dry with the pineapple placed it on without even being reheated. The calamari was basically just fried batter and when I asked for a side of ranch to go I was told that I had to pay .54 which is nothing but it’s the point that the manager had to have us take our money back out after we had already ordered just for that small cost. Unfortunately, I won’t be back.
… more
Bob Sfero
Yes, the pizza is good…but order the wings too. There is usually battle for the last leg/wing. We ordered them extra crispy, they were not dry, just delicious. The garlic knots are really good too
… more
Not Available
I had a sausage popper and the Chicago style pizza. The popper was odd. Bread dough stuffed with garlic, butter and meat with marina sauce on the side. It was cheap, less that a dollar (I think??) and tasted pretty good. The Chicago style pizza was a thin crust. I am from Chicago so I am always skeptical. This pizza did taste like Chicago thin crust. I did have a problem because it was cut in triangles. Chicago style should be squares. It affected my experience. I would recommend the pizza. Just re-cut it. 🙂
… more
Nick
The decor was a traditional new York style pizzeria. The service was pretty good besides the waitress did not introduce her self formerly the entire visit. Started off with a good portion good priced chicken ceasar with tasty dressing. Then decided on a 12 inch special pizza with extra cheese. First off there really wasn’t that much cheese. The cheese didn’t taste too great compared to other local places. The sauce was good nice zest to it. The crust was plain and not great at all. On a final note I found an eye lash in the cheese not cool but it happens. Didn’t bother to complain because they would probably think it was mine anyway. But honestly I think there is better pizza other places. It was my first time going and I might give them one more shot for a fair judgment on their establishment.
… more
Sarah Jaggar
Great Pizza! Crispy crust! Went here for Father’s Day and brought our 4 kids. We were very impressed. Sarah was our waitress and our 3 year old daughter really took to her. Sarah reciprocated and was very kind to our daughter who insisted on paying the bill. Thank you Pinocchio’s and thank you Sarah, for being so kind to our little one and befriending her.
… more
… View more